Angela M is taking a break.'s Reviews > A Council of Dolls

A Council of Dolls by Mona Susan Power
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4685500
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: edelweiss-reviews, 2023-favorites

While I reading this book, it was nominated for the National Book Award . I can see why. I’ve been thinking about this so much the last two days, I upped my rating. 4.5 stars rounded up.

“There is no true healing without remembering…”

A legacy of trauma as a result of brutality, abuse, loss, war, prejudice. A reflection of the Native American experience through three generations of Dakhota women and their dolls who are their companions and confidants who see and sense and speak . A child’s imagination or spirits? There are other spirit encounters with ancestors. There are visions. I just accepted them as part of the story.

Through six year old Sissy in 1960’s and Ethel, her black Thumbelina doll, through her mother Lillian in the 1930’s and her Shirley Temple doll named Mae and through Cora, her grandmother and her Native doll Winona, Power tells a haunting, powerful and important story. The Indian boarding school experience seems to have come to light more and more recently and it’s imperative that we not just remember, but bear witness to what happened to so many Native American children.The last part of this novel with stories of the three dolls was gutting, stunning actually. This is difficult to read, but it’s imperative to acknowledge this history.

The author in her note:
“While this book is a work of fiction and it characters a product of my imagination, some of the experiences depicted in these pages are inspired by stories my mother shared with me about what it was like growing up on the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation…”

“From earliest memory I've been familiar with the history of the devastating Indiar Boarding School experience. Both grandparents on my mother's side of the family attended the Carlisle Indian Industrial School.”

https://carlisleindianschoolproject.com/

I received a copy of this book from HarperCollins through Edelweiss.
86 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read A Council of Dolls.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 22, 2022 – Shelved
November 22, 2022 – Shelved as: to-read
September 10, 2023 – Started Reading
September 17, 2023 – Shelved as: edelweiss-reviews
September 17, 2023 – Finished Reading
October 1, 2023 – Shelved as: 2023-favorites

Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Melissa Crytzer Fry OOOh. I'm going to read this next, I think! Can't wait to hear your thoughts!


Angela M is taking a break. Just about to start it ! Looks good .


Melissa Crytzer Fry Angela M wrote: "Just about to start it ! Looks good ."It really, really does! I'm excited.


Jodi Definitely want to read this. I'm looking forward to your review, Angela!


Canadian Jen I love that these came from the stories the author's mom shared. Not that we needed further validation that the horrors took place, but from a personal perspective there is always such a greater impact. This is a great review, Angela. I wasn't sure about adding, but now I am.


message 6: by Kendall (new)

Kendall Fabulous review Angela!!!


Cheri Wonderful review, Angela! This was such a heartbreaking read at times, but such an important one, as well.


Melissa Crytzer Fry This is next up for me, I think! I love your review.


Angela M is taking a break. Jen, thanks so much . I wasn’t sure if I’d get into the part that the dolls take in the story, but it’s really an interesting mechanism to tell the story. I just accepted it and wow ! What a story. I’ll be interested in seeing what you think.


Angela M is taking a break. Kendall, thanks so much.


Angela M is taking a break. Cheri , thanks very much. The truth of our history is so many times hard to read about , but definitely important.


Angela M is taking a break. Melissa, thanks so much. I will definitely look for your thoughts.


message 13: by Carmel (new) - added it

Carmel Hanes I could not agree more about the need to bear witness. To hold this terrible history close to our hearts. Stunning review, my friend.


message 14: by Jodi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jodi Beautiful review, Angela! From the many books I've read by Canadian First Nations authors, it seems that all their relatives, once passed, become part of the ancestor spirits who watch over them and impart knowledge to them through dreams and dream-like encounters. Ancestors are a valuable resource for knowledge and for comfort. I only wish it could be the same for all of us - Indigenous and non-Indigenous alike.💖


message 15: by Lisa (new) - added it

Lisa Angela M wrote: "Jen, thanks so much . I wasn’t sure if I’d get into the part that the dolls take in the story, but it’s really an interesting mechanism to tell the story. I just accepted it and wow ! What a story...."

Angela, I wondered about how those dolls would work in this story and hesitated to add for that reason. You've convinced me that this aspect was handled well so I'll give it a try.


Angela M is taking a break. Carmel, thanks so much , my friend!


Angela M is taking a break. Jodi, thanks very much. I agree as I’ve read some books which reflect the same thing. An important part of the Native culture and definitely important for this story.


Angela M is taking a break. Lisa, I think Jodi gets it right in her comment with regard to the importance of spirits and ancestors in the Native culture. At first I thought it would impact my ability to get into this story , but then I realized the important thing was the story that’s told. And it is so important to remember.


message 19: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue Great review, Angela. I just added this to my list. Don’t know how I am going to decide what to read from now on. Too many to choose from!


Angela M is taking a break. Sue wrote: "Great review, Angela. I just added this to my list. Don’t know how I am going to decide what to read from now on. Too many to choose from!"

Sue, I know exactly what you mean. I have a hard time deciding with so many ! Thanks . This is a good one, though :).


message 21: by Sue (new) - added it

Sue It really sounds like it’s right up my alley, so to speak. My library has it too.


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Wow, Angela. This is definitely a can’t-miss for me. I loved reading your thoughts.


Angela M is taking a break. Sue, I’ll be interested in what you think !


Angela M is taking a break. Jennifer, thanks! It’s definitely a do not miss .


message 25: by Phyllis (new) - added it

Phyllis Runyan Great review, Angela. I know I'm going to love it.


Angela M is taking a break. Phyllis, thanks ! I hope you do love it.


message 27: by Maricarmen (new) - added it

Maricarmen Estrada M Fantastic review, Angela! I had no idea about the topic from the title of the book. It seems very interesting!


Angela M is taking a break. Thanks , Maricarmen. I definitely had to read the description to have an idea of what the dolls meant .


message 29: by Antoinette (new)

Antoinette Wonderful review, Angela! It’s always so sad to consider all the horrible things that have occurred to Native Americans.


Linda Beautiful review, Angela. Really enjoyed this one as well. Can't wait for more from this talented author. ;)


Angela M is taking a break. Antoinette and Linda, sorry I missed your comments. Thanks so much.


Sallie Dunn A lovely review, Angela. Thanks for enlightening me about this book. First that I’ve heard of it.


message 33: by Laysee (new)

Laysee What an important piece of fiction inspired by history! An informative review, Angela.


Angela M is taking a break. Sallie and Laysee , thanks very much.


message 35: by Jenna (new) - added it

Jenna Dying to read this, thank you for sharing your thoughts!


Angela M is taking a break. Jenna, hope you enjoy it , too !


Melissa Crytzer Fry I loved your review, Angela. This is one of my favorite reads this year. I know you don't often do well with magical realism, but am happy to hear that this one was a good fit and you were willing to suspend disbelief. It was phenomenal! Fabulous review.


Angela M is taking a break. Melissa, thanks very . I can take it in small doses, especially when it is a perfect fit like it was here .


Melissa Crytzer Fry Angela M wrote: "Melissa, thanks very . I can take it in small doses, especially when it is a perfect fit like it was here ."It really was a terrific vehicle for the story content. Genius.


message 40: by Jaidee (new) - added it

Jaidee Thanx so much for convincing me to add Angela !


Angela M is taking a break. Hope you enjoy it, Jaidee!


back to top