Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly (original 1997; edition 1997)by Simms Taback (Author)This book is based off of a popular old folks tale about an old lady who swallowed a fly and then many other animals to kill the other animals she swallowed. It ends with her eating her a horse and dying from eating it. Children may find this comical or they might think it is frightening so you need to be aware of your audience. I believe this is best suited for primary readers. This story is a timeless classic about a woman who swallows an increasingly absurd number and type of animal in order to catch the previous one, all starting with an accidental eating of a fly. The rhyming and ridiculousness of the story would engage the listener/reader while also introducing them to two key math concepts--sequencing and comparison-- and the science topic of food chains, even if this food chain is not an actual one the basic idea is still there. This story uses a repeated sequence of animals that young students would be able to follow, and it also places these animals in order from smallest to largest. An eye-catching, humorous version of the American folk tale. The lettering and choice of magazine cut out typography further depicts the newspaper worthy story of an old lady who swallowed so many animals she died. I can see why parents wouldn't be a fan of this version due to the slightly distasteful death of the old woman. I find it humorous as well but would not likely read it in a story time. I really like this book for a multiple of reasons. Its is such a humorous story that and unique that can keep the reading focus throughout the entire book. It tells the story of a old lady who keeps swallowing bigger and bigger animals. This is a great guided reading story because it has a sense of rhyme that makes it easier for the students to follow. Each solution only made the problem worse. This folk poem is quite interesting and weird. I can remember reading it as a child and being in complete shock. The illustrations make the old lady seem mentally unstable, with her eyes going in different directions, but children love this book because it's so out there. The illustrations seem as if they were done on a variety of different surfaces with a variety of mediums them made into a collage on a computer. This picture book can be used to teach students about the sequencing of events. After reading the book the teacher can have cut outs of the different animals that the old lady ate and have them organize them in order. I like this book because it is repetitive and helps the students inference what is going to be said next. I really enjoyed this book for a variety of reasons, but the first reason is because of the humor it contains with the old lady swallowing all these animals from small ones to huge ones. The second reason it uses rhyme and makes it more catchy to read, and I think because even I as an adult finds it catchy to read then so will a young child. Lastly, it gives knowledge about different types of animals and allows children to see and really put in perspective how crazy and funny this book really is. I love this book because not only of the significant amount of humor that is within the book, but rather, the rich history behind the book itself. "There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed A Fly" is a captivating story that has been converted from an older folktale and song that is based off a fictional tale about an Old Lady who seems to swallow everything in sight. The story shows all of the things that she consumes through rich plot and intriguing illustrations. At the beginning of the story, the Old Lady swallows a fly; however, as the story progresses, she swallows larger objects that fill up her tummy. I love the silliness and humor that the book contains, and I think my future students will as well. Some may even know the old folktale behind the story too. I liked this book for three reasons. First, I really enjoyed the illustrations that went along with the book. Throughout the story this old lady swallows different bugs and animals. Along with the story you saw illustrations of these bugs and animals as they talked about them. When the old lady had swallowed a fly, a spider, and a bird, there was a cut out on her stomach and “inside her stomach” you can see all three of those things that were in her stomach. As the story goes on, and she swallows more animals her stomach gets larger, and they continue to show you all the bugs and animals “inside her stomach” that she has eaten. This made the story much more fun to read because you were able to see all of the previous things that she had swallowed. Another reason that I liked this book was the rhyming that occurred throughout the story. After the story says what the old lady swallowed, they end it with “Perhaps she’ll die”. On each of these pages there are other animals and bugs and next to them there are little sayings that end in something that rhymes with “die”. For example, after the old lady swallowed the fly a few of the rhyming things were, “I think I’ll cry”, “She gulped it out of the sky”, and “OH my!”. These are really funny to read as the story goes on and some of them talk about how they feel about her swallowing these things. My final reason why I liked this book was because of the way the book flows. There is a lot of repetition in the story, as more animals/bugs get added to the list of things that the old lady swallowed. In the story after the old lady swallows a dog the writer says “She swallowed the dog to catch the cat. She swallowed the cat to catch the bird. She swallowed the bird to catch the spider. She swallowed the spider to catch the fly. I don’t know why she swallowed the fly. Perhaps she’ll die.” In the beginning of the story this was very short because she had only swallowed one or two things. As the story goes on this gets longer. At the end of the story it says that the moral is to “never swallow a horse”. This is because the old lady dies when she swallows the horse, but obviously no one can do this. This story goes along with the old folk song, but this adds illustrations to the story. I believe that the big idea of this story is just for children to enjoy the book, and get a little humor out of it. The illustrations make it easy and fun to picture the story, unlike the original old folk song. |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)782.421622100268The arts Music Vocal music Secular Forms of vocal music Secular songs General principles and musical forms Song genres Folk songs Folk songs of British, English, Anglo-Saxons Folk songs of the British IslesLC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |
I really enjoyed this book because of how silly the plot is. Having a lady swallow a fly is silly enough but then she swallows a whole bunch of other animals. For a young reader, having a character eat such ridiculous things is quite silly and makes the book a bit more interesting for them. I also enjoyed that the book was very repetitive, only certain parts of the book change from page to page. Since it’s so repetitive, it allows a very young child to be part of the reading, enhancing their confidence in reading and desire to learn how to read.
Not only did I enjoy the plot and the repetitiveness of the book, I also enjoyed the illustrations of this book. I thought it was fun to have parts of the page cut out so a part of the previous page showed through. I think this is an excellent, fun feature for young readers because they can see how the previous page is connected to the current page. ( )