Lorna's Reviews > Cold Mountain
Cold Mountain
by
by
Lorna's review
bookshelves: american-south, civil-war, southern-literary-trail, historical-fiction, national-book-awards-finalists, history, appalachia
Apr 17, 2023
bookshelves: american-south, civil-war, southern-literary-trail, historical-fiction, national-book-awards-finalists, history, appalachia
Cold Mountain is the heartbreakingly beautiful and breath-taking debut novel by Charles Frazier purportedly based on the local history and family folklore passed down for generations in his family. Frazier grew up in the Blue Ridge mountains of North Carolina and in the shadow of Cold Mountain. But Cold Mountain was the also debut opera score written by Pulitzer Prize-winning composer, Jennifer Higdon, who coincidentally also grew up in Appalachia. We were so excited to be able to attend the World Premiere of Cold Mountain in August 2015 at the Santa Fe Opera just north of Santa Fe. We were there on the night of the final performance when, just as the conductor came on stage, there were huge claps of thunder followed by the skies lighting up the stage as it is an open-air theater with a stunning backdrop of the beautiful Sangre de Christo mountains of Northern New Mexico. It was a superb performance and evening with the impeccable timing of the thunder and lightning to coincide with the opera script and musical score in this unique setting and written to mark the 150th anniversary of the American Civil War.
Now, many years later, I am finally reading the historical fiction novel by Charles Frazier that is so beautifully and elegantly told. Frazier found his inspiration for what he calls his "American odyssey" along with the area's unique history. Frazier has said that his family has lived in the hills of North Carolina for over two-hundred years. At the core of this story is a tale of survival. It is the story of a Confederate soldier and deserter in 1865. We witness Inman's long and perilous journey as he walks home to his beloved Ada Monroe at the close of the Civil War. He is witness to the vast devastation suffered in the South as the Confederates are close to defeat. The book unfolds in alternate chapters with Inman and his struggles versus Ada and Ruby and their struggles to revive her father's failing farm after his death. Ruby has had to struggle to survive from a young age but with her Native American roots, she has a connection to the land and shares her wisdom with Ada who works along side her tirelessly. There is a bond that forms between these two women. At the stunning conclusion of this Odysseus-like tale, Inman and Ada have to confront the transformation that has occurred in each of their lives.
Now, many years later, I am finally reading the historical fiction novel by Charles Frazier that is so beautifully and elegantly told. Frazier found his inspiration for what he calls his "American odyssey" along with the area's unique history. Frazier has said that his family has lived in the hills of North Carolina for over two-hundred years. At the core of this story is a tale of survival. It is the story of a Confederate soldier and deserter in 1865. We witness Inman's long and perilous journey as he walks home to his beloved Ada Monroe at the close of the Civil War. He is witness to the vast devastation suffered in the South as the Confederates are close to defeat. The book unfolds in alternate chapters with Inman and his struggles versus Ada and Ruby and their struggles to revive her father's failing farm after his death. Ruby has had to struggle to survive from a young age but with her Native American roots, she has a connection to the land and shares her wisdom with Ada who works along side her tirelessly. There is a bond that forms between these two women. At the stunning conclusion of this Odysseus-like tale, Inman and Ada have to confront the transformation that has occurred in each of their lives.
". . . . You will be living fitfully. Your soul will fade to blue, the color of despair. Your spirit will wane and dwindle away, never to reappear. Your path lies toward the Nightland. This is your path. There is no other."
"Monroe would have dismissed such beliefs as superstition, folklore. But Ada, increasingly covetous of Ruby's learning in the ways living things inhabited this particular place, chose to view the signs as metaphoric. They were, as Ada saw them, an expression of stewardship, a means of taking care, a discipline. They provided a ritual of concern for the patterns and tendencies of the material world where it might be seen to intersect with some other world. Ultimately, she decided, the signs were a way of being alert, and under those terms she could honor them."
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Cold Mountain.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 7, 2012
– Shelved
June 5, 2015
– Shelved as:
civil-war
June 5, 2015
– Shelved as:
american-south
February 22, 2018
– Shelved as:
southern-literary-trail
February 22, 2018
– Shelved as:
to-read
November 29, 2021
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
November 29, 2021
– Shelved as:
national-book-awards-finalists
November 29, 2021
– Shelved as:
on-deck
April 12, 2023
–
Started Reading
April 12, 2023
– Shelved as:
history
April 13, 2023
– Shelved as:
appalachia
April 14, 2023
–
16.57%
"“. . . Your soul will fade to the color of blue, the color of despair. Your spirit will wane and dwindle away, never to reappear. Your path lies toward Nightland. This is your path. There is no other.”"
page
59
April 14, 2023
–
29.21%
"“But Ada, increasingly covetous of Ruby’s learning in the ways living things inhabited this particular place, chose to view the signs as metaphoric. They were, as Ada saw them, an expression of stewardship, a means of taking care, a discipline. They provided a ritual of concern for the patterns and tendencies of the material world where it might be seen to intersect with some other world.”"
page
104
April 15, 2023
–
65.73%
"“To Ada, though, it seemed akin to a miracle that Stobrod, of all people, should offer himself up as proof positive that no matter what a waste one made of one’s life, it is ever possible to find some path to redemption, however partial.”"
page
234
April 16, 2023
–
71.63%
"“It was work that was just moderately tiring and, unlike the haying, produced only a peaceful still picture in Ada’s mind as she lay in bed at night: a red or yellow apple hanging from a drooping limb, behind it deep blue sky, her hand palm up, reaching out to the apple but not touching it.”"
page
255
April 17, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Julie
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Apr 17, 2023 01:52PM
This is my new favorite review of yours, Lorna. (I particularly love what you've shared in your first paragraph). I couldn't agree more!
reply
|
flag
What a fabulous connection you have with seeing the opera, Lorna. I am equally pleased how much you enjoyed the novel. It is nothing less than a masterpiece.
Julie wrote: "This is my new favorite review of yours, Lorna. (I particularly love what you've shared in your first paragraph). I couldn't agree more!"
Thank you for your dear comments, Julie. And I must say that being able to be at the final performance of that World Premiere was one of the most precious moments we have shared over a lifetime. We had tried to get tickets but every performance was sold out, and suddenly one more performance was added, that was the one we attended. And what a beautiful venue, my heart and soul reside in those Sangre de Christo mountains.
Thank you for your dear comments, Julie. And I must say that being able to be at the final performance of that World Premiere was one of the most precious moments we have shared over a lifetime. We had tried to get tickets but every performance was sold out, and suddenly one more performance was added, that was the one we attended. And what a beautiful venue, my heart and soul reside in those Sangre de Christo mountains.
Diane S ☔ wrote: "Heartfelt review for as you say and I agree, a beautiful story."
Thank you so very much for your kind words, Diane. And a beautiful story, indeed.
Thank you so very much for your kind words, Diane. And a beautiful story, indeed.
Julie wrote: "
(FYI--he's taken!)"
Oh damn, but that's OK, my eyes are on Charles Frazier. What a love he is. I listened to an interview where he was commenting on the opera score. He said he just sat in his house and wrote the book for eight years, not sure that anyone would even read it, and now he was listening to an opera with his characters centerstage. What a humble and talented man.
(FYI--he's taken!)"
Oh damn, but that's OK, my eyes are on Charles Frazier. What a love he is. I listened to an interview where he was commenting on the opera score. He said he just sat in his house and wrote the book for eight years, not sure that anyone would even read it, and now he was listening to an opera with his characters centerstage. What a humble and talented man.
Lori wrote: "What a fabulous connection you have with seeing the opera, Lorna. I am equally pleased how much you enjoyed the novel. It is nothing less than a masterpiece."
Oh Lori, I am in total agreement about this beautiful book being a masterpiece. I am now on a Charles Frazier read-a-thon. I have many of his books on my TBR. And thank you for your dear comment.
Oh Lori, I am in total agreement about this beautiful book being a masterpiece. I am now on a Charles Frazier read-a-thon. I have many of his books on my TBR. And thank you for your dear comment.
Lorna,
I am thrilled that you had that experience. It sounds like a "once in a lifetime" event, and in your beloved New Mexico.
I agree about Charles Frazier. He comes across as a complex Southern gentleman. He's pretty irresistible, too!
I am thrilled that you had that experience. It sounds like a "once in a lifetime" event, and in your beloved New Mexico.
I agree about Charles Frazier. He comes across as a complex Southern gentleman. He's pretty irresistible, too!
Julie wrote: "Lorna,
I am thrilled that you had that experience. It sounds like a "once in a lifetime" event, and in your beloved New Mexico.
I agree about Charles Frazier. He comes across as a complex Southern ..."
Thank you for your lovely comment, Julie. It was "a once in a lifetime" event for sure. When I was writing my review, I was surprised that it was in 2015 because it is still vivid in our memories. One of those beautiful and memorable evenings in my "beloved New Mexico."
I am thrilled that you had that experience. It sounds like a "once in a lifetime" event, and in your beloved New Mexico.
I agree about Charles Frazier. He comes across as a complex Southern ..."
Thank you for your lovely comment, Julie. It was "a once in a lifetime" event for sure. When I was writing my review, I was surprised that it was in 2015 because it is still vivid in our memories. One of those beautiful and memorable evenings in my "beloved New Mexico."
Swrp wrote: "A beautiful summary, Lorna. So nice. Thank you! 🌼"
Thank you for your kind comments, Swrp.
Thank you for your kind comments, Swrp.
Diane wrote: "Excellent review for an excellent book Lorna."
Thank you so much, Diane. What a masterpiece.
Thank you so much, Diane. What a masterpiece.
Excellent review, Lorna. I especially like your real life experience beside Cold Mountain and listening to the opera with the thunder and lighting. The book also seems really interesting.
Joseph wrote: "Excellent review, Lorna. I especially like your real life experience beside Cold Mountain and listening to the opera with the thunder and lighting. The book also seems really interesting."
Thank you for your kind comments, Joseph. Both the opera and the book are amazing, each in their own way. It was an unforgettable evening in Santa Fe.
Thank you for your kind comments, Joseph. Both the opera and the book are amazing, each in their own way. It was an unforgettable evening in Santa Fe.
I read this many years ago and don't remember having loved it as much as you. Your personal experience certainly must have been very moving. I thoroughly enjoyed your review, Lorna.
Barbara wrote: "I read this many years ago and don't remember having loved it as much as you. Your personal experience certainly must have been very moving. I thoroughly enjoyed your review, Lorna."
Thank you, Barbara. I loved this book but our experience at the Santa Fe Opera certainly was at the heart of this beautiful story.
Thank you, Barbara. I loved this book but our experience at the Santa Fe Opera certainly was at the heart of this beautiful story.