Angela M is taking a break.'s Reviews > Lady Tan’s Circle of Women

Lady Tan’s Circle of Women by Lisa See
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4685500
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2023-favorites, edelweiss-reviews

In each of the seven novels I have read by Lisa See, I always find it enlightening to learn so much about Chinese culture, families, history . While that focus pays tribute to her heritage and especially to strong women, she’s a versatile writer, telling stories of women in various times and places in varied circumstances. This one begins in 1469 during the Ming dynasty, in the time of bound feet, arranged marriages and concubines. The story is inspired by a real life woman doctor, Yunxian Tan, whose books today are “still used today in traditional Chinese Medicine “

The book opens when Yunxian Tan is eight, learning from her mother what her place in the future as a dutiful wife will be . The descriptions of the foot binding, while fascinating are brutal seeing what young girls endured to make them desirable and for the sake of proving one’s love for her husband. There’s more for her to learn, though. Yunxian is from a family of privilege and scholars, and when she comes to live in the elegant mansion of her loving grandparents, she becomes a part of the family legacy of practicing medicine. She learns more from her grandmother more than how to treat women. “You must speak if you wish to be heard.” The story continues through her life as a wife and mother and doctor.

There’s so much substance to this story. The history of the times where power, riches, land are dependent on having sons puts a focus on women giving birth and concubines. The power of friendship, of women caring for each other is portrayed in wonderful ways. The writing is lovely. The descriptions of the residences “The Garden of Fragrant Delights” , “The Courtyard of Whispering Willows”, and her use of actual phrasing of the times - “a resident is dwelling in her child palace” for being pregnant.

While this is a work of fiction, it’s obvious from the acknowledgements that the novel is impeccably researched, and if you are inclined to know more, go to LisaSee.com where she provides us all the background one might want on the culture, customs, traditional Chinese medicine and more that are portrayed in the novel . This is my favorite of hers yet.

I received a copy of this book from Scribner through Edelweiss.
330 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Lady Tan’s Circle of Women.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 15, 2023 – Shelved
January 15, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
July 21, 2023 – Started Reading
July 26, 2023 – Shelved as: edelweiss-reviews
July 26, 2023 – Shelved as: 2023-favorites
July 26, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 76 (76 new)


Debra I look forward to your thoughts, Angela. I hope you are enjoying it.


Angela M is taking a break. Debra, I’m am loving it ! I think this is my favorite See novel so far . I’ve read 6 . I’ll circle back to your review when I’m finished.


Cathrine ☯️ Good to hear. We're doing a buddy read on this in August. I've been hit & miss with See in the past and it's been a while. Long wait list at the library.


Canadian Jen YES!!! Awesome...can't wait for your thoughts. I'm reading this next as I adore See as well.


message 5: by Carol (last edited Jul 26, 2023 03:25PM) (new) - added it

Carol Yay! I've just downloaded this one, and I love your 5 stars!


Linda Absolutely, Angela. It was a stellar 5 Stars for me, too. ;)


Karen Yay! Starting this tomorrow!


message 8: by Antoinette (new)

Antoinette Wow, high praise. Consider me interested.


Teres Wow, best yet? Can't wait to read your review, Angela!


message 10: by Christine (new)

Christine Isn’t it great when a favorite author is still soaring with book 7? Beautiful! And beautiful review, Angela!


message 11: by Heather (new) - added it

Heather Thank you for this descriptive, wonderful review! Adding to my TBR!


message 12: by Candi (new) - added it

Candi Wonderful review, Angela! Your favorite yet says a lot about the quality of this book. I've read one of her books so far and was greatly impressed. It seems I should catch up on her backlist and make my way towards this one :)


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks, everyone. It’s a fantastic novel and I highly recommend it !


Angela M is taking a break. Heather, thanks! Hope you enjoy.


Angela M is taking a break. Candi, thanks so much . She’s definitely worth reading. This one just offered so much . Hope you continue to enjoy others of hers that you read.


Carmel Hanes Beautiful review! I've only read Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, many years ago. It had foot binding in it, too, and I'll never forget it.


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader I absolutely love that this is your favorite of hers yet, Angela. I can’t wait to pick it up to learn more. I enjoyed reading your thoughts, as always.


message 18: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Wonderful review!


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks, Carmel ! I read and enjoyed that one ,too.


Angela M is taking a break. Jennifer, thanks very much . Hope you enjoy it !


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much, s.


message 22: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee I can SEE that you are a huge fan !


message 23: by Jodi (new) - added it

Jodi Terrific review, Angela!! My sister loves this author, too, and I bought the book for her last week. Just now, I forwarded your review to her, as well, because I know how much she likes reading them. (She's the historical fiction reader of the two of us.)😊


Lisa (NY) Terrific review Angela, I agree - there is so much substance here.


Angela M is taking a break. Jaidee , very good! I am!


Angela M is taking a break. Jodi , thanks very . If your sister is a fan, I think she’ll love this one .


Angela M is taking a break. Lisa, thanks so much. Glad we both enjoyed it .


Diane S ☔ Fabulous review, Angela. Sounds a bit like Amy Tans, Bonesetter's daughter. Will compare after I read this.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much , Diane. I read Tan’s book , too. Similar if I recall, but this one is just so expansive in terms of things portrayed . So good!


message 30: by Missy (new)

Missy LeBlanc Ivey Great review! I absolutely LOVE her writing and story telling.


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much, Missy.


message 32: by Martha☀ (new)

Martha☀ Such a lovely in-depth review, Angela. Thank you!


Angela M is taking a break. Martha, thank you so much!


Stephanie ~~ Fantastic review!! I loved this so much. Another fantastic hit out of the ballpark for Lisa! ~


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks so much , Stephanie . She’s a fabulous writer!


message 36: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Splendid review, Angela.


message 37: by Susan (new)

Susan Chapek I've read most of her books, too. Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is my favorite, and I'm looking forward to reading another historical set in the even more distant past.


Angela M is taking a break. Bianca, thanks very much.


Angela M is taking a break. Susan , I enjoyed that one , too , but as I mentioned this is my favorite. Hope you enjoy it !


message 40: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Fab review, Angela. A work like this has historical and cultural value.


message 41: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Snowflower and the Secret Fan is my favorite of See's works so far. I am encouraged to hear that you loved this one even more. The perspective on Chinese medicine is also appealing to me. As always, I enjoyed reading your review.


message 42: by Jonetta (new) - added it

Jonetta Excellent review, Angela💜 I’m in a long library queue for this one because I took too long thinking about it.


Angela M is taking a break. Laysee, thanks so much . I couldn’t agree more . There’s much depth here.


Angela M is taking a break. Lisa, I enjoyed that one , too. The traditional Chinese medicine aspect is fascinating . Thanks so much.


Angela M is taking a break. Jonetta, thanks very much. I hope you get it and that you enjoy it, too !


Karen Wonderful review Angela!
I was completely engrossed in this novel.. just loved it! The only other book I had read by her was The Tea Girls of Hummingbird Lane.


Angela M is taking a break. Karen, so glad you loved it, too! I think you would enjoy some others as well. Thanks so much .


message 48: by Sara (new)

Sara Your always stunning reviews make me want to read EVERYTHING.


Marianne I learned so much, too… the author’s style of writing connects me to her characters & setting so well.


Angela M is taking a break. Sara, you made my day with your lovely comment . Thanks so much.


« previous 1
back to top