MarilynW's Reviews > Cilka's Journey

Cilka's Journey by Heather   Morris
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
49815208
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: netgalley, netgalley-2020

Cilka's Journey (The Tattooist of Auschwitz #2) by Heather Morris

I did not mean take so long to finally read this Advanced Read Copy but once I received it, I felt very uncomfortable tackling a book about the Holocaust. Finally I read a couple of books that touched on the Holocaust and felt ready to read this book. But first, I read The Tattooist of Auschwitz, as my introduction to this book. After The Tattooist of Auschwitz, I wanted to know what happened to Cilka, after the liberation of the concentration camp, in 1945.  I read this book as historical fiction, with the emphasis on fiction, because so little was really known about Cilka and there are so many articles that discuss conflicting information about Cilka, her actions and even her existence. 

Having said all of that, I enjoyed this book despite it's gruesome subject matter. Cilka, of this story and the first one, survived the concentration camp by not fighting back with her captors. She was raped regularly by officers high in the chain of command and because they had "claimed" her, she was in charge of Block 25, the barracks where the women who were going into the gas chambers slept one more night, before being loaded into the trucks to be driven to their deaths. When the camps were liberated, Cilka was sentenced to 15 years in a Siberian gulag, for sleeping with the enemy but her role as the head of Block 25 was the role that haunted her even more than the fact she didn't fight back while being raped. 

Once at the gulag, Cilka tries to remain unseen, unnoticed but she quickly is chosen by a powerful prisoner to be his property, so she is once again raped regularly but safe from the gang rapes that happened to other women. Cilka's knowledge of many languages and her ability to learn quickly also kept her from hard labor because she was chosen to work with the doctors and nurses in the prisoner medical facility. Always, Cilka remembered her life and role at Auschwitz and feared that her fellow prisoners would find out about her former life. But the memory of her former life also drove her to do all she could to help her fellow inmates. 

The real live Soviet gulags were as bad as the Nazi concentration camps, even if they didn't have the gas chambers, ovens, and medical experiments. The prisoners were slaves, to be starved and worked to death and replaced by more slaves, there were always more bodies to replace those that fell. I'd been unaware of the details of places like this and now I know about one more historical horror. Cilka's Journey is a moving story and I'm glad I read it. 

Pub October 1, 2019

Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for this ARC.
254 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Cilka's Journey.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 28, 2019 – Shelved
October 8, 2020 – Started Reading
October 12, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 54 (54 new)


Sheyla ✎ I have not read the first one, but it is on my list.


MarilynW Sheyla ✎ wrote: "I have not read the first one, but it is on my list."

The audio is good on both of these books. You don't have to read the first one to enjoy the second one but Cilka knew the tattooist and his girlfriend/wife at the concentration camp, so there is some crossover. I'm about a 1/3 into Cilka's Journey and I'm enjoying it a lot.


message 3: by Jayme (new)

Jayme Always heartbreaking! 💔


Maureen ( NOT RECEIVING NOTIFICATIONS) Heartbreaking subject but lovely review Marilyn 😢


Lindsay L Terrific review of this excellent book Marilyn! I also learned a lot through Cilka’s story.


MarilynW Jayme wrote: "Always heartbreaking! 💔"

Yes 😧💗


MarilynW Maureen wrote: "Heartbreaking subject but lovely review Marilyn 😢"

Thank you, Maureen. I've been appreciating every little thing, because of this book and books like it.


MarilynW Lindsay - Traveling Sisters Book Reviews wrote: "Terrific review of this excellent book Marilyn! I also learned a lot through Cilka’s story."


Thank you, Lindsay. I really did a lot of research while reading the Tattooist of Auschwitz, which helped me a lot when reading this book.


message 9: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Harrowing story. 😌


Andrea Not read this book yet,I do read alot of these types of books they are harrowing but a story that should be read and to never happen again.good review Marilyn. 🌹


Cheri Excellent review for a heartbreaking story, Marilyn.


MarilynW Barbara wrote: "Harrowing story. 😌"

Yes, I can't even imagine, it's so horrible.


MarilynW Andrea wrote: "Not read this book yet,I do read alot of these types of books they are harrowing but a story that should be read and to never happen again.good review Marilyn. 🌹"

Thank you, Andrea! I think it's gotten a bit easier to read these stories, once I started, not because I've gotten used to them but because I don't want to forget these things happen/happened.


MarilynW Cheri wrote: "Excellent review for a heartbreaking story, Marilyn."

Thanks so much, Cheri!


message 15: by Carol (new)

Carol Wow! This sounds like a heart-wrenching read, marilyn.


MarilynW Carol wrote: "Wow! This sounds like a heart-wrenching read, marilyn."

Yes it was Carol. There were even babies born in the Siberian prisons. Just so much heartache.


message 17: by NZLisaM (new)

NZLisaM Fantastic review. I need to read this one, and The Tattooist of Auschwitz.


MarilynW NZLisaM wrote: "Fantastic review. I need to read this one, and The Tattooist of Auschwitz."

Thank you Lisa. Read the Tattooist first because it introduces Cilka. I actually listened to the audios of both books and they were really good.


Tina (not receiving notifications!) This was a fabulous review Marilyn. I still need to read this one (and the first one too!)


message 20: by Pat (new)

Pat Awesome review Marilyn. From what I’ve seen, harrowing as the story is, there is some doubt about the authenticity of Cilka. That doesn’t take anything away from the book. I’m sure it is very well written. The gulags were awful. Clearly you didn’t read any Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn, one of his books was a required text in high school. I’ve never forgotten it. He was a celebrated Russian Author who really did suffer in a gulag


Marilyn (recuperating from hip replacement surgery Fabulous review, marilyn, of a most heart breaking story. It is so hard to believe that after all she went through during the Holocaust she had to endure even more. I enjoyed learning about her story as well.


MarilynW Tina wrote: "This was a fabulous review Marilyn. I still need to read this one (and the first one too!)"

Thank you, Tina. I'm glad I could read both books close together.


MarilynW Pat wrote: "Awesome review Marilyn. From what I’ve seen, harrowing as the story is, there is some doubt about the authenticity of Cilka. That doesn’t take anything away from the book. I’m sure it is very well ..."

That's why I read this as fiction, I'd read so much about the controversy but still wanted to read the book. I just read more about Solzhenitsyn and learned about the Holodomor, which wasn't something I knew about.


MarilynW Marilyn wrote: "Fabulous review, marilyn, of a most heart breaking story. It is so hard to believe that after all she went through during the Holocaust she had to endure even more. I enjoyed learning about her sto..."

Thank you, Marilyn. Life was hard for those who survived to be released from the gulags, too, because often the ex prisoners were not allowed to settle near large cities or take certain jobs.


DeAnn Terrific review Marilyn. I thought is so unfair that the camp was liberated but Cilka was punished even more. I'm glad Facebook finally announced they would ban content on holocaust deniers this week. I'm amazed people think that, but they wouldn't read a book like this to be educated.


MarilynW DeAnn wrote: "Terrific review Marilyn. I thought is so unfair that the camp was liberated but Cilka was punished even more. I'm glad Facebook finally announced they would ban content on holocaust deniers this we..."

Thank you, DeAnn. I don't want to forget what happened and have no understanding of those who deny the Holocaust.


message 27: by Ceecee (new) - added it

Ceecee Fantastic review and a very moving story ❤️


Richard (on hiatus) A fine review Marilyn ......... this subject is always hard to read about - I do have these books and will read them when the time is right.


MarilynW Ceecee wrote: "Fantastic review and a very moving story ❤️"

Thank you, Ceecee. 💗


MarilynW Richard wrote: "A fine review Marilyn ......... this subject is always hard to read about - I do have these books and will read them when the time is right."

I understand so well, Richard. I had this book for well over a year, as an Advanced Read Copy, but once I got it I couldn't bring myself to read it. Then something made me want to read The Tattooist of Auschwitz and doing soe made me able to read this book.


message 31: by *TUDOR^QUEEN* (new)

*TUDOR^QUEEN* Sounds horrific but great review 😍


MarilynW *TUDOR^QUEEN* wrote: "Sounds horrific but great review 😍"

Thank you, TQ...it gave me a lot to think about and set me off research the history of gulags.


Meredith (Trying to catch up!) Fantastic review, Marilyn! This sounds difficult to read, but it sounds like it is worth it!


MarilynW Meredith wrote: "Fantastic review, Marilyn! This sounds difficult to read, but it sounds like it is worth it!"

Thank you, Meredith!


Dorie  - Cats&Books :) wonderful review Marilyn, I can see why you put it off though, difficult to read especially during these times!


MarilynW Dorie - Cats&Books :) wrote: "wonderful review Marilyn, I can see why you put it off though, difficult to read especially during these times!"

Thank you, Dorie, it was about as far from light reading as I could get. 😧


message 37: by Beata (new)

Beata Fine review, Marilyn :)) Not the book for me, but I enjoyed your thoughts :)


MarilynW Beata wrote: "Fine review, Marilyn :)) Not the book for me, but I enjoyed your thoughts :)"

Thank you, Beata 💗


message 39: by Bridgett (new)

Bridgett Beautifully written review, Marilyn! I'm not sure this is a book I'd want to dive into, but I did appreciate your thoughts. 💗


MarilynW Bridgett wrote: "Beautifully written review, Marilyn! I'm not sure this is a book I'd want to dive into, but I did appreciate your thoughts. 💗"

Thank you, Bridgett...these books are difficult to read but right now I seem to be able to read them. 💕


message 41: by JanB (new)

JanB I’m glad you read it and appreciated it despite it being a difficult read. Wonderful review Marilyn!


MarilynW JanB wrote: "I’m glad you read it and appreciated it despite it being a difficult read. Wonderful review Marilyn!"

Thank you, Jan...many books fade in my memory, after a while, but I know this one and The Tattooist will stay in my mind for a very long time. 💗


Debbie W. Lovely review, Marilyn! I enjoyed this one more than The Tattooist of Auschwitz.


MarilynW Debbie wrote: "Lovely review, Marilyn! I enjoyed this one more than The Tattooist of Auschwitz."

Thank you, Debbie...it's hard for me to separate these two books because I did so much research on both books and the controversies surrounding them and listened to them close together. Heading to your review now 😁


Kimmylongtime This review is amazing and a perfect depiction of these style of stories. It seems it is harder to separate the fact from fiction. The subject matter is extremely rough but I love everything history and seeing it depicted in fiction. Happy reading 📖


MarilynW Kemora wrote: "This review is amazing and a perfect depiction of these style of stories. It seems it is harder to separate the fact from fiction. The subject matter is extremely rough but I love everything histor..."

Thank you, Kemora...I love that these books have me digging deep to find out the facts that are known. We can't really know what went on but I do enjoy historical fiction, so much, for how it makes me learn more about history.


Mary Beth has lots of catching up to do! Terrific review! Glad you enjoyed this one too. 💗


MarilynW Mary Beth wrote: "Terrific review! Glad you enjoyed this one too. 💗"

Thank you, Mary Beth! 💕


message 49: by Shelley (new)

Shelley Lawrence I’m completely hesitant to read it for the same reasons.


MarilynW Shelley wrote: "I’m completely hesitant to read it for the same reasons."

Shelley, they are very difficult to read. My mind can hardly take it all in. 😳


« previous 1
back to top