3.5 étoiles (3/10 cœurs). Au début, j'aimais beaucoup ce livre et j'aurais aimé lui donner une note plus élevée, mais j'ai trouvé la fin quelque peu d3.5 étoiles (3/10 cœurs). Au début, j'aimais beaucoup ce livre et j'aurais aimé lui donner une note plus élevée, mais j'ai trouvé la fin quelque peu décevante. J'ai bien aimé les personnages. Alex et Caroline étaient tous deux des jeunes sympas et avaient de bonnes personnalités. J'aimais beaucoup Martine aussi, et Manouche était tout simplement pathétiquement mignon ; les parents étaient gentils. Presque tout les autres je n’ai pas trop aimé. Je ne détestais pas Elisabeth mais elle était attristante ; les méchants étaient, eh bien, méchants ; et je n’ai pas aimé non plus le détective (qui a littéralement tabassé le professeur d’art ?? pourquoi, je n’en ai aucune idée ???). Mais j’aimais bien le pauvre vieil oncle…
Et cela nous amène au décor. J’ai choisi ce livre délibérément parce qu’il se déroule à Montréal mais PAS en Nouvelle-France (comme c’est unique !). J'aime aussi le pont J.C. et, bien sûr, ayant grandi à Montréal pendant un certain temps, j'étais curieux d'en savoir plus sur la ville d'un point de vue contemporain et non historique. J'ai découvert plus tard que les personnages principaux étaient originaires de St-Jean-sur-Richelieu, près de chez moi maintenant, donc un lien supplémentaire intéressant pour moi !
J'ai aussi choisi ce livre car il promettait du mystère et du suspense, qui a été bien livré. J'étais assez perplexe et extrêmement intrigué tout au long de l’histoire. Le style d’écriture était plus simple et clair que celui auquel je suis habitué dans les livres français, ce que j’ai apprécié, mais j’ai trouvé qu’il manquait parfois de clarté. Il y avait beaucoup de va-et-vient sur la chronologie, ce qui était acceptable si les choses étaient claires, mais déroutant sinon ; certaines choses étaient très mal et brièvement expliquées tandis que d'autres étaient récapitulées à maintes reprises ; les conclusions des personnages sur le mystère étaient parfois assez soudaines (comme Caroline insistant sur le fait que le frère était l'homme qui avait tenté de l'écraser, alors qu'elle le voyait à peine) ; et finalement, toute l'aventure s'est soudainement arrêtée à la fin et tout s'est terminé avec le détective expliquant tout le dénouement que nous n'avons pas eu l'occasion de voir ! Il a également expliqué les différents aspects du mystère et j'ai trouvé cela très insatisfaisant ; peu de mes questions ont reçu une réponse et celles qui l’étaient n’ont pas été expliquées suffisamment clairement ou suffisamment profondément.
Il s'avère qu'il s'agit du tome 3 d'une série (pourquoi cela n'est pas noté sur la couverture, je ne sais pas) et certains éléments ont été référencés dans les tomes 1 et 2, mais seulement quelques-uns, donc cela peut certainement être lu comme un livre autonome. Et malgré ma déception à la fin, j’ai suffisamment apprécié l’histoire pour aller chercher les tomes précédents. Aussi, j’ai apprécié la façon positive dont la police était présentée.
Dans l’ensemble, c’est un mystère approprié, passionnant et entièrement québécois.
————
3.5 stars (3/10 hearts). I started out quite liking this book, and would have liked to give it a higher rating, but I found the ending somewhat disappointing. I quite liked the characters. Alex & Caroline were both nice kids and had good personalities. I really liked Martine, too, and Manouche was just pathetically cute somehow, the parents were nice. Pretty much everyone else was not my favourite. I didn’t hate Elisabeth but she was saddening; the bad guys were, well, bad; I didn’t like either the detective (who literally beat up the art professor?? why, I have no idea???). I did really like the poor old uncle, though…
And that leads us to the setting. I picked up this book purposefully because it’s set in Montréal but NOT during New France (how unique!). I also love the J.C. bridge, and of course being raised in Montréal for a time, I was curious to read about the city from a contemporary and not historical perspective. I later discovered the main characters are from St.-Jean-sur-Richelieu, near where I now live, so an additional interesting link for me!
I also picked up this book because it promised mystery and suspense, which was well delivered. I was quite puzzled and hugely intrigued the whole book through. The writing style was more simple and clear than I’m used to in French books, which I appreciated, but I did find that it was lacking sometimes in clarity. There was a lot of hopping back and forth on the timeline, which was okay if things were clear, but confusing otherwise; some things were very poorly and briefly explained while others were recapped over and over; characters’ conclusions about the mystery were sometimes rather sudden (like Caroline insisting the clergyman was the guy who tried to run her over, when she barely saw him); and finally, the whole adventure was suddenly drooped at the end and it all wound up with the detective explaining the whole dénouement that we didn’t get to see! He also explained the various aspects of the mystery and I found it very unsatisfying; few of my questions were answered and those that were, weren’t explained clearly or deeply enough.
It turns out that this is book 3 in a series (why that isn’t noted on the cover, I don’t know) and some stuff was referenced from books 1-2, but only a handful, so this can definitely be read as a standalone. And despite my disappointment at the end, I enjoyed the story enough that I’m checking out the previous books. Also, I appreciated the positive way in which the police was presented.
Overall, it’s a clean, exciting mystery, and fully Québécois....more
5 stars & 5/10 hearts. I’ve been eagerly awaiting this book since the author began it, as a short story, some years back. The book is, of course, diff5 stars & 5/10 hearts. I’ve been eagerly awaiting this book since the author began it, as a short story, some years back. The book is, of course, different, yet it carried out the promise it had so long ago!
As kingdom fiction, the worldbuilding was fantastic. Elira was a well-built medieval land, with some history hinted at and surrounded by an interesting country. I did have a bit of a struggle at the portrayal of the setting—the fear, the uncertainty, everyone paralyzed and struggling to survive. It was highly reminiscent of the pandemic times and spiked my anxiety. “She didn’t disagree with the sentiments her neighbors raised, for the most part, but she did hate the feeling of existential dread and overwhelming heaviness that weighed her down after hearing them.” That sums up my feelings during 2020-2021 and for part of this book. However, I appreciated how the writing style and dialogue was done—while not particularly old-fashioned, it was not modern either, and had an interesting flavour that complimented the book well. I loved the symbolism of the forest and how recurrent it was!
I liked the characters. Violet was a sweet, hardworking girl who earned my respect and sympathy at once. I related a lot to her anxiety and worry, as well as her desire to do the right thing mixed with her struggle to defy authority/place herself within the limits of punishment. Obed was an interesting fellow. I guessed his real identity, but I enjoyed seeing him in his amnesic identity. He was a good, kind man and I liked his interactions with Violet & Granny and the little boy. Marcus was fascinating and I loved him, Frendel was so nice, Everard I LOVED and wanted more of, Malcom was epic, the villain was terrible, and Granny was sweet.
The plot was quite interesting. I really had no idea where it would go and was pleasantly surprised by each new development. I appreciated the addition of Granny’s dementia, and I’ve always been intrigued by stories about amnesia, so that part was fun too. The author did an excellent job of raising the stakes yet keeping things clean. While I feared the Kingsmen, I also knew that nothing untoward would happen and my trust was confirmed. The romance was sweet and slow-burn, focussed on character and quite selfless, and I loved how low-key yet strong it was. I don’t want to say too much and spoil anything, but I loved the ending and how everything wrapped up! I’m afraid I am very vague about the plot but it is very difficult to talk of without quite a few spoilers.
What I appreciated most of the book is the theme & messages. The reminder to stand up and do the right thing even if it’s dangerous and no one will help, or it will cost us our dearest possessions. The reminder that the past is wiped away and we are made new in Christ, with a purpose He can carry out in us despite our feelings of worthlessness. The reminder that no matter what happens, God triumphs and evil cannot win.
Overall, although parts of the book did make me rather heavy and anxious, I found it a sweet, heartwarming, encouraging tale, not spectacular, but pleasant and wholesome—rather like a slice of warm, homemade bread and butter. I look forwards to the next book in the series!
Content: The one thing I was bothered by was the frequent use of “hell” as a description—“he fought like hell”; he wanted to “bring down hell” on Violet’s antagonists; they lived a “hellish moment”; after being burned, her back was “didn’t burn with hell fire”; when Violet is brought through a room of kinsmen she says “if the room burned as hot as her soul did, then they would all burn in hellfire.” The other four instances of “hell” I didn’t mind—mention that “all hell will break loose;” mention that Elira was “a living hell;” Violet prays for her Granny and says “I don’t know what hell exists for her on earth;” and during a fire, “everything around her threatening to give her a taste of the hell she had been promised to avoid with the death of her Savior.” I felt that the constant use of “hell” brought down the force that the word actually had and bordered on using the word in vain. Other content includes non-graphic violence; several mentions that Elgon carried on affairs with many women in his past (one mention of a woman siting on his lap, them touching, then leaning in for a kiss, and a mention that women wore ‘lewd, revealing dresses’); and several instances where Violet is threatened with r*pe but never in anything more than words; also a hint that another girl may have been violated by kingsmen. Recommended ages: 16-18+, depending.
A Favourite Quote: “We need to remember, that He does have it all in control. He knows when the breaking point is, not us. We have to realize that, while we are weak and want all of this to be over, He knows every single piece of the puzzle and the perfect timing for it all to fit together. There is good left in this world, Violet. We can’t expect Him to destroy every last inch of it just to rescue us. This isn’t the first time in history that His people have been cut down and destroyed. Remember Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego? They were thrown into a fiery furnace. He rescued them. Will He not do the same for us?” … “The furnace feels mighty hot right now.” […] “But He’s right here with us in the fire. Don’t you see Him?” A Favourite Beautiful Quote: She stopped short, her eyes running along the length of the forest. Shadows crept at the edges, their blackness encroaching but being forced back by the smattering of light that shone through the sparser leaves on the edge of the forest. Its denseness made it dark, ominous...overpowering. She longed for the happy forest whose greenness had beckoned to her as a child, its playful light, color, and patterns soothing her soul, encouraging her imagination, and filling her with life. A Favourite Humorous Quote: “You are supposed to be dead.” Malcolm repeated, a touch of panic in his voice, emphasizing the word “supposed.” Elgon grunted. “Clearly, I’m not.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*
Merged review:
5 stars & 5/10 hearts. I’ve been eagerly awaiting this book since the author began it, as a short story, some years back. The book is, of course, different, yet it carried out the promise it had so long ago!
As kingdom fiction, the worldbuilding was fantastic. Elira was a well-built medieval land, with some history hinted at and surrounded by an interesting country. I did have a bit of a struggle at the portrayal of the setting—the fear, the uncertainty, everyone paralyzed and struggling to survive. It was highly reminiscent of the pandemic times and spiked my anxiety. “She didn’t disagree with the sentiments her neighbors raised, for the most part, but she did hate the feeling of existential dread and overwhelming heaviness that weighed her down after hearing them.” That sums up my feelings during 2020-2021 and for part of this book. However, I appreciated how the writing style and dialogue was done—while not particularly old-fashioned, it was not modern either, and had an interesting flavour that complimented the book well. I loved the symbolism of the forest and how recurrent it was!
I liked the characters. Violet was a sweet, hardworking girl who earned my respect and sympathy at once. I related a lot to her anxiety and worry, as well as her desire to do the right thing mixed with her struggle to defy authority/place herself within the limits of punishment. Obed was an interesting fellow. I guessed his real identity, but I enjoyed seeing him in his amnesic identity. He was a good, kind man and I liked his interactions with Violet & Granny and the little boy. Marcus was fascinating and I loved him, Frendel was so nice, Everard I LOVED and wanted more of, Malcom was epic, the villain was terrible, and Granny was sweet.
The plot was quite interesting. I really had no idea where it would go and was pleasantly surprised by each new development. I appreciated the addition of Granny’s dementia, and I’ve always been intrigued by stories about amnesia, so that part was fun too. The author did an excellent job of raising the stakes yet keeping things clean. While I feared the Kingsmen, I also knew that nothing untoward would happen and my trust was confirmed. The romance was sweet and slow-burn, focussed on character and quite selfless, and I loved how low-key yet strong it was. I don’t want to say too much and spoil anything, but I loved the ending and how everything wrapped up! I’m afraid I am very vague about the plot but it is very difficult to talk of without quite a few spoilers.
What I appreciated most of the book is the theme & messages. The reminder to stand up and do the right thing even if it’s dangerous and no one will help, or it will cost us our dearest possessions. The reminder that the past is wiped away and we are made new in Christ, with a purpose He can carry out in us despite our feelings of worthlessness. The reminder that no matter what happens, God triumphs and evil cannot win.
Overall, although parts of the book did make me rather heavy and anxious, I found it a sweet, heartwarming, encouraging tale, not spectacular, but pleasant and wholesome—rather like a slice of warm, homemade bread and butter. I look forwards to the next book in the series!
Content: The one thing I was bothered by was the frequent use of “hell” as a description—“he fought like hell”; he wanted to “bring down hell” on Violet’s antagonists; they lived a “hellish moment”; after being burned, her back was “didn’t burn with hell fire”; when Violet is brought through a room of kinsmen she says “if the room burned as hot as her soul did, then they would all burn in hellfire.” The other four instances of “hell” I didn’t mind—mention that “all hell will break loose;” mention that Elira was “a living hell;” Violet prays for her Granny and says “I don’t know what hell exists for her on earth;” and during a fire, “everything around her threatening to give her a taste of the hell she had been promised to avoid with the death of her Savior.” I felt that the constant use of “hell” brought down the force that the word actually had and bordered on using the word in vain. Other content includes non-graphic violence; several mentions that Elgon carried on affairs with many women in his past (one mention of a woman siting on his lap, them touching, then leaning in for a kiss, and a mention that women wore ‘lewd, revealing dresses’); and several instances where Violet is threatened with r*pe but never in anything more than words; also a hint that another girl may have been violated by kingsmen. Recommended ages: 16-18+, depending.
A Favourite Quote: “We need to remember, that He does have it all in control. He knows when the breaking point is, not us. We have to realize that, while we are weak and want all of this to be over, He knows every single piece of the puzzle and the perfect timing for it all to fit together. There is good left in this world, Violet. We can’t expect Him to destroy every last inch of it just to rescue us. This isn’t the first time in history that His people have been cut down and destroyed. Remember Shadrach, Meshach, and Abednego? They were thrown into a fiery furnace. He rescued them. Will He not do the same for us?” … “The furnace feels mighty hot right now.” […] “But He’s right here with us in the fire. Don’t you see Him?” A Favourite Beautiful Quote: She stopped short, her eyes running along the length of the forest. Shadows crept at the edges, their blackness encroaching but being forced back by the smattering of light that shone through the sparser leaves on the edge of the forest. Its denseness made it dark, ominous...overpowering. She longed for the happy forest whose greenness had beckoned to her as a child, its playful light, color, and patterns soothing her soul, encouraging her imagination, and filling her with life. A Favourite Humorous Quote: “You are supposed to be dead.” Malcolm repeated, a touch of panic in his voice, emphasizing the word “supposed.” Elgon grunted. “Clearly, I’m not.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4 étoiles. Je n'ai pas beaucoup aimé les livres #1-2 (en particulier tome 1) mais j'ai apprécié les personnages et je voulais donner une autre chance 4 étoiles. Je n'ai pas beaucoup aimé les livres #1-2 (en particulier tome 1) mais j'ai apprécié les personnages et je voulais donner une autre chance à la série, notamment parce que j'aimais livre #3 assez bien.
Je pense que celui-ci était le meilleur de la série jusqu'à présent. Jeanne ne s'est pas mise en danger, a écouté et obéi aux adultes, et n'a pas fait de détective seule, en plus d'être consciente des dangers d'accuser les gens et de divulguer des informations sans suffisamment de connaissances… donc je pouvais réellement l’apprécier ! Les autres personnages étaient très bien eux-mêmes… et j’ai aimé les professeures plus que je m’y attendais, notamment Mme M. C’était intéressant de rencontrer Sonia Delaunay, que je ne connaissais pas non plus.
En ce qui concerne l'intrigue, j'adore la partie empoisonnement du mystère ((view spoiler)[surtout la partie arsenic (hide spoiler)]) et l'aspect contrefaçon. J’ai également beaucoup apprécié le travail des femmes auprès des mères célibataires (même si je m’oppose à l’idée que la grossesse est toujours uniquement la faute du père) et leur résistance à la négligence et aux abus de la société envers ces filles et leurs bébés. C'était aussi amusant de voir certains personnages des œuvres précédentes de la série ! Mais j’étais vraiment ennuyé de revoir ces incompétents tyrans des policiers.
Dans l'ensemble, j'attends avec impatience une conclusion satisfaisante dans le tome 5 (et peut-être même un soupçon de romance ????)
———————
4 stars. I did not like books 1-2 very much (specifically book 1) but I did enjoy the characters and wanted to give the series another chance, specifically because I liked book 3 well enough.
I think this one was the best of the series so far. Jeanne didn’t cram herself into danger, listened & obeyed the adults, and didn’t do hardly any sleuthing on her own, besides being aware of the dangers of accusing people and giving away information without enough knowledge… so I could actually appreciate her! The other characters were very nicely themselves… and I liked the teachers more than I expected, specially Mme M. It was interesting to meet Sonia Delaunay, whom I didn’t know about, too.
As far as the plot was concerned, I love the poisoning part of the mystery ((view spoiler)[especially the arsenic part (hide spoiler)]) and the counterfeiting aspect. I also really appreciated the ladies’ work among unmarried mothers (though I object to the idea that the pregnancy is always only the father’s fault) and their standing up to society’s neglect and abuse to those girls and their babies. It was also fun to see some characters from the earlier works in the series! I was really annoyed at seeing those incompetent bullies of policemen again though.
Overall, I look forwards to a satisfying conclusion in book 5 (and maybe even a hint of romance????)...more
3,5 étoiles (3/10 cœurs). C'est le premier livre de Jeanne Loiseau que j’ai lu, et même si je n'en étais pas fou, j'étais suffisamment intéressé pour 3,5 étoiles (3/10 cœurs). C'est le premier livre de Jeanne Loiseau que j’ai lu, et même si je n'en étais pas fou, j'étais suffisamment intéressé pour découvrir les livres précédents de la série. Il y avait un mélange assez équilibré des choses que j’aimais et que je n’aimais pas.
Donc, tout d’abord, j’étais très confus quant à ce qui se passait avec la bande d’enfants orphelins qui erraient dans les catacombes. C'est de ma faute – cette série ne se lit pas bien hors d’ordre, pour votre information. Je n’étais pas non plus un grand fan de Jeanne qui rompu sa promesse et désobéis à son père, même si les circonstances étaient quelque peu atténuantes. Mais j'ai apprécié le fait qu'elle lui réponde honnêtement et immédiatement lorsqu'il l'interrogeait ainsi que les bonnes relations qu'elle entretenait avec lui et ses frères et sœurs.
Je n’étais pas non plus fan de la façon dont la police était traitée ; ni comment Agatha Christie a été présentée, même si c'est en fait la raison pour laquelle j'ai choisi le livre. J’étais très frustrée par son basculement constant entre le français et l’anglais (en tant que bilingue, je peux vous dire que ça ne se fait pas comme ça dans la vraie vie) ; et elle semblait parfois plutôt volatile, ce que je pense n’est pas tout à fait exact. J’ai cependant assez aimé le mystère, et j’ai vraiment aimé la manière dont le trouble de la parole de Marguerite était traité et la façon dont l’auteur discutait de ses nombreuses causes et conséquences. Et j'ai aimé découvrir Paris !
Je ne me souviens de rien d'autre, mais après avoir lu les tomes 1 et 2 depuis, j'espère que cette série continuera de s'améliorer au fur et à mesure qu'elle continue et je vais essayer le tome 4.
Contenu : une phrase où Jeanne et Marguerite disent quelques choses vulgaires sur ses tyrans d’école.
————
3.5 stars (3/10 hearts). This was the first Jeanne Loiseau book I read, and while I wasn’t crazy about it I was interested enough to check out the earlier books in the series. There was a pretty even mixture of likes and dislikes.
So, first off, I was very confused as to what was going on with the catacomb-roving thieving band of orphan children. That’s on me—this series doesn’t read well out of order, for your information. I also wasn’t a huge fan of Jeanne braking her promise and disobeying her father even if circumstances were somewhat alleviating. But I did like that she answered him honestly and at once when he questioned her and the good relationship she had with him and her siblings.
I was also not a fan of how the police was treated; nor how Agatha Christie was presented, though she was actually why I picked up the book. I was very frustrated by her constant switch between French and English (as a bilingual, I can tell you it’s not done like that in real life); and she came across as rather flighty sometimes, which I don’t think is quite accurate. I liked the mystery well enough though, and I really liked how Marguerite’s speech impediment was worked in, and how the author discussed its numerous causes and consequences. And I enjoyed learning about Paris!
I remember nothing else, but having since read books 1 & 2, I hope this series keeps improving as it continues and I’m gonna give book 4 a shot.
Content: a sentence where Jeanne and Marguerite say a few vulgar things about her bullies....more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). I can’t wait until the whole series is done and I can reread it all. After the growing crisis in book 2, the war is finally ex5+ stars (6/10 hearts). I can’t wait until the whole series is done and I can reread it all. After the growing crisis in book 2, the war is finally exploding…
We’re back to the coastland for this adventure, and our old characters have returned! While the book mostly focusses on Vladic and Naturo, Marcus and the others show up, along with a couple of their wives. I quite liked Vladic. He reminded me of some of the other guys, but was still his own person. Mostly, though, I loved Elmery! Her bookish feels were EPIC and while usually I’m not a fan of enemies-to-lovers, Vladic and Elmery pulled it off PERFECTLY. I also really liked Myranthe, who was super sweet and big-sisterish… her storyline was great. And Naturo was a nice fellow. I loved Esmarie and her little friends, too, and the parents were all wonderful. And the villains, as usual, were delightfully hateful.
As always, I enjoyed the sweet, bantery romance and the sarcastic humour, as well as the complex, drawn-out plot. I’m slow at putting together puzzle pieces so I think I’m missing a few things from the big picture, but I like seeing the little bits of the conflict fitting in. The suspense and the excitement are high, and I love the message of trust and surrender—and the pro-life addition. It’s a great addition to the series and I eagerly anticipate book 4! I really hope Marcus’ story is done soon, and I’d love to see Maclean’s too. ;)
A Favourite Quote: Perhaps courage could grow from fear. Perhaps one needn’t be terribly courageous to face their fear. A Favourite Beautiful Quote: “So you like horses, then?” “Oh, yes.” She loved the animals. Beautiful and regal, they looked like wind in physical form. A Favourite Humorous Quote: “Do you need me to go to whatever meeting you’ll be having with the nobles?” “No, thank you. The last thing I need is you managing to personally insult every single one of them.” Vladic smirked. “I’ll stand guard outside, then. Just holler or hoot like an owl, and I’ll come in.” “Your offer is appreciated, but I’ll pass. Your capability of remaining silent when you hear something you dislike is measly at best. There is something you can do for me, though…. Bring Miss Nemorio here.” “Why can’t you just send a maid for her?” “Because you’re here and why waste a maid’s time?” Despite the unease swarming about his gut, Naturo smiled and leaned his elbows on his desk. “If you really want to help me, go get Miss Nemorio. It will take two minutes of your time—not long enough for you to experience an unfortunate death.” “Miss Nemorio wouldn’t think it so unfortunate.” “Then inform her it will have to wait until I’m finished with you. That buys you a month or so, at least.” Vladic scowled. “You’re so funny. Haha. Fine, I’m going, but if I sustain injury in any way—emotional, mental, or physical—then I’m holding you personally responsible.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
5 stars. I read this as a serial on the blog (https://chronicwarriorchronicles.subs...) and boy, it was way more of a wild ride than the four other ep5 stars. I read this as a serial on the blog (https://chronicwarriorchronicles.subs...) and boy, it was way more of a wild ride than the four other episodes of this season one! To start off, there’s division among the group: Rachelle is understandably upset, Brady has to choose between the guilt of betraying either one of the girls, and Dash is furious. Tensions are high, and the clock is ticking…
Let me tell you, my emotions were everywhere… but the ending was SO satisfactory and worth it all!! I’m so happy to hear more of Harper’s backstory and I look forward to huge strides in the group’s relationships in Season 2! And finally, the message is absolutely amazing. <3...more
4 stars. I was first interested in this book by the author, because I quite enjoyed her debut; and secondly by the information that the story included4 stars. I was first interested in this book by the author, because I quite enjoyed her debut; and secondly by the information that the story included a colourblind character. I was not disappointed, either.
Ethan was very well done. I was impressed by the obvious research the author did and how well she wrote out his monochromatic vision. And it fit into the message and the story (and title!) SO well! I appreciated the good family relationships, and Sophie was such a good friend.
The plot was very simple—just a kid moving from the country to the city, adjusting to a new school, dealing with bullying and homesickness, struggling with his creativity and self-doubt—but it was relatable, even for an adult. The message was great, and the whole thing was just a really well done middle-grade novel I wholeheartedly recommend.
A Favourite Quote: “But no one understands. They all laugh.” “Then make them understand. Maybe the only way to make people understand is to show them the world you see. Not how it looks through your eyes, but how you see it, how everything around you makes you feel, show them all that you can't explain.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
5 stars. To be honest I did not remember where we left off, so I was kinda launched into things trying to remember what was up. That made things a bit5 stars. To be honest I did not remember where we left off, so I was kinda launched into things trying to remember what was up. That made things a bit odd at first. ;P Of course I adoreddddd the banter and love between the friends (or frenemies, in Dash+Brady’s case—I love that plot line). And sweet, sweet little Gracie + Brady… ❤️ Car’s “alarm” was terrifying but I loved seeing everyone rally and show their best when they were at their worst. Of course Rachelle was AMAZING and so was Brady, and I LOVE DeANDRE, and I’m so happy with how this episode went!!! Also hearing more backstory was epic and Rachelle’s story was so well done and heart-tugging… ...more
4 stars. This is more of a slow-paced, slice-of-life type of story, a good place to rest after high-stakes read. I related to Libby in many places. Al4 stars. This is more of a slow-paced, slice-of-life type of story, a good place to rest after high-stakes read. I related to Libby in many places. Although I don’t have chronic illness I do have chronic health issues… and her spiritual struggles were parallel with mine right now. Amanda was a fantastic friend, and Magda was the sweetest. She reminded me of all my Swiss friends in church! <3 Her backstory was amazing, too (love seeing WWII from a German POV). And Kate was lovely.
The plot was slow to start, as I mentioned, and I struggled a bit until about the 50% mark. Somehow I didn’t connect with the writing style. But I got invested once Libby’s life started crashing downhill… it was to a point I finally thought “what’s left to go wrong?” But I’m glad I pushed through (like Libby) because there was a great message to wrap up—after the lowest points, God always shows up. Just hang in there and seek Him. <3 something I’ve been reminded in my life lately but need to hear more of. ;)
I already mentioned the spiritual aspect a bit but I really like the messages of choosing joy, and most of all of how to really make Jesus a best friend. Again, I needed it. I almost cried at several bits, actually.
I look forwards to book 2. :)
A Favourite Quote: “I told God my struggles yesterday and gave those to Him, but I don’t think that’s good enough. God wants me to tell Him everything and make Him part of all I experience. The happy times and the sad ones. What kind of a friend would I be if I never spent time with Him unless I was in trouble? We get to walk through it all together, whatever happens.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
**Featured on the historic fiction podcast The Gibson Girl Review! Listen as my cohost Amy Drown & I discuss this novel at https://www.gibsongirlrevie**Featured on the historic fiction podcast The Gibson Girl Review! Listen as my cohost Amy Drown & I discuss this novel at https://www.gibsongirlreview.com/seas...
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). Silver Sandals is the story of Thornley Colton, a blind amateur detective in NYC. It opens in a crowded hotel restaurant, where a man and a woman walk in and request a table. The woman leaves soon after, and then it is discovered the man has been dead for hours… and so begins a very complex tale.
This novel was apparently written after a bunch of short stories that are referenced throughout the book and which I really want to read. It also starts with a prologue defending the author’s choice to have a blind detective, citing all sorts of evidence including a blind surgeon who was very active in NYC. Apparently Stagg also interviewed and researched with Helen Keller and the Association for the Blind for this novel. Absolutely fascinating information.
I really enjoyed the writing style here—unique and strong and vivid, and setting the atmosphere so well. There were times when it was a bit weak—the mystery was super complex, even a bit too much at times, and it was so hard to piece together all the clues, even if they were given, because they didn’t make sense or fit together. And the action scenes were a bit muddy sometimes—so much going on you have trouble keeping up. But those quibbles aside, I thoroughly appreciated the mystery and it definitely kept me hooked. As a Sherlock Holmes nerd, I definitely had strong Sherlock feels from this, especially in how Colton found his clues, got information, and kept everything to himself.
And speaking of the characters, as a huge fan of vintage mysteries, the first thing that stood out to me is how they’re old tropes stood on their heads. You’ve got the brilliant detective in the prime of health–who’s blind. You’ve got the devoted assistant… who ends up not being able to help much in the end. You have the beautiful girl… who’s not a love interest. You’ve got the wild young man who turns out to be not as as he seems. Every time I thought I knew a character and what they’d do and be, they surprised me. Over and over again! That’s what made it so hard to pick out the suspect, because everything kept twisting and changing radically. I think the girl actually surprised me the most, because her story is just SO complex and interesting. And as for REVLIS SLADNAS, the victim… he just kept pulling punches until you didn’t know if he was dead or alive, good or bad… a most unusual victim. The only character who stayed the same throughout was McMann, the bulldog policeman… and even he surprised me at the end when I had to grudgingly admire him. And finally, the actual bad guy/killer–I still have to wrap my head around that, because it is SO unexpected.
I know I stated above that the story was a bit too complex at times, but for the most part it was well done, and I loved the complexity. The victim was an archaeologist who was obsessed with Ancient Egypt and his death is steeped in Egyptian mythology, but the story takes place in bustling, modern New York. There are just so many layers and so many DIFFERENT layers going on at the same time. The author really builds his mystery into a full novel–it’s not just a mystery, it’s a real story. And another fascinating thing about this book is how much primary source info it holds about the early 1900s, from things like unaccompanied women not being allowed into restaurants, to the Egyptomania common at the time (long before King Tutu’s tomb was unveiled).
All in all, it’s a fascinating mystery, a fascinating bit of historic fiction, and a fascinating glimpse into the world of the blind in the 1900s. I look forwards to reading this again and reading more by the author!...more
5 stars. We already know I adore this series and the characters. Of course I loved this book. Very much.
A Man & a Brother (previously published i5 stars. We already know I adore this series and the characters. Of course I loved this book. Very much.
A Man & a Brother (previously published in Hope) Ahh, another lovely addition to the Quiet Valor books! This one comes right after “A Threat & a Promise” and it was delightful. Inger was a wonderful woman; and I liked Althur; and I enjoyed seeing Eben & Rolfe! ;) ;) And there was such a lovely message too. <3
“Hold to your petty defiance if you will, and give up everything you claim to love. Althur and I choose hope—the hope Kord held to—the hope that sees beyond what is to what might be, if we don’t lose heart.
Blenwyn This bit of story, set during Jaelyn’s marriage, just about made me cry. Blenwyn is amazing. And the message is so good… especially to a MCK. <3
“You can’t leave her behind, my darling girl. She shines in your face and speaks in your voice and lingers in the touch of your hand. If your children never speak a word of Corwysh, they’ll still carry her heritage. And if you hold her in your heart, you can’t lose her, no matter where you go.”
Jaelyn OH MY HEART I loved this so so much. A soldier’s orphan? Struggling to care for him and his sick mother? Bring in all the victorian feels. And Jaelyn standing up for him. YES, YES, YES. It’s so sweet and heart-tugging. <33
My husband had been one of that reviled horde mere months ago, and I knew well how warm a heart could beat beneath a gruff mask and an imposing black uniform.
Inger Now we’re getting to the people I don’t know—yet. I can’t wait. This little story about war and PTSD and the cost of freedom is poignant. It’s so tiny but so good.
EDIT: I just realized I do, in fact, know Inger and Althur. ...more
5 stars. This serial is kinda addicting, not gonna lie. I’m loving how they build on each other!
As a huge people-pleaser, I identified deeply with Bra5 stars. This serial is kinda addicting, not gonna lie. I’m loving how they build on each other!
As a huge people-pleaser, I identified deeply with Brady. His mini lesson about choosing to do what God called him to do despite Dash’s grumpiness, and trust Him with making things work, really touched me.
I enjoyed seeing everyone working together, and Car giving him the pep talks he needed, and Harper smoothing everything down, and Brady learning to trust himself. And most of all I loved seeing Dash’s real self emerge. 3 That little line about him and his heart was amazing.
I can’t wait for the next episode. <3
A Favourite Quote: Was this really the surrender he had promised? Ignoring the work God had put in front of him to do exactly what he’d chosen for himself instead? Of course if Rachelle asked for help, that would be a different thing—a real need he could fill, not a convenient excuse to hide from bad timing and uncertain consequences. And if God was in control as always, then was the timing truly bad? Suppose God had picked this day because of something going on in the city that he could help and Dash couldn’t? Was he willing to turn his back on that for the sake of Dash’s ego and his own comfort? A Favourite Humorous Quote: “I’m sorry. I was out of line—shouldn’t have gone off on you.” “That’s your version of going off?” Dash scoffed a little. “Needs work; that’s all I can say.” “I don’t—really have any plans of getting better at it.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes but I was not required to write a review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
Disclaimer: Yes, I have a book in this collection, but that does not influence my reviews. The following are my honest reviews.
Jesus, I am Resting byDisclaimer: Yes, I have a book in this collection, but that does not influence my reviews. The following are my honest reviews.
Jesus, I am Resting by Faith Blum So, I loved the WWI setting and the hymn! Also, the message on resting was super good and one I personally really need to hear often, haha (ironically I have been pretty ill for 5 days, all because I’ve been pushing myself hard for months, and more specially for the last 3 weeks… and my body collapsed. So yes, very timely message lol). While I struggled to relate to Elinor, I really appreciated her grit and determination. Malachi and Andrew were pretty awesome, and the epilogue was just sweet :)
Content: brief mentions of war injuries, nothing graphic; otherwise totally clean.
The Cottage on the Hill by Andrea Renee Cox Oh my heartttt this story was gorgeous!! I absolutely adored the setting and the author painted the descriptions so vividly and beautifully. Moira was so sweet and God-centered and Adrian was so funny and loving and Godly, and their story was absolutely darling. The ending was absolutely PERFECT and the message of trusting God through the ups + downs and following Him as He leads to new dreams that perfectly satisfy… <3 so good.
Content: brief, undetailed kisses & touching; MC is a ballerina with a male partner, but their relationship is 100% clean and sweet.
If I Knew You Were Coming by Bailey Gaines Wow, definitely all the WWII feels here! The author did a great job representing the common struggles and sacrifices the British made during the war. Her message on doing the right thing before you even if it means giving up dreams was excellent, and I liked how she tackled the aspect of mother- and wifehood mixed with working outside of the home. Joan was delightful, Levi was awesome, and Oliver, Lottie, and Sophie were all so distinct and childlike and adorable!
Content: brief mentions of war, wounds, & PTSD; brief, undetailed kissing between wife & husband. Totally clean.
Her Heart’s Home by Grace A. Johnson Okay, this was just heartwarming. I love the 1920s setting, especially through the eyes of an older woman used to the early 1900s. Trevor is so dear and broken and manly, and Meredith is super sweet and humble and yet somehow a bit sassy. ;) I love them both! The writing is gorgeous, the hotel setting is so cool, the message is awesome… <3
Content: mentions of PTSD, non-graphic; slightly more detailed kissing but nothing extreme.
The Tussie-Mussie by Katja H. Labonté This story has been a long time in the making, first thought of when I was a child. It’s changed a lot since then, but I’m happy with where the idea is now. Although this novella was hard on me and wasn’t at all easy to write, edit, or even proofread, it has a special place in my heart, imperfect as it may be. There’s an awful lot of me in the characters, and the messages are some of the lessons God’s been teaching me lately. May you find encouragement and help through them as well. <3
Content: a family member’s vocal abuse is mentioned
The Odd Duck Society by Rachel Leitch I absolutely love this story! It’s so cute and whimsy. The ducks theme is epic, the characters are super cool, the plot is awesome, and I love how well the writing storyline is done (Lewis’ writing was mimicked to perfection!). Most of all, I loved seeing in Jessamy the self-disparagement I have myself and to see her grapple with it and heal just a bit. This was a fantastic portrayal of anxiety and overwhelm.
Fear Not Tomorrows by Erika Mathews I read this story three times now, having been a beta reader for it, and I still love it as much as when I finished the first draft. It’s such a sweet, vintage story—reminds me of Courtenay Burden’s writing and Five Little Peppers somehow. Margaret & her fiancé are so strong and sweet and real, and all the kids are adorable, and the messages are SO on point. <3
Courage to Stay by Kellyn Roth Kellyn Roth is known for tackling hard themes, and she didn’t shy away from several here: forced marriage (albeit both are *secretly* in love) and PTSD… before it was deemed to be a thing. I absolutely loved how she handled the PTSD and Rosalind + Matthias were adorable, and the humour was excellent, and I really liked Matthias’ friends. ;P In fact I need more about R&M. ;)
Content: There's quite a bit of married content in my personal opinion BUT please notice I am very sensitive to this and most everyone else had no issues. Everything is well handled and discreet. Personally I’d rate this novella 18+ but I’ve heard others say 14+ so it’s up to your own discretion.
And there’s my reviews of the entire collection. To sum everything up, it’s 100% a 5 star read for me; I love this collection so much, and it has some of the best authors; and I definitely recommend it!
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4 stars. This is a heartbreaking, beautiful short story prologue to a lovely series. Some bits did feel repetitive, but as someone who struggles with 4 stars. This is a heartbreaking, beautiful short story prologue to a lovely series. Some bits did feel repetitive, but as someone who struggles with depression repeatedly I understand that’s really how life does go. I loved Russell and I absolutely am HEARTBROKEN for him, and Eliza is so cute, and I need more of their story, pronto!!
*Quotes & updated review to come upon reread. I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
5 stars. So book 1 is all about foundation, and here you finally get to see the accidental chronic illness superheroes use their superpowers… for good5 stars. So book 1 is all about foundation, and here you finally get to see the accidental chronic illness superheroes use their superpowers… for good. :)
I love the characters more than ever! They just get more amazing—I love Harper so much now and I’m already starting to reallyyyy like Dash. 3 ALSO, Car is an EPIC addition & sidekick. So is the nutritionist…
Things ended up a bit more intense than I expected with what Brady ends up helping with, but I love the theme of trusting God even when it doesn’t make sense and when we are totally helpless to do anything more to help or fix the situation. And I really appreciate seeing the characters struggle with the downsides of their superpowers (even if it’s primarily Brady doing so, lol) as well as still battling the chronic illness itself.
On to the next book, even if it’s 11:30 PM. XD
A Favourite Quote: “I can’t save the world. I can’t save anyone…. All I can do is my part. Bloom where I’m planted. And let God handle the rest.” A Favourite Humorous Quote: He gulped air, attempting to slow the frantic beating of his heart that had expected—what? Kidnappers? The police? Some tough guy who didn’t appreciate a stranger staking out the random tree he’d been staring through?
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes but I was not required to write a review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
**Featured on the historic fiction podcast The Gibson Girl Review! Listen as my cohost Amy Drown & I discuss this novel at https://www.gibsongirlrevie**Featured on the historic fiction podcast The Gibson Girl Review! Listen as my cohost Amy Drown & I discuss this novel at https://www.gibsongirlreview.com/seas...**
3.5 stars (4/10 hearts). I started out really liking this book. It began with a bang and didn’t stop going. I loved the bit of mystery and suspense that ran almost all the way through, and how when one mystery was explained another arose. I enjoyed the characters so much—Katharine and Jervis are both awesome—and I loved how it portrayed Canada in the late 1800s, showing how much—or rather how little—it was settled, the struggles pioneers faced, and the strong ties to England. That’s not a side of Canada that’s explored very much. It reminded me somewhat of Catharine Parr Traill and Susanna Moodie, and I appreciated it.
I discovered after that the author, Bessie Marchant, is considered “the girls’ G.A. Henty.” As a lifelong fan of G.A. Henty, I can definitely see the similarities. It’s more feminine, unsurprisingly, but you have the same perfect heroines who are daring and womanly and a little more than human in how perfect they always are, you have the excitement and the “all turns out well in the end,” you have the unrealisticness because the author never visited the countries they wrote of and relied on second- or third-hand information, you have the ones who love each other finally getting together, and you have a hefty load of “England is the best forever, and everyone else is a bit less great.”
All that said, I loved the characters. Katherine was such a nice heroine—very strong and feminine, with a great character and plenty of strengths to be emulated. I know I mentioned that something about how she’s a little more than human, but personally I didn’t mind, I thought she was very well developed and I found her very inspiring. And I was surprised by how strong and hardworking Katherine was! She works A LOT and she works HARD, which is rather unusual for books of this era. Her sister Nellie was a bit more of a frustration to me because I saw a lot of my own personality in her and I felt that the author and the other characters were often dismissive to her. But her brothers Miles and Phil were both very enjoyable characters—very well developed too, and quite amusing. And her father, ’Duke, was very interesting—his character was quite intriguing and his illness was unique. I also liked Mr. Selincourt a lot. And I ended up liking Mary. The other characters were also well done—Oily Dave was so fun to hate on—and Jervis was a great hero. I admit towards the end I started to get a little annoyed that it was always HER saving HIM, because I felt like the surprise and freshness of that plot device was wearing off. I’d have loved to see him rescue her at some point. But I did still enjoy all of the rescue scenes, and how they really showcased their characters—how Katherine is quick and practical, and Jervis is very calm and thoughtful.
I was surprised, though, with how the other village folk were presented. Everyone was sloppy or stupid in some way, which made a very interesting dynamic, and also made it hard for me to remember who was who because they came across kinda similar. I liked the lesson that Katherine gave Mrs. M'Crawney, though, and how Mrs. McKee and Mrs. Jones both had their moments of glory. It made them to be a bit more than the caricatures they were, and I liked that. But I was really bugged by how almost every single Native American was represented. That really left a bad taste in my mouth. Particularly because, as I mentioned in the beginning, the book reminded me a lot of Catharine Parr Traill, who represented the Native Americans around her accurately, without any derogatory attitude and with plenty of “what can I learn from them?” Bessie Marchant really failed in that aspect of her writing. It was so flat.
The other thing that was hard for me was the ending. It came out of nowhere, it was not needed, and I felt it was out of characters for both Jervis and Katherine. And to make things worse, the book ends very abruptly without even finishing a paragraph! No “and this is what happened after,” no “well let’s wrap up this story,” nothing. I was so mad.
As far as themes go, I loved the message that “hardship can actually help us a lot more than it hinders us,” which comes back several times, both in Katherine and Jervis’ conversation and her talk with Mr. Selincourt. I also enjoyed seeing how strongly the English characters and Katherine’s family felt that her work was not “fit for a girl”—not because they thought she couldn’t do it but because they thought she shouldn’t have to do it… although I’m not sure they would have objected if it was Mrs. Jones doing it. It’s an interesting glimpse at chivalry… but a chivalry that existed mostly for one class. But I really liked how it showed that Katherine COULD do all she had to do and do it WELL, because it HAD to be done.
My overall feelings? This may surprise people, but…. I enjoyed the book a lot as I read it, but looking back now I mostly remember what I disliked, and my feelings are pretty neutral about it. I’m not sorry I read it, but I don’t know if I’ll reread it. I just… I don’t know. But I’d like to try more by Bessie Marchant, and I think this is definitely a book worth reading if you’re interested in it!
A Favourite Quote: She was especially blithe of heart to-day, and so had donned a skirt of scarlet blanket cloth, which matched in hue the woollen cloud she wrapped about her head. On other days, when her mood was more sombre, she wore a dark-blue skirt, like the thick, fur-lined coat which was put on every time she left the house. “How gay you look, Katherine!” exclaimed Mrs. Burton, as her sister came dancing into the kitchen, where she was making bread. “But what a pity to put on that scarlet skirt if you are going to bring fish home!” “I shan't spoil it, or if I do I will wear it spoiled until it drops into rags,” replied Katherine. “I call it my happiness skirt, and I wear it only when I feel happy.” A Favourite Humorous Quote: Katherine ought to have gone, but in view of the confusion which still existed on the shelves it hardly seemed safe to leave Miles in charge, because he had a habit, when he could not find the right thing, of supplying something else which looked almost like it. So when Katherine found him tying up an ounce of caustic soda, in place of the tartaric acid which had been ordered, it seemed high time to interfere[.]...more
5 stars. So this series has been ongoing since 2022… and I’ve been wanting to read it yet been terrified to, because it’s superheroes. But you know I 5 stars. So this series has been ongoing since 2022… and I’ve been wanting to read it yet been terrified to, because it’s superheroes. But you know I adore Angie Thompson’s books. So I’ve been collecting the series and planning to read them sometime when I was brave enough to bite the bullet and give them a shot. I finally did because I needed a book that started with U. And when I did… I loved them. Of course. Why do I always doubt? Angie keeps delivering books out of my normal reading genre and I always go “ehhh” and then discover they’re amazing. You’d think I’d learn.
So for starters, I was intrigued by the chronic illness part of this book. Having a large number of family and friends with chronic illness, I really appreciated the realistic inclusion of this in a book. As for the superpowers, they made enough sense in a pseudo-scientific way for me not to be weirded out. I mean, they’re still a bit weird but Angie Thompson does a great job handling it, as she does everything else. I may be a bit of a fangirl.
The characters are what made me fall, though. Brady is so sweet and strong, Rachelle is absolutely amazing, Grace is adorable, Harper is intriguing, and I want to (and know I will) like Dash eventually. I may or may not have binged the series in one night (from 9:30 to midnight to be precise) so I don’t exactly remember what happens in this book, but it’s the set up for everything and it includes Brady managing to accidentally be a hero thanks to his new superpowers… and it’s super sweet and funny and intriguing and everything Angie-Thompson-ish and I absolutely had to read the next book ASAP immediately.
A Favourite Quote: “This isn’t about needing to feel useful. If the best we can do is stock you with water and shut the door, then that’s what we’ll do. It’s not—not really the migraine I’m asking about. But you. What makes things more bearable, when you can get it?” A Favourite Humorous Quote: “I know it’s small and a little bare, but you wouldn’t have to keep it that way. Bare, I mean—there’s not much you could do about the size.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes but I was not required to write a review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4.5 stars (5/10 hearts). This was such a sweet, wholesome book—like eating sugar-free dessert. I adored the small town feels—LarkSprings was such a da4.5 stars (5/10 hearts). This was such a sweet, wholesome book—like eating sugar-free dessert. I adored the small town feels—LarkSprings was such a darling little place and I would love to live in somewhere similar!! I loved getting to know all the townsfolk, and they were all so nice… or ended up nice. ;) I particularly liked Leah & Emily. Autumn was very sweet and very relatable, too.
The plot was slow-paced, but interesting, and once I got started, I didn’t want to put the book down. The diversity of the cast was awesome, and I really liked how Hannah shone a light on broken families so sweetly and respectfully. As someone who is haunted by shame & guilt, and has ever since she can remember, the message of the book really hit me. It was all things I’d heard before, but I teared up just the same because of how beautiful & powerful it was. A lot of this book impacted me because I related to it—the fear of starting one’s own business, of being a counsellor, of being a bad big sister… it was all handled & resolved so well. <3 I can’t wait for the next instalment in this series!
*Quotes to come upon reread. I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4.7 stars (5/10 hearts). This is one of the deeper, darker stories of this collection… and I love it.
Young Felix, a musical genius, is the orphan son 4.7 stars (5/10 hearts). This is one of the deeper, darker stories of this collection… and I love it.
Young Felix, a musical genius, is the orphan son of a beautiful-souled woman and a shallow violinist. His grandfather, terrified the boy will turn out like dead son-in-law, removes the child’s violin and insists he must become a minister. When Felix is caught sneaking away to play on disreputable old Abel Blair’s fiddle, his grief at his grandfather’s dismay leads the minister to exact a promise Felix will never touch a violin again. How will Felix hold up against such torment, and will the minister ever come to realize that music can be used to minister as well as to entertain?
The characters in this story are varied and fascinating. Felix, such an innocent yet wise young boy, with peculiar insight into the souls of those around him; Abel, sin-stained but unrepentant, yet kindly hearted in spite of all his folly and stubbornness; Reverend Mr. Leonard, considered saintly (and overall a good man!) yet demonstrating real unkindness and lack of wisdom; Janet, demure yet blunt; poor Maggie, tragically disabled; and Naomi, immoral and broken… each one is alive and captures the imagination, and they are all flawed and human, while having each their own good points.
The plot, although short, is very well done. I am always heartbroken for poor Felix and disapproving of Mr. Leonard, saddened by Abel and pitiful of repentant, terrified Naomi. The climax, so dramatic and passionate, is one of my favourite of Montgomery’s. I love how she wove in the music, and I love the message… that gifts can be used to minister for the Lord as much as it can be used to minister for the Devil; and that God is Love and always forgives when we truly repent and seek His forgiveness.
Content: a woman has a child out of wedlock (it seems she trusted someone to marry her but he abandoned her after she became pregnant). ...more
5 stars. I was pretty certain this would be strong and gritty and beautiful, but it still wasn’t what I expected. It was so very different in feel and5 stars. I was pretty certain this would be strong and gritty and beautiful, but it still wasn’t what I expected. It was so very different in feel and aesthetic than “Once I Knew.” It’s foggy mountains and snow-laden pines and dark cloudy winter days, silent wolves and dark red clothes and weathered leather. If there’s one single aesthetic this book has, it’s a red rose frozen in dark ice…
I did find that the writing style was a little pretentious at times… a little showy… and in a few bits it was grammatically confusing; but mostly it was deep and beautiful and fit the book so extremely well. And the characters! Marcus was a good man, and I related deeply to his emotional struggles. Dilara I loved even more though. She was so strong and sweet and her pain was so well expressed and handled. Fendrel was a humorous, wise old doctor; Everard was simply AMAZING (that twist at the ending though!! OH MY STARS); the innkeeper and his wife and all the kids and their families—they were all so sweet and funny and so alive… and I loved seeing Elgon again! And the wolf was such a fun touch. ;) Also, the world building in this book is excellent. The whole part about the war and refugees was great and built things up perfectly to follow OIK and prepare for the next novel.
This book definitely has moments of crisis and suspense, but I loved how slower-paced it was and focussed on the emotional growth of the characters. Things were very well paced and revealed little by little. I loved seeing Dilara slowly gain trust and confidence. Her whole backstory of slavery, assault, and forced abortion was horrible, but the pro-life theme was splendid and unapologetic, covering the value of life in every aspect, from slavery and abortion to war and disability. The author did an excellent job in writing this. It was real, heavy, unvarnished; the stark tragedy was vivid, and it moved you to act; yet it was handled with enough grace and delicacy to be fit reading for teens and not too graphic to overwhelm. And the way she showed how much real beauty can come from the bleakest, most fire-ravaged ashes was tearfully beautiful. The horror of this world and the wonder of God met in this novel.
Content: description of wounds, etc, that is not over-graphic but still somewhat graphic in my (perhaps very) sensitive opinion. The theme of the book is slavery, handling both physical and sexual abuse. The sexual part is veiled, but it’s still clear. As I said, though, it's very well handled and definitely has no extra unneeded details. The abortion and birth scene are a little more detailed (specifically the birth scene at the end).
A Favourite Quote: “I know it’s hard to understand now[.] But your story knows no bounds with how God will use it. Your life was not a useless emptiness or waste of pain. Your life is full, meaningful, purposeful. Every breath you continue to take has a reason, and who are we to assume that to end it would be in the best interest of the world around us? To have never been or to change any part of your past would be to rob the world of who God created you to be and what you have become as a result of the sorrow and pain that has shaped you. What you will become. While it seems underwhelming to say ‘how can we know His plans and purposes,’ the reality is, they are far deeper, long reaching, and more impactful than we could ever imagine[.]Just think about Jesus. His brokenness and sacrifice is still spoken of today, over a thousand years after he lived and breathed.” A Favourite Humorous Quote: “Are you all right?” one little boy asked[.] “Right as rain in the summer,” Marcus quipped. “My mother says it’s not good to lie.” Marcus refrained from rolling his eyes at the young child’s response. “And your mother would be right.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
Loading...
