5+ étoiles (6 cœurs). Cette histoire était encore plus excitante que tome 1 ! Je ne l'ai pas aimée tout à fait autant que Une bouteille à la mer à5+ étoiles (6 cœurs). Cette histoire était encore plus excitante que tome 1 ! Je ne l'ai pas aimée tout à fait autant que Une bouteille à la mer à cause de son intensité, mais je pense qu'en la relisant, je l'apprécierai davantage.
J'étais ravie que l'oncle Calvin, Laura et Tariq soient parfaitement eux-mêmes et aient toujours d'excellentes relations. Quant aux nouveaux personnages, personne ne pourrait aimer Rita et Bob, mais Jimmy a plu malgré tout, pauvre enfant ; et j'ai aimé le Canadien (!!!) et l’ancien gars des Opérations spéciales. Et les nouveaux méchants étaient bien pires que les premiers, carrément terrifiants.
L'intrigue, comme je l'ai mentionné, était beaucoup plus rapide que le livre 1. Bien sûr, j'ai beaucoup apprécié la partie croisière (j'ai TOUJOURS voulu une croisière). Je n’ai pas vraiment aimé la partie sur les fugitifs… c’est effrayant et je déteste tous les mensonges et les demi-vérités auxquels les enfants doivent recourir… en plus, ça semble juste un peu irréaliste. Cependant, c’était certainement captivant, les enfants avaient de bonnes raisons pour ce qu’ils ont fait, et ils ont avoué rapidement et honnêtement quand ils le pouvaient. J’ai aussi aimé la façon dont tout s’assemble et comment la préservation marine a été ajoutee, ainsi que les thèmes profonds du courage, de l’amitié et de la confiance en soi.
J’ai dû lire ce livre très vite pour le rendre à la bibliothèque, de plus je l’ai trouvé assez lourd en émotions/épuisant la première fois que je l’ai lu, alors attendez-vous à une meilleure critique lors de la relecture.
—————
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). This story was even more exiting than book 1! I didn’t love it quite as much as Une bouteille à la mer because of how intense it was, but I think upon reread I’ll enjoy it more.
I was thrilled that Uncle Calvin, Laura, and Tariq were perfectly themselves and still had excellent relationships. As for the new characters—no one could love Rita & Bob but Jimmy grew on you despite everything, poor kid; and I liked the Canadian fellow (!!!) and the former Special Ops. And the new villains were much worse than the first ones—downright terrifying.
The plot, as I mentioned, was a lot more fast-paced than book 1. Of course I enjoyed the cruise part a lot (I have ALWAYS wanted a cruise). I was not quite such a fan of the fugitive portion of the book… it’s scary and I hate all the lies and half-truths the kids have to recourse to… plus it feels a teeny bit unrealistic. However, it was certainly gripping, the kids did have good reasons for what they did, and they did own up quickly and honestly when they could. Also, I liked how everything fit together and the marine preservation was worked in, also the deep themes of courage and friendship and self-confidence.
I had to read this very fast to return it to the library, plus I found it rather heavy on the emotions/exhausting the first time I read it, so expect a better review upon reread....more
3 stars. I didn’t find this one quite as amusing, or hugely interesting, because it was a little more serious than the first story. But it was funny, 3 stars. I didn’t find this one quite as amusing, or hugely interesting, because it was a little more serious than the first story. But it was funny, and I wish it had been finished after all! ...more
5+ étoiles (7/10 cœurs). J'ai failli ne pas prendre ce livre quand je l'ai vu à la bibliothèque, mais quand je l'ai fait, le résumé m'a tellement intr5+ étoiles (7/10 cœurs). J'ai failli ne pas prendre ce livre quand je l'ai vu à la bibliothèque, mais quand je l'ai fait, le résumé m'a tellement intrigué que j'ai dû lui donner une chance. Et oh que je suis vraiment content de l'avoir fait !
J'ai tellement aimé ce livre que je ne sais même pas par où commencer. Je suppose que, tout d'abord, c’est le cadre. Une ville côtière britannique avec des activités de contrebande historiques, se déroulant à l'époque contemporaine, mais avec une touche de “fantaisie” à l'ancienne ? INSCRIVEZ-MOI. J'ai adoré, adoré, adoré St. Ives et la plage. Et le style d'écriture était excellent + correspondait si bien à l'histoire… et j'ai adoré tout le côté détective. ;)
Ensuite, j'ai vraiment aimé l'héroïne. Laura était courageuse + impulsive, mais aussi attentionnée et intelligente, contrairement à de nombreux personnages principaux dans les mystères pour jeunes. C'était une enfant réaliste, mais obéissante, et elle était raisonnable, et ne tirait pas trop de conclusions stupides, du moins pas sans de bonnes preuves. Et son oncle Calvin était fantastique. Intrigant, inhabituel et très aimant et compréhensif. Son scénario était fantastique, et j'ai vraiment aimé la relation pleine de confiance et de respect qu'ils avaient et la rapidité avec laquelle l’oncle comprenait le point de vue de Laura et demandait pardon lorsqu'il faisait des erreurs, tandis qu'elle, de son côté, lui obéissait, communiquait clairement (quelque chose qu'il lui rendait assez bien), et essayait de ne pas le déranger. Après une série de romans jeunesse avec des relations parents/tuteurs non idéales pour diverses raisons, j'étais ravie, et d'autant plus que Laura et Calvin étaient tous deux dans une situation où ils pouvaient très facilement et légitimement se débattre. De plus, l'acolyte, Tariq, était un autre personnage génial, un très bon ami et un garçon très droit et responsable ; la voisine était amusante et adorable ; et les méchants étaient parfaits.
Enfin, j’ai adoré l’intrigue ! Nous savons tous que j’aime les bons romans jeunesse mystère, car ils ont la dose parfaite de suspense ; et les (bons) romans jeunesse ont généralement un bon équilibre entre les problèmes de la vie réelle et une vie heureuse et idéaliste. Et ce livre a ces deux choses. Il y a beaucoup de souffrance et de luttes du monde réel – j’ai profondément apprécié la mise en évidence du travail des enfants et de l’exploitation des personnes vulnérables ; c’était si bien fait – mais il y a aussi beaucoup de plaisir et de bonheur simples et heureux au quotidien, et cela se retrouve tout au long du livre, même depuis le début de Laura à l’orphelinat jusqu’à sa vie de famille finale à la fin. Oui, l’intrigue commence plutôt simple, mais elle devient rapidement complexe et culmine en un véritable suspense. J’ai adoré la façon dont tant d’éléments (que je ne peux pas expliquer à cause des spoilers) avaient du sens et n’étaient pas juste parce que quelqu’un était anormalement idiot.
Ce livre m’a rendu si heureux ! C'est une lecture parfaite pour l'été, les vacances ou la plage, et cela donne naissance à une superbe série que je dois absolument lire et posséder en format poche. J'ai apprécié chaque minute de ce livre et j'ai hâte de le relire.
————
5+ stars (7/10 hearts). I almost didn’t pick this up when I saw it at the library, but when I did, the blurb intrigued me so much I had to give it a shot. And boy, am I ever glad I did!
I loved so much about this book that I don’t even know where to start. I guess, first off, the setting. A costal British town with historical smuggling activities, set in the contemporary era, but with a dash of old-fashioned whimsy? SIGN. ME. UP. I loved, loved, loved St. Ives and the beach. And the writing style was excellent + fit the story so well… and I loved all the detective stuff. ;)
Next, I really liked the heroine. Laura was brave + impulsive, but also caring and smart, unlike many MCs in MG mysteries. She was a realistic kid, but obedient, and she was sensible, and didn’t jump too too many stupid conclusions—at least not without good proof. And her uncle Calvin was fantastic. Intriguing, unusual, and very loving + understanding. His storyline was fantastic, and I really loved the trustful, respectful relationship they had and how quick he was to understand her POV and ask forgiveness when he messed up, while she on her part obeyed him, clearly communicated (something he reciprocated fairly well), and tried not to inconvenience him. After a string of MGs with non-ideal parent/guardian relationships for various reasons, I was THRILLED—and all the more so because both Laura & Calvin were in a situation where they could very easily and legitimately struggle. Also, the sidekick, Tariq, was another great character—a really good friend, and a very upright, responsible boy; the neighbour was fun and loveable; and the villains were perfect.
Finally, I loved the plot! We all know I love me a good MG mystery, because they have the perfect amount of suspense; and (good) MGs usually have a great balance of real-life issues and happy, idealistic life. And this book has both of those things. There’s plenty of real-world pain and struggle—I deeply appreciated the highlighting of child labour and exploitation of vulnerable people; it was so well done—but there’s also plenty of simple happy every-day fun and happiness, and this is consistent through the whole book, even from Laura’s own beginning at the orphanage to her final home life at the end. Yes, the plot starts out rather simple, but it quickly gets complex and climaxes to a real nail-biter. I loved how so many of the elements (which I can’t explain because of spoilers) made sense and weren’t just someone bing unnaturally idiotic.
It just made me so happy! It’s the perfect summer/holiday/beach read, and sets up a great series I must read and own in paperback. I enjoyed every minute of it and cannot wait to reread it....more
3,7 étoiles (4/10 cœurs). J’ai adoré cette magnifique couverture et le titre m’a tout de suite attiré. C’est un livre pour enfants, mais je l’ai vraim3,7 étoiles (4/10 cœurs). J’ai adoré cette magnifique couverture et le titre m’a tout de suite attiré. C’est un livre pour enfants, mais je l’ai vraiment apprécié ! Je ne connaissais pas la plupart de ces lieux, et si j’en avais entendu parler, je ne savais rien de leur histoire ou de leurs spécificités, donc c’était assez instructif. C’était assez bien écrit pour les enfants sans être ennuyeux pour un adulte, et la seule chose dont je n’étais pas folle, c’était les illustrations. J'aurais préféré voir les bâtiments avec plus de réalisme, ou au moins avoir une photo en pièce jointe. Mais en général, c'était plutôt génial.
—————
3.7 stars (4/10 hearts). I loved that beautiful cover and the title caught my eye right away. It’s a book for kids, but I really enjoyed it! I didn’t know about most of these places, and if I’d heard of them I didn’t know anything about their history or specifics, so it was quite educational. It was written well enough for kids while not being annoying to an adult, and the only thing I wasn’t a fan of was the illustrations. I would have preferred to see the buildings in more realism, or at least have a photograph attached. But in general, it was pretty great....more
3,7 étoiles (4/10 cœurs). C'est un livre pour enfants, mais je l'ai apprécié quand même. Ce livre présente 10 femmes à travers l’histoire; certaines q3,7 étoiles (4/10 cœurs). C'est un livre pour enfants, mais je l'ai apprécié quand même. Ce livre présente 10 femmes à travers l’histoire; certaines que je connaissais déjà mais la plupart non.
Rosa Parks et son mouvement des droits civiques protestent contre le racisme aux États-Unis ; Wangari Maathai, qui protège les arbres et l'environnement du mauvais gouvernement et des étrangers au Kenya ; Marie Curie, la première femme à recevoir un prix Nobel pour ses immenses réalisations scientifiques ; Alexandra David-Néel, l'une des premières exploratrices du Thibet ; Joséphine Baker, une danseuse qui devint résistante pendant la Seconde Guerre mondiale ; Valentina Tereshkova, qui a débuté comme ouvrière dans une usine et est devenue la première femme dans l'espace ; Hélène Boucher, l'une des premières femmes pilotes et détentrice d'un record du monde ; Malala Yousafza, qui lutte pour la scolarisation des filles ; Frida Kahlo, une grande peintre malgré toute la tragédie de sa vie ; et J.K. Rowling, qui est passée de mère célibataire brisée à auteur de renommée mondiale.
Certaines d’entre elles étaient plus inspirantes que d’autres, et j’en ai aimé certaines plus que d’autres, mais tous étaient plutôt intéressantes. Au début, je me demandais pourquoi Frida Kahlo était là avec toutes ces femmes révolutionnaires, mais en tant qu’auteur, j’ai apprécié l’histoire de Rowling, même si je ne lis pas ses livres, car c’est fondamentalement ce dont rêve tout écrivain ! Alors peut-être que Kahlo pourrait inspirer les artistes. Quoi qu'il en soit, ce fut une lecture agréable et j'ai envie de lire la version augmentée avec 5 femmes supplémentaires.
Contenu : une femme dans une tenue assez étriqué.
———— 3.7 stars (4/10 hearts). It’s a kids’ book, but I enjoyed it, actually. This book features 10 women through history, some of whom I knew already but most of whom I didn’t.
Rosa Parks and her Civil Rights movement protests against racism in the States; Wangari Maathai, protecting trees and the environment in Kenya from bad government and foreigners; Marie Curie, the first woman to get a Nobel Prize for her huge scientific achievements; Alexandra David-Néel, one of the first explorers to Thibet; Josephine Baker, a dancer and resistance fighter in WWII; Valentina Tereshkova, starting out as a humble factory worker and becoming the first woman in space; Hélène Boucher, one of the first female pilots and setter of a world record; Malala Yousafza, fighting for female schooling; Frida Kahlo, a great painter despite all the tragedy of her life; and J.K. Rowling, who went from broken single mother to world-renowned author.
Some of them were more inspiring than others, and I liked some more than others, but all of them were pretty interesting. At first I wondered why Frida Kahlo was in there with all these groundbreaking women, but as an author, I appreciated Rowling’s story, even if I don’t read her books, because it’s basically what every writer dreams of! So perhaps Kahlo might be inspiring to artists. Anyways, it was an enjoyable read and I want to read the expanded version with 5 extra women.
Content: a woman in a pretty skimpy outfit....more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). Let’s face it: if any other book had been dealing with blood transfusions, I probably would have DNFed or hated it. Needles ar5+ stars (6/10 hearts). Let’s face it: if any other book had been dealing with blood transfusions, I probably would have DNFed or hated it. Needles are my Waterloo. Nonetheless, Christina Baehr managed to make this book an absolute delight to me. So let’s discuss why.
After Edith’s experiences in Wales, it’s great to see her newfound understanding and sensitivity. She still believes as much as ever in good triumphing over evil and right making might, but she’s also quicker to see and act against injustice and wickedness, even when she stands alone. Her lessons on healing, on letting others help, and on not managing others are powerful. Janushek and Gwendoline are absolute STARS, and Tallantire was AWESOME (can’t wait to see more of him), and I loved seeing Lily again, and Lady Butter Roll (I forget her name) was so sweet and Cousin Stephen + Crispin were so fun and Hanna was a dear—but I miss Father and George and all the other family members!! And Simon, of course… Oh, I mustn’t forget Miss Rivers. She was epic herself.
I LOVED following Edith’s journey through London and the puzzling Worms secrets. I am so eager to see Gwendoline’s medical practice start, and it was so fun to see Edith socializing (under her nom-de-plume). The historical aspects (tax representation for women, prostitution rings, and chemical warfare) are SPLENDID and fit in perfectly with the dragon side of things—that part always blows me away—and Edith exploring her Jewish roots (and forcing Janushek to) are awesome. As I mentioned, I did hate the blood transfusions and bloodletting. I have a particular repugnance/trauma connected to that. But though I had to take a few pauses, personally, nothing was detailed at all and the story whisked me on so quickly and distracted me so well I didn’t have any issues. And I have to mention the self-defence scene. THAT CHAPTER WAS THE BOMB.
Seriously, this book is the best so far. It will be hard to beat, but I’m positive Christina Baehr will produce an absolute smasher of a finale in book 5. I cannot wait.
also WHAT WAS THAT CLIFFHANGER?!?!
Content: blood transfusions & iffy scientific experiments (on one occasion done to an nonconsenting, drugged patient); a dangerous moment with a snake; mention of women being unsafe and needing to take self-defence lessons; talk of prostitution rings/s*x trafficking.
*Quotes to come upon reread, because my Kindle malfunctioned and wiped them all…I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4.5 stars (4/10 hearts). Another middle-grade Sunday school book (8-12), but it still kept my interest. I enjoyed the simple, concrete way Savery talk4.5 stars (4/10 hearts). Another middle-grade Sunday school book (8-12), but it still kept my interest. I enjoyed the simple, concrete way Savery talked of Jesus being our tower, while also spinning an enjoyable story. Gilly and Jane were nice little things, and I appreciated their characters very much. And Savery’s writing really is awesome, even in this small book. Oh, and I loved the bit about King Uzziah’s towers!...more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). This was recommended by Saraina Whitney and I decided to drop everything and read it today. Oh, am I glad I did!!
Set in a sub5+ stars (6/10 hearts). This was recommended by Saraina Whitney and I decided to drop everything and read it today. Oh, am I glad I did!!
Set in a suburb of London, it features a sweet little bit of the comedy and tragedy we call life. The writing style is epic (I’ve always said Doyle was a fantastic writer) and I loved seeing Doyle’s writing in the NON mystery genre! And his characters are as odd and charming as in his Sherlock books. The funny little old maids, quasi pitiful with their memories of a land once belonging to them; the impulsive, impressionable Doctor; the noble, hearty old Admiral; and the wild, feminist Mrs. B. Sweet Clara, merry Ida, honourable Henry, and study Charles complete the cast, along with darling Mrs. Admiral.
I actually laughed aloud several times… especially when Clara & Ida carry out their plan to convince the susceptible doctor NOT to marry the widow. Misses Monica and Bertha were also quite the pair. Yet with all the humour there’s also a thought-provoking theme on feminism. While Mrs. B. is clearly an exaggeration and meant to poke sly fun at women who fly off the handle, she does say and is respected for saying several deep, good things to ponder over. I really appreciated seeing that contemporary bit of information.
Overall, this is a mixture of adorable romance, friendship, and family love, a dip into tragedy, and a good dose of hilarity, all ending perfectly. I never knew what to expect and loved every minute of it. It’s a short, typically victorian, and absolutely charming read!
A Favourite Quote: “Do you think that a woman's love is like this sunshade which I carry in my hand, a thing only fitted for the sunshine, and of no use when the winds blow and the clouds gather?” “I would not drag you down, Clara.” “Should I not be dragged down indeed if I left your side at such a time? It is only now that I can be of use to you, help you, sustain you. You have always been so strong, so above me. You are strong still, but then two will be stronger.” A Favourite Beautiful Quote: Six or eight such cottages scattered over a rolling country-side were all the houses to be found there in the days when the century was young. From afar, when the breeze came from the north, the dull, low roar of the great city might be heard, like the breaking of the tide of life, while along the horizon might be seen the dim curtain of smoke, the grim spray which that tide threw up. Gradually, however, as the years passed, the City had thrown out a long brick-feeler here and there, curving, extending, and coalescing, until at last the little cottages had been gripped round by these red tentacles, and had been absorbed to make room for the modern villa. A Favourite Humorous Quote: “The blackguard!” cried the Doctor, “but the police must be hot upon his track.” “I fancy not,” Mrs. Westmacott answered calmly. “As my brother is a particularly tall, thin man, and as the police are looking for a short, fat one, I do not think that it is very probable that they will catch him.”...more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). Every time I think Christina Baehr can’t possibly surprise me, I end up mind blown. I am not exaggerating, these books get bet5+ stars (6/10 hearts). Every time I think Christina Baehr can’t possibly surprise me, I end up mind blown. I am not exaggerating, these books get better and better!
I love Edith. She’s so, so relatable. I’m not as smart as she is, nor as good at reading people, but I totally am as naïve and optimistic. Seeing her take a hefty dose of realism and finally fully understanding the wickedness of people—beyond just what she heard as a clergyman’s daughter—was splendid. So was her growing faith. Simon was a brick, as always, and their tiny growing romance THE SWEETEST; I can’t wait to see it blossom. Arthur was despicable, and fascinating; and somehow I hated his father worse. The Welsh maiden, whose name currently escapes me, and the butler, and the schoolteacher too, were my favourites—what intriguing characters! I’d wish to see them again but I think they’d be out of place anywhere else. As for Miss F, she was well worth leaving in Wales, despite all the interest she commands.
The plot was certainly more intense than any of the other books so far. Questions are raised, a few answers given, more puzzle pieces are revealed—all during a forced sojourn in an unknown village buried in the remote, unforgiving mountains where a selfish, self-satisfied theoretician enforces his idea of Utopia. Flying dragons, a rival, hostage negotiations, and thousand-year-old beasts make for plenty of excitement, and the author tackles more deep topics: oppression & minority, politics and sin nature, losing oneself to conformity, and the vulnerability + exploitation of women and children, to name a few.
I enjoyed so many things, like the medieval aesthetic, the symbolism, the dragon love; I appreciated the splendid humour and thought-provoking messages; the ending had me melting and the cliffhanger aghast… it’s absolutely an amazing addition to the series. <3
Content: mentions of women being mistresses & exploited; attempted a*sault to Edith that doesn’t get too far; discussion of the a*sault of a minor ending in pregnancy;
A Favourite Quote: “There are no invisible people here. Everyone has a purpose, everyone is respected. No one is superfluous.” The old woman who had touched my face so tenderly, what would her condition be if she had grown old in a Welsh mining town, I wondered. Or in Ormdale? I felt a flush of guilt—some of the servants at the abbey were growing old, with no comforts to alleviate the inevitable complaints of age. Had I been content not to see them? Was Ormdale full of invisible people? A Favourite Beautiful Quote: How odd, I thought, that Arthur’s good looks made me feel off-balance and slightly ill, but Simon’s made me feel like I was sitting in my own chair at home with a teapot brewing and a good fire warming me. A Favourite Humorous Quote: Goodness, why wouldn’t he find me dull? Quick, I must think of something dull! What was the dullest thing I could think of? Ah! I had it. “Have you ever attended a charity bazaar, sir?” I asked. He looked taken aback. “No, I can’t say I’ve ever had the pleasure…” “It is no pleasure. It is a torment,” I said fervently. I then launched into what I hoped was an interminable description of one of the most tedious afternoons I had ever survived. But somehow it didn’t come out that way. It was rather like that ridiculous book I had read on the train. Nothing of any consequence happens in it, the people and events are tiresome in the extreme, but one never wants it to end. From Arthur’s rapt expression, I was beginning to think I should consider trying my hand at a comic novel next instead of my usual detective fare, when I caught a glimpse of Miss Falconer’s face and began to fear I would not survive the night. (Perhaps a knowledge of common poisons would come in handy, after all.) Faltering, I ended my story rather weakly. “So you see, sir, you haven’t missed anything at all. There’s nothing at all to interest you.”
*Quotes to come. I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
3.7 stars (4/10 hearts). This is a type of book I’ve never read before, especially as a GA/PE novel. It was brutally honest about things people don’t 3.7 stars (4/10 hearts). This is a type of book I’ve never read before, especially as a GA/PE novel. It was brutally honest about things people don’t like to talk about, and I loved that. Austen’s and Jefferson’s characters was stripped of conventionalities and laid bare, and it gave raise to so many thinking points.
The setting was the first unique part: the Canary Islands. Spain is generally fascinating to me, and I particularly enjoyed seeing a lesser-known part of it. As a multicultural person, I appreciated seeing the remarks on the cultural differences between the Castilians, the English, and the Americans. The secondary setting was Western Africa, which of course gave rise to racist language, actions, and opinions; yet I got the impression that the author disagreed with this, at least to a degree. He had a lot of deep points to make about the struggle between the white and black men, about justice and safety and morality in a hard land…
The characters were also unusual. There was Austen, the hero, who starts out lazy and indolent, and by plunging into a fiery furnace of primitive work displays the true steel of his character. He’s not perfect—and that’s the whole point—but he’s honest about his issues, too. Jefferson I didn’t like as much. He was too brutal, even for this type of book—and yet he could be heroic at times too. That was another unique thinking point of the story. The characters were so FLAWED—and so real. There was Jacinta, far too proud and controlling and who got a sharp lesson; Muriel, too innocent and naïve, yet almost refreshing after everyone else; her companion, a shrewd, loveable old lady; and Bill, Tom, and Macallister, who had plenty of issues and plenty of likability.
Then the plot was unusual. One man gets engaged, considers he doesn’t have enough money to support his wife in the comfort she deserves, and decides to risk his life on a project to doing out to Western Africa, buying a stranded ship, and removing the valuable gum from her. When he’s stricken down with deadly fever, his pal heads out with supplies to join him and stays there to help him out, with no real reason but personal satisfaction. The story becomes one of personal fight, perseverance, and satisfaction, and also a look into the reality of life when conventionalities are removed. It’s primitive and harsh, and looks the disagreeable truth straight in the face in a way I have rarely read, and I deeply appreciate that. There’s also a strong appreciation of courage, and a lot of deep questions about morality, and a lot of comparison between different characters…
The book has its issues. But what I appreciated about it most was that it dared say things most people don’t. It didn’t have the answers, but it made you think about its questions....more
4.7 stars (5/10 hearts). If you know me, you know I am a Titanic buff. I’ve aways been fascinated by it, and I’m always on the lookout for more info o4.7 stars (5/10 hearts). If you know me, you know I am a Titanic buff. I’ve aways been fascinated by it, and I’m always on the lookout for more info or reading material. So when I discovered B.M. Baker was writing a Titanic novel and releasing it on the anniversary of the sinking, I had to read it.
The plot is split into two parts—2023 and 1912. My favourite part was undeniably the 2023 part. I just didn’t connect with Renita very well… I found her too modern for 1912. I know, I’m a snob. I’m sorry. But I also found her a bit stilted and preachy? Maybe because we were less in her head than in her diary. I liked Daniel, though… although again, at times he was too perfect and wooden for me to really appreciate as a character. But most of all I liked Greyslin and Stanley a lot. They were such a cute friends-to-more couple! Stanley is so sweet and Greyslin is super relatable. And their friends + family are just amazing.
Without giving any spoilers, I love how the two plot lines paralleled each other and merged finally… (I never expected that final revelation!). I enjoyed getting to see G+S navigate college life and their emotions. Greyslin’s arc was particularly epic—I LOVE the message about fear and trust that she learned. And Stanley’s storyline was unexpected but awesome. ALSO, I love the whole part of the play about the Titanic, and Greyslin’s story for that, and how she found the diary, and alllll that part. It was splendid!
And that leads me to the Titanic. I really appreciate how B.M. Baker pulled this off. She clearly did her research and had so much respect for the people who perished in this disaster. She handled things very well. That last scene was pretty poignant. And I love the open-ended ending so much.
So, Titanic fans, definitely check this novel out. And people who aren’t Titanic fans, if you love musicians, school stories, slowburn but super cute moments, illness, deep messages, and anything else I mentioned in this review, you should give this a shot!
Content: mild mentions of attraction; a couple places where G&S almost kiss; G keeps thinking about kissing S.
A Favourite Quote: “You haven’t abandoned me. Forgive me, Jesus. You’re still here with me. You’re not just walking beside me, You’re carrying me in Your arms right now. Thank You for the reminder.” And just like the hymn writer said, Greyslin had not been promised a life of ease and free of sorrow but one where God would give her what she needed to face whatever came her way.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4.5 stars (4/10 hearts). This was my first book by this author, who was recommended to me by a friend. I understand it’s part of a series, but I read 4.5 stars (4/10 hearts). This was my first book by this author, who was recommended to me by a friend. I understand it’s part of a series, but I read it quite well as a standalone. I was expecting your typical Victorian historical fiction adventure, but it’s more of a Christian historical fiction than an adventure.
I liked the characters well enough—Sir Thomas, who meant sooo well; Rachel, who was hilarious; Jack, until he went rogue; Mr. Robin T., a great preacher; Blanche… Others were interesting, even if they weren’t great people, like Lucrece, and Don Juan, whom I found excessively amusing. Clare wasn’t really the MC at all—barely had any screen time to be honest!—and was rather boring. The characters certainly had enough personality and interest to create a good plot, and I was a little disappointed that the book didn’t have that much plot. It’s not that nothing happened—it did—but it was more focussed on the spiritual development than anything else, and that shown by long talks, not by struggles and adventures. The characters changed rather quickly.
But despite that, I didn’t find the book boring; it was actually quite interesting. Though it could basically have been set at any other period of Elizabeth’s reign, for all it ended up talking about the Armada… that taking up about one whole chapter, and only a few scenes set among fictional characters. Being as I love history and particularly this part of history, I didn’t mind the historical digressions à la Henty; but I was annoyed by the constant repetitions of who was and wasn’t a historical character and whether or not she invented a personality for an actual historical character. And the whole genealogy at the end was rather tangled. But I liked the humour, and the old-fashioned dialogue (though I could have done without most of the definitions—the context made it pretty clear).
I did quite like the spiritual aspect, however. It was definitely christian, not just moralistic. I was fascinated by the long conversation about the errors of the Roman Catholic Church, which was actually well written and not just an info-dump. And as someone currently struggling with having a spot in life that doesn’t seem important, plus wishing for marriage, Clare’s lessons really spoke to me. And Mrs. T’s sermon to Blanche was so good.
Overall, I’m rounding it up to 4.5 stars, and I’ll read more by this author—specifically, the rest of this series....more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). I have put off this review for weeks because I dreaded having to put into words how much I enjoyed it. I was so scared it woul5+ stars (6/10 hearts). I have put off this review for weeks because I dreaded having to put into words how much I enjoyed it. I was so scared it wouldn’t be quite as good as book 1, but it took up the torch and continued in unbroken amazingness.
Where do we start? The characters, I suppose. I love how everyone is such a great continuation of themselves. It’s wonderful to see Edith build confidence and Gwendoline heal and Simon take control. They’re all three finding themselves, and it’s wonderful. Helen was not who I expected her to be and I ended up almost mourning over her; but I love, LOVE, L-O-V-E Janushek. (I have a thing for Polish/Slavic guys, apparently??) He’s fantastic and I cannot wait to know more about him.
As in book two, the mysteries are slowly revealed… more and more is being built on, and it’s whetting my appetite so much!!! There’s the usual excellent humour and the sweet family scenes and a splendid plot, just similar enough to book 1 to be satisfying. The tiny thread of romance is super cute and I love all the historical connections happening as Edith discovers more about herself, the dragons, and the dale. The relatableness, the mock Gothic feels, and the everyday life interwoven with danger and questioning is epic.
But my favourite thing is the themes. Christina Baehr really goes in for the kill here as she tackles parental/hereditary trauma and social injustice. There’s Gwendoline struggling to let go of the dark habits and beliefs ingrained in her by her father, and battling social prejudices as a woman seeking to become a doctor; there’s Simon, whose parent stifles him to make up for the trauma she herself endured at the hands of her husband; there’s Janushek, who faces racism and social ostracism because of his jewish roots, his foreign origin, and his physical scars; and finally, there’s Pip, born of the master of the house assaulting a young, pretty maid, and who with his mother receives neither aid nor acknowledgement—all very real and very terrible yet common and disregarded happenings.
I love how Edith takes consciousness of all these evils and sets out to battle them, even if alone and unsupported. I love how she starts understanding the people of the dale and ministering to them, accepting her role as a protector and keeper. Her backbone is developing, and she’s got such a good mixture of respect and fearlessness.
The story ends on a cliffhanger as the first one did, but I didn’t need that to make me eager for book 3!
A Favourite Quote: “Courage is love defying fear. And that’s what those girls need…. Just keep being Edith, and take them along with you sometimes. What you are doing here—being a friend to Gwendolyn and Simon, and heaven knows what else you’ve taken on in this place—is courageous. And they will see it, if you let them.” A Favourite Beautiful Quote: But they remained faithful, keeping watch; keeping England’s dragons secret and safe. And the world around them changed, and people were ashamed to think that their grandparents had ever believed in dragons. A Favourite Humorous Quote: But it had colourful scales instead of fur, small useless wings halfway down its body, and (or so it seemed to me) an expression of simmering fury. I had schooled myself not to stare at it, lest I annoy it further, but today I thought it looked if possible even more sour-tempered—no doubt as a result of its involuntary ablutions.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). When I first heard of this (through Lindsey from Books For Christian Girls), I was hooked. Cozy, nonmagical fantasy with drago5+ stars (6/10 hearts). When I first heard of this (through Lindsey from Books For Christian Girls), I was hooked. Cozy, nonmagical fantasy with dragons? Sounds great. But I quickly discovered it was even better than I expected.
Excellent humour? check. 1800s English historical setting? Mystery without spook or second-hand embarrassment? check. Strong family circle? check. Great writing style, similar to 1900s classics? check. Good message? check. Living characters? check, check, checkety check check.
All right, my favourite thing was Edith. We’re about the same age… and I’m also a pastor’s daughter… and I also write… and I write mysteries… and I’m homeschooled… and I love history… and I love frogs… okay, that last bit doesn’t have much to do with the story BUT I think Edith would like frogs if she tried it. I don’t think there’s that much difference between a dragon and a frog, when it comes to their feel. Anyways, I loved Edith. I related to her a lot, and she was such a solid MC—sensible, realistic, flawed, honest, strong, but not anti-men (well, by the end at least). Her character arc was so well done. (And I, too, find that “my rambles always turn out best when there is someone to tell me when I’m going the wrong way.”)
But I loved the other characters too! Gwen was such a dear, and Drake was a real gentleman, and Violet + Una + George were fantastic supporting characters, and Mother & Father were just delightful. I love absent-minded studious male characters (they’re such a hoot) but I LOVED that father was quite able to be sensible and present and Fatherly and protective and wise. (The recurring cup of tea was *kiss fist*). And saintly, wise mothers are my favourite every time. Also, Pilot is a darling, and Rivers was the PERFECT villain.
And I loved the plot. It reminded me of Amanda Kastner’s Questless series, actually… that same time of feel, like Victorian England reimagined to include dragons—real, nonmagical, little pet dragons. (And the occasional real, nonmagical, venomous wyvern). Dragons are real creatures, and the author is very specific to say the story is NOT magical and the dragons are totally normal, as they were back in medieval days. The antidote is also nonmagical and just a matter of genetics, which was super cool. I love how the mysteries were slowly revealed… the pacing was epic! And personally, I loved that the suspense was so fully tempered with humour.
I loved the sensible gothic abbey setting (it’s a thing, I promise!) and how Edith handled the history and past of the place but also looked to the future and broke the generational trauma of the place. The whole thread about sacrifice was amazingly done. The spiritual aspect was subtle, but deep. I love how bookish it was and Edith & Drake constantly dragging up classics. I loved the ridiculousness tempered with seriousness—such a great balance, and well displayed in the whole part of Edith thinking she was dying. It was hilarious but had such a deep message.
Honestly, I’m not sure what to say! This story scratched a bookish itch I didn’t even know I had. I am so hooked to this series and absolutely cannot wait to read the next book. I NEED TO MEET MRS. DRAKE. And I also need Edith to confess her writing. ...more
5+ stars (7/10 hearts). I'm familiar with, and love, Courtenay Burden's style, but she blew me away with this book. It's so delightfully Victorian!! I5+ stars (7/10 hearts). I'm familiar with, and love, Courtenay Burden's style, but she blew me away with this book. It's so delightfully Victorian!! I could swear it was written in 1864. It was so funny and sweet and realistic and vintage... I swooned over the writing alone.
And then there were the characters. Did I mention the book was realistic? As a homeschool graduate and the eldest of nine children, I can vouch for how very, very real the children and the schooldays were. Emily, Walter, Arthur, Janet, Bertie, Clarence... they were all so darling and so funny in their own ways! Mrs. Hazelby was so very sweet and such an inspiration, and Mr. Hazelby was a wonderful, wonderful man. As for Miss Webster & Pauline... they ended up very loveable after all.
It's a quick, simple story, taking place over a short period, and very much slice-of-life... schoolday adventures, countryside rambling, excitement and worry such as crops up every so often... I loved the plot. And the message! "Do all to the glory of God" was explored so throughly and so well, and connected specifically to education so splendidly! It gave me so much to think about, it brought a few tears to my eyes, and it made my heart very happy. <3
In short, this is another stunning novel by one of my very favourite authors, and I think all homeschooling parents and families should read this...
A Favourite Quote: “Mamma does say we need not be afraid of the dark. And you know why she says that, Bertie, don’t you?” “Because God is there, just the same as the day,” whispered Janet. A Favourite Humorous Quote: Emily wanted to commence with the whole name, Royal Society for the Self-Im- provement of Hazelby Priors, in gothic letters across the top. Walter was not certain that you could put in the word “Royal” without permission from the Queen. The Queen was sure to give it to such a worthy object, but it would be rather a bother to wait until the letter came. Arthur was vociferous in his recommendation of red ink, as being ever so much more exciting than ordinary black and white. Janet, who had once seen Papa looking at the text of the East India Company Charter, was very sure that it would not be proper unless there was a great deal of printing, all done on a real press, like a newspaper—an opinion that was not popular, since its attainment was practically impossible. Bertie begged very hard to stick the whole document shut with sealing wax, and could not understand how this might be an inconvenience in the future; while Clarence, who had a general notion that a Charter was probably something good to eat, ventured his personal opinion that it would be even better with plum buns.
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
4.70 stars (5/10 hearts). We had this when I was a kid, and we all adored it. It's so cute, with all the adorable teddies, and the lovely text, and th4.70 stars (5/10 hearts). We had this when I was a kid, and we all adored it. It's so cute, with all the adorable teddies, and the lovely text, and the wholesome little story. This is what sparked my love for cardboard houses and curtains, I think. ;) Rereading it now after so many years to my own siblings, I still love it. It's sweet and well-written, and they loved it as much as I do. :)
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). I avoided this tale for years before finally trying it “to decide if it really was a ghost tale or a dream,” as per my 2020 re5+ stars (6/10 hearts). I avoided this tale for years before finally trying it “to decide if it really was a ghost tale or a dream,” as per my 2020 review. I decided to reread it this year since I enjoyed the 1951 film so much… and I was surprised how much I loved it!
To start off, the w r i t i n g s t y l e. It’s purely amazing. Dickens is a thorough master, and he says so much in so little, and is so humorous and poignant and wise withal… honestly, I’m continually blown away by how gorgeous the writing in this book is. And then the characters. Scrooge—who is such a villain but whom you somehow love and root for. Bob Crachit and family, so sweet and simple and upright and funny. Fred, who barely appears but who’s a wonderful man. Fizziwig and Marley and Fan and Alice… all so alive! The characters are all SOOOO good.
And the plot. I subscribe to the belief that Scrooge dreamed it all (because aside from the whole ghost conversation, logically, Christmas doesn’t have a soul to become a ghost anyways. I’m pretty sure Dickens was doing a play on words with the Christmas Spirits and yes, I just figured that out). Anyways, this was a poignant reminder of how easy it is to forget the past, present, and future as we plod along our designated way. Scrooge’s mistake of turning his loneliness and worthlessness into greed for gold is a sharp warning; and the other messages besides of loving people and caring for them is beautifully illustrated. And the comments on society and Christmas are splendid.
A perfect yearly Christmas read… because we all need to remember. Seriously, it’s amazing and I reread it every Christmas. It has so, so many good messages.
A Favourite Quote: “None other of my race will find him here. What then? If he be like to die, he had better do it, and decrease the surplus population.” Scrooge hung his head to hear his own words quoted by the Spirit, and was overcome with penitence and grief. “Man, forbear that wicked cant until you have discovered What the surplus is, and Where it is. Will you decide what men shall live, what men shall die? It may be, that in the sight of Heaven, you are more worthless and less fit to live than millions like this poor man's child. Oh God! to hear the Insect on the leaf pronouncing on the too much life among his hungry brothers in the dust!” A Favourite Beautiful Quote: They were a gloomy suite of rooms, in a lowering pile of building up a yard, where it had so little business to be, that one could scarcely help fancying it must have run there when it was a young house, playing at hide-and-seek with other houses, and have forgotten the way out again. A Favourite Humorous Quote: Old Marley was as dead as a door-nail. Mind! I don't mean to say that I know, of my own knowledge, what there is particularly dead about a door-nail. I might have been inclined, myself, to regard a coffin-nail as the deadest piece of ironmongery in the trade. But the wisdom of our ancestors is in the simile; and my unhallowed hands shall not disturb it, or the Country's done for. You will therefore permit me to repeat, emphatically, that Marley was as dead as a door-nail....more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). This is my first time trying Joanna Davidson Politano, but I’ve been wanting to read her books for quite a while because they 5+ stars (6/10 hearts). This is my first time trying Joanna Davidson Politano, but I’ve been wanting to read her books for quite a while because they sounded right up my alley; and this book, anyhow, didn’t disappoint.
First off, I love the 1903 setting, especially with the filmmaking! I learned so much about the early movies. I loved the garden and all its cool parts, and the beautiful beach… and the writing style complemented everything so so well. It was so unobtrusive and so beautiful! I don’t usually enjoy modern books’ style quite this much.
I also loved the characters! Peter was such an adorable hero. He reminded me of Peter from Kellyn Roth’s Chronicles of Alice & Ivy SO much. He was just so sweet and upright and clever, and yet not flawless, because what he started out half despising he learned to appreciate by the end. He was just amazing with Lily and he loved people SO much. As for Lily—wow, she was amazing. She was so deep and layered! I hugely enjoyed slowly seeing her peel things back and admit and explain, and she kept me guessing while simultaneously letting me like her more and more. They were a wonderful couple, and their romance was so sweet and simple. Roddy was a great sidekick, despite his dislike of Lily, and I love the gardener, and the villain was SO unexpected… and I haven’t time to get into the other characters but they just FIT IN so well. <3
The plot was delightful! It was mysterious, even suspenseful, but not scary or creepy, just fascinating. It was quite twisty and so, so interwoven. I just couldn’t put the book down. And oh my STARS, I adored how much storytelling was slipped into the story. The whole constant theme of fairytales, and how it related to Lily and her past, and the allegory about God the Father, was gorgeous. I did feel like the spiritual aspect was missing a little—it was so very subtle it wasn’t quite defined, and I wasn’t satisfied—but it was certainly lovely… lovely enough to have me say this! I loved the humour, and the ending was THE BOMB.
Yes, I loved this book. <3 And I can’t wait to read more by this author!
A Favourite Quote: “Why must adults trivialize fiction so?” “Because it’s a story.” “Children instinctively know its worth, but then they grow up and view stories as a mere indulgence, relegated to those elusive ‘spare moments’ that rarely come, and it’s a shame. A shame! The value of stories cannot be measured.” A Favourite Beautiful Quote: That tender face, the heartbreak streaked across every feature. The affection as he touched the looking glass that held the fairy he’d so lovingly nurtured into being. His head tipped to one side while she, played by me, danced and talked and laughed in the other world. Forgetting the gardens, forgetting him. He was important to her, but only a piece of her world. A small fragment. Yet his attention never strayed from her. How he watched her with such longing. Such affection. Then he scattered even more brightly colored petals in the bleak world, a reminder to the fairy of the world she’d forgotten about. An invitation to return. Little breadcrumbs back to where she belonged. Breadcrumbs. Small remembrances. Little nudges and coincidences. A Favourite Humorous Quote: “Peter. What are you doing here?” “At my own estate?” He grinned. “Oh.” I grimaced and stretched. “Right.” “I’m tempted to ask the same question, but I’m rather afraid of the answer.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
Lesley Castle: An Unfinished Novel in Letters 3 stars. I didn’t find this one quite as amusing, or hugely interesting, because it was a little more serious than the first story. But it was funny, and I wish it had been finished after all! ...more
5+ stars (6/10 hearts). To be honest, it was the cover (and maybe the title) that drew me into this book. The synopsis had me a little worried. But wh5+ stars (6/10 hearts). To be honest, it was the cover (and maybe the title) that drew me into this book. The synopsis had me a little worried. But when I considered how much I’d enjoyed most of Hannah Linder’s works so far, I decided to give this one a shot—and am I ever glad I did! It might be my favourite yet.
For some reason, the book really clicked with me. I love the forest and the beautiful, mysterious mansion, and how almost everything takes place in these two settings. I love the writing style—Eliza’s narration specifically. It was so much sweeter than I expected! Still Gothic and mysterious, but more light and soft. Really, I think Eliza was my favourite thing in the book. She was so innocent and pitiful and strong, and her love for nature + her fanciful imagination was awesome. Felton was pretty epic too—the perfect opposite to Eliza, and with such a splendid character arc. I liked the Captain, even if he never appeared, and the Earl, too. And Felton’s parents were very interesting to think over. Also, the villain was terrifying and awful—but not TOO much—just short of the over-intense line for me!
And the plot was great! The Christian theme is pretty subtle, but I love the message about names and being worthy in your own right. Felton & Eliza’s romance was the sweetest, cutest thing—specially once he buckled down and admitted it, haha—and I loved how it developed from such a deep friendship and protectiveness. Everything was revealed so slowly, and you were interested in the past AND the present at the same time. I LOVE how Eliza’s memories + PTSD was developed and explained. The story was more mystery than suspense, I think, but both sides were well done. I couldn’t put the book down—read until eleven P.M. and I was too tired to continue, and picked it up first thing when I awoke! Things were very twisted and NOT what I expected (but so cool!). It was all rather different from Hannah Linder’s other books, especially as far as the climax goes, which helped it stand out more.
I’m so glad I read this. <3 It was just so SATISFYING!! The perfect blend of light and dark.
Content: Hint that a girl might be as*aulted by the villain; a side character is revealed to have frequently been a*used by a warden; a minor widowed character is caught being with another man to earn her + her children’s living; mentions of drinking; language—de*il, bl**dy, etc; 1-2 kisses; mention that dead side characters had been having an affair (false); on-screen violence involving knives and blood—personally bothered me because of the coldness and deliberateness of the villain. Much less content than I expected, overall!
A Favourite Quote: How long had he been carrying a burden that should have belonged to all of them? That did belong to all of them? Now that a new burden was upon them, should he not trust his parents were strong enough to shoulder the weight? A Favourite Beautiful Quote: How many times had she snuck out in the middle of the night, crept to the stream without candle, and sat on the Lady’s Throne to watch the moonlight on the water? The blue light flickers were moon tears, she used to pretend. She’d read in books that the moon was a man, but she couldn’t believe it was so. Anything so lovely must have been a woman. A sad, lonely woman in a sphere of blackness, who shed light tears onto the earth because not even the stars would befriend her. A Favourite Humorous Quote: “Ellis, indeed. Now that seems a bit familiar. Sort of ugly thing, was he, with missing teeth? No, no, that would be my wife’s father.”
*I received a complimentary copy of this book for promotional purposes. I was not required to write a positive review. These are my honest thoughts and opinions.*...more
Loading...
