Angela M is taking a break.'s Reviews > Clear

Clear by Carys Davies
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4685500
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: netgalley-reviews, 2023-favorites

This felt like the kind of story that might have been written many decades ago, one that might have been read in school, one that reflects a profound truth about human nature and our need to connect to each other, one that has a classic feel, one with a stunning ending that encourages faith in humanity. Two historical events in 1840’s Scotland set this quiet, introspective novel in motion - the split in the Scottish Church and the Clearances as the author describes in her notes where “whole communities of the rural poor were removed from their homes by landowners in a relentless program of coercive and systematic dispossession to make way for crops, cattle and increasingly as time went on - sheep.” I knew nothing about either of these. The beauty of learning through well written historical fiction. It’s a short novel, so I’m not going to go into detail of the plot. The book description tells much of it.

I wanted to read this because I loved West by Davies. While very different stories, I found the beautiful atmospheric writing and a deep reflection of what loneliness feels like. This is worth reading for the writing, the thought provoking and touching ending and characters who will stay with me.


I received a copy of this book from Scribner through NetGalley.
201 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Clear.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 11, 2023 – Shelved
September 11, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
October 6, 2023 – Started Reading
October 9, 2023 – Shelved as: netgalley-reviews
October 9, 2023 – Finished Reading
December 24, 2023 – Shelved as: 2023-favorites

Comments Showing 1-50 of 63 (63 new)


Diane S ☔ Beautiful review, Angela.


message 2: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa ~ Bantering Books Yay for the five stars! I have this one coming up, Angela, and I'm really looking forward to it.


Angela M is taking a break. Diane, thanks so much.


Angela M is taking a break. Melissa, thanks! I’ll be looking for your thoughts .


message 5: by Kathleen (new) - added it

Kathleen What a wonderful review, Angela. I must add this now!


message 6: by Martha☀ (new)

Martha☀ Fascinating! I don't know much about the clearances. I'll add it . Thanks for your compelling review.


Cathrine ☯️ Oh Boy! Love those stars. I felt the same way about West. Great review A.


Cheri Love your review, Angela! As you know, I loved this one, loved how atmospheric it was, and loved the beauty of the prose, as well.


Angela M is taking a break. Kathleen wrote: "What a wonderful review, Angela. I must add this now!"

Kathleen , thanks so much. I think you’ll appreciate it.


Angela M is taking a break. Martha☀ wrote: "Fascinating! I don't know much about the clearances. I'll add it . Thanks for your compelling review."

Martha, I didn’t know anything about it, so this was an enlightening read as well as a beautiful story.


Angela M is taking a break. Cathrine ☯️ wrote: "Oh Boy! Love those stars. I felt the same way about West. Great review A."

C, I think since you loved West , you will appreciate this one.


Angela M is taking a break. Cheri wrote: "Love your review, Angela! As you know, I loved this one, loved how atmospheric it was, and loved the beauty of the prose, as well."

Cheri, thanks so much. No surprise we both loved it.


message 13: by Connie (new) - added it

Connie G Lovely review. The book sounds wonderful!


message 14: by Carmel (new) - added it

Carmel Hanes Touching review, Angela.


message 15: by Bianca (new) - added it

Bianca Splendid review, Angela. I haven't read Davies yet.


Canadian Jen I haven’t read West yet but I need to add this one now too. Great review, Angela


message 17: by Jodi (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jodi Very lovely review, Angela! I've been meaning to read West for years now and I'm very sorry I failed to do it before Clear was published. Your reviews of both, however, compel me to keep trying! I wish I could read much faster so I could read MORE!!😣


message 18: by Teres (new)

Teres The beauty of learning through well written historical fiction.

THIS is why I enjoy reading historical fiction as an adult, Angela. I've learned so many things they never taught us in school.


Angela M is taking a break. Carmel, Connie, Bianca, Jen and Teres, thanks so much.


Angela M is taking a break. Jodi wrote: "Very lovely review, Angela! I've been meaning to read West for years now and I'm very sorry I failed to do it before Clear was published. Your reviews of both, howe..."

Jodi, thanks so much. My reading has declined over the last year - sometimes life throws you a curve and I don’t read as much as I used to . I used to read 2-3 books a week, but now it’s one. I’m disappointed that I can’t focus on more because I have so many books I want to read so I hear you. This year I decided that I would focus on quality and read books by authors who I love or books that I’m reasonably sure (although you never know) that I’ll enjoy. So far I’ve been able to read some wonderful books this year, but not as many as I would like .


message 21: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Wow! Your review makes this book sound irresistible, Angela!


Angela M is taking a break. Candi , thanks! If you read it I’ll be interested in your thoughts as always.


message 23: by Laysee (new)

Laysee A wonderful review, Angela. We do indeed learn much from good historical fiction. I'm glad this one was memorable.


Angela M is taking a break. Laysee , thanks so much!


message 25: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa I've got this one on my list, so I'm delighted to see those 5 Stars. I'm popping over to see your review of West, a work with which I am not familiar.


message 26: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura Yes - land clearances - I think that's the basis of Sir Walter Scott's - Rob Roy.


Angela M is taking a break. Lisa, I’ll be interested in your!


Angela M is taking a break. Laura, I have not read Rob Roy so so was unaware.


Karen I’m so glad that you loved it, Angela! Wonderful review! Ivar 💕


Angela M is taking a break. Karen, thanks so much. Loved Ivar and John , but Mary was my favorite character.


Pamela I was considering reading this title, but now have placed it on my every growing to read list. A lovely review. Will have to consider West by the author as well.


Angela M is taking a break. Pamela, thanks so much . I’ll be interesting in your thoughts.


message 33: by Debbie (new)

Debbie Terrific review, Angela! Your enthusiasm shines!


Angela M is taking a break. Debbie, thanks so much!


message 35: by Debra (new)

Debra Terrific review, Angela!


Angela M is taking a break. Debra, thanks very much.


message 37: by Jaidee (new) - added it

Jaidee Gorgeous review Angela...I am going to go see if this is still available on NG.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much , Jaidee . It’s not going to be published until 2024 , so hope you can get a copy!


message 39: by *TUDOR^QUEEN* (new)

*TUDOR^QUEEN* Beautiful review... So glad you enjoyed it 😉


message 40: by Antoinette (new) - added it

Antoinette Awesome review, Angela! I was just in Scotland in August- I’d love to read this book if only to be transported back there. Such a beautiful country.


message 41: by Tundra (new) - added it

Tundra Sounds interesting Angela. The events in Scotland led to a lot of Scottish people migrating and taking up landholdings in Australia (and probably elsewhere) . Sometimes at great detriment to the indigenous inhabitants. Unfortunately this knock on effect seems to be all to familiar.


Angela M is taking a break. TQ, thanks so much .


Angela M is taking a break. Antoinette, thanks! This was definitely an atmospheric read . So glad you enjoyed your trip.


Angela M is taking a break. Tundra, thanks foe your comment. So much world history that I’m not aware of .


message 45: by Susan (new) - added it

Susan I don't know anything about West or Clear, thanks for putting it on my radar!


Angela M is taking a break. Susan , hope they work for you if you do read them .


message 47: by Melissa (new) - added it

Melissa Crytzer Fry Another one waiting for me that I'm very excited to read, after seeing your review, Angela. I, too, loved WEST and look forward to this because I certainly need some faith in humanity at this point!


Angela M is taking a break. Melissa, we all need some faith in humanity about now , for sure . I will be looking your thoughts! Thanks !


Lisa (NY) Angela, I love your phrase "the beauty of learning through well written historical fiction." This novel transported me to an unfamiliar world.


Angela M is taking a break. Lisa, sorry I missed your post . Thanks so much !


« previous 1
back to top