bri's Reviews > The Spear Cuts Through Water

The Spear Cuts Through Water by Simon Jimenez
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
74226493
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: owned, achillean, adult, books-that-made-me-cry, disability-rep, fantasy, favorites, high-fantasy, lgbtqia, poc-author, poc-mc

SOMEONE GET MIYAZAKI ON THE LINE IMMEDIATELY!!!

Do you ever read something so large, so impactful, that the work itself feels like a tsunami wave cresting over you? Its dazzling mass soaring above your head so that your vision is filled with nothing but its utter majesty, so that even the most blinding sunlight is fractured and scattered by its thick undulating form until everything is blue blue blue?

Well that’s how this book feels. Epic. Mythological. Tremendous. This is a work of art. This is a piece of theater wedged inside a novel. This is storytelling at its most profound.

This is a love story down to its blade-dented bone.

Our tale takes place in the Inverted Theater, a stage that exists between the planes of life, run by the love-child of the Moon and the Water, and upon which the greatest stories and greatest performances are portrayed. Mortals may attend this theater through their dreams and when they visit the theater, they will find themselves witness to the right story at the right time. But. They cannot choose the timing of their visit, and upon waking from their dream, the memories of their experience in the Inverted Theater will have dissolved into nothing but a vague feeling of satisfaction.

And as our main character finds himself in this liminal performance space, he witnesses the story of two boys transporting an ancient god across a broken land, determined to end the tyrannical rule of her descendants.

The story we then witness alongside our main character is unlike any other. Its cruelty is as haunting as its utter beauty. It’s romantic and tender and violent and ethereal. There’s something of a Ghibli quality to it, especially in the way it unravels itself as a gorgeous expression of love for people, land, culture, and the relationships between. I found myself listening to the Princess Mononoke soundtrack while reading it and fantasizing about the breathtaking adaptation Miyazaki would make if someone would do the honor of putting this book in his hands. (I HIGHLY recommend listening to the Mononoke soundtrack when reading this for a transcendent experience. I even more highly recommend telling Miyazaki to read this book.)

My overall experience with THE SPEAR CUTS THROUGH WATER was mystifying, like I myself was a dreaming visitor of the Inverted Theater, put in a trance and taken on a journey through a life-defining tale that would forever alter my world.

Thank you Simon Jimenez for reminding me why I love reading. For showing me what it can mean to thread myself into the tapestry of life and lose myself in the rhythm of the world.

As the tsunami of this story crested over my head and broke its way through my tear ducts and flooded down my cheeks, I knew–wracked with heavy sobs–that I would emerge from its depths to find myself forever changed. And for a moment, I was so certain I would find myself brought back to my own plane of existence to have lost the memory of this tale. That this story, like all others told in the Inverted Theater, would be one that only exists in the spaces it’s left behind. That its only relics would be the puddles of toilet paper tissues scattered on the floor of my room, the crowded rows of goosebumps like tiny headstones up and down my arms, and a hunk of negative space in my memory in the shape of something equally yearning and fulfilling. Oh, but how lucky we are, that Simon Jimenez has pressed the Inverted Theater onto paper so we may maintain its memory.

CW: violence, drowning, decapitation, blood & gore, body horror, death, grief, murder, cannibalism, war, animal death, ableism, drug use, emesis, death of grandmother, death of child, death of parent, suicide (mention)
122 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read The Spear Cuts Through Water.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 15, 2022 – Shelved
November 15, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
November 5, 2023 – Shelved as: owned
December 3, 2023 – Started Reading
December 3, 2023 –
page 10
1.9% "telling y’all right now: this is gonna be one of my favorite books of the year."
December 5, 2023 –
page 71
13.52% "this book is so whimsical and dreamlike and then every once in a while it smacks you with the most fucked up violent shit, made even worse because it’s still written in that same dreamlike style of prose"
December 5, 2023 –
page 100
19.05% "i’m enjoying this book but damn it is not reading itself"
December 8, 2023 –
page 144
27.43% "not Keema going through a queer crisis because of gay porn that he stole lmaooo"
December 9, 2023 –
page 173
32.95% "unreliable narrator???? wow this book just keeps throwing out more layers of narrative to peel apart"
December 9, 2023 –
page 184
35.05% "“The flower was cut from the stem. It’s red petals strewn.” OH MY GOD MORE VIOLENCE VIA METAPHOR IN BOOKS PLZ!!!"
December 9, 2023 –
page 234
44.57% "“You know as well as I that there are no odds in this world. There is only the Rhythm, and the Dance. That we are but the dancers.” so THIS is what The Killers meant when they asked if we were human or dancer"
December 10, 2023 –
page 281
53.52% "so far this book has been entirely in 2nd and 3rd person (except for some internal thoughts) and now we’re just fully switching to 1st person? this shit is wild"
December 11, 2023 –
page 334
63.62% "it just occurred to me that this book would make the BEST ghibli movie ever. someone get this in miyazaki’s hands literally immediately because oh my god. I just know it would be world-shifting"
December 11, 2023 –
page 359
68.38% "y’all this book has used 3rd person POV, 2nd person POV, added 1st person POV around page 200 and now we’re adding 4th person POV???"
December 11, 2023 –
page 367
69.9% "“This bath had become a performance, with an audience of one. It was an audience he was glad to perform for.” YOU GUYS THE SLOW BURN IS SLOW BURNING AND OH MY GOD THIS LINE IN CONTEXT IS INSAAAAAAANE"
December 11, 2023 –
page 392
74.67% "it’s honestly a feeling unlike any other to get to almost 400 pages in a 500+ page book and realize, with reluctance and sadness, that it’s coming to a close"
December 11, 2023 –
page 398
75.81% "y’all. I have actual goosebumps. that only happens when I see live theater. not when I read books."
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: fantasy
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: disability-rep
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: books-that-made-me-cry
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: adult
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: achillean
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: poc-mc
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: poc-author
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: lgbtqia
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: high-fantasy
December 12, 2023 – Shelved as: favorites
December 12, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

liv ❁ oh my god i would DIE if this was adapted as a miyazaki film


message 2: by bri (new) - rated it 5 stars

bri Liv ❁ wrote: "oh my god i would DIE if this was adapted as a miyazaki film"

i'm truly convinced this book exists to become a miyazaki film


message 3: by marine ♡ (new) - added it

marine ♡ take my money, my time, my life, this looks to good


message 4: by alofa (new) - added it

alofa someone call this man out of retirement 😭


message 5: by bri (new) - rated it 5 stars

bri alofa wrote: "someone call this man out of retirement 😭"

he keeps saying he's retiring but this man just made the boy and the heron lmao


message 6: by Nelson (new)

Nelson Alright youve sold me on reading it next


message 7: by bri (new) - rated it 5 stars

bri Nelson wrote: "Alright youve sold me on reading it next"

I really hope you enjoy it as much as I did :)


Rachel omg yes i was trying to figure out what this felt like and MIYAZAKI is exactly hitting the nail on the head!!!
would love to see this created into a film!


back to top