Candi's Reviews > Lila

Lila by Marilynne Robinson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: contemporary-literary, book-i-own, favorites

"Doll may have been the loneliest woman in the world, and she was the loneliest child, and there they were, the two of them together, keeping each other warm in the rain."

Lila understands what it means to be lonely. She knows what it means to connect with another human soul to overcome that utter loneliness. Lila takes us on her journey and it is one of beauty and understanding and developing faith, not just in God but in the human spirit itself. Despite hardship and neglect, can a person truly learn to trust another? Ultimately, this is what the heart yearns for and what Lila seeks throughout her life.

Lila, born into poverty and neglect, is rescued and raised by an older woman named Doll. It becomes necessary to their survival to lead a life wandering from one place to the next in order to avoid detection. Doll is determined to protect Lila from those that had failed to provide her with the most basic of human needs, including love. The two attach themselves to a band of drifters and lead a harsh life, but one that allows them to form a bond that will always remain within Lila’s heart long after she must strike out on her own. Alone in the world, Lila searches for an identity, she longs for that human connection that sustains her, sustains all of us. Drifting into the small mid-western town of Gilead, the town we encountered in the book of that same title, Lila decides to settle for a bit. "… she wanted to stay in one place for a while. The loneliness was bad, but it was better than anything else she could think of. It was probably the loneliness that made her walk the mile or so into town every few days just to look at the houses and stores and the flower gardens. She never meant to talk to anybody." Then one day while in town, Lila seeks shelter from the rain and enters the church. Thus begins one of the most beautiful human connections in literature as Lila meets the Reverend John Ames. Lila is full of mistrust towards others. John Ames is gentle and patient and full of wisdom – wisdom that he doesn’t preach but quietly shares with humility and after much contemplation. He makes no demands. John is not a stranger to loneliness himself and Lila’s recognizes this. "He looked as if he’d had his share of loneliness, and that was all right. It was one thing she understood about him. She liked his voice. She liked the way he stood next to her as if there was a pleasure for him in it." Lila, not formally educated, but with her own brand of intellect based on experience, reasoning and inquisitiveness, will develop a spiritual rapport with John that is moving and simply powerful.

This novel, published after Gilead, is set in a time prior to the events occurring in that outstanding work of fiction. While Gilead was told from John’s point of view, Lila is a third person narrative which focuses on Lila’s life. It highlights her own perspective of those events leading up to the time she meets John and their early life together. The story is told with a stream of consciousness feel to it that alternates between past and present. Robinson draws a portrait of Lila that illustrates her past struggles and how these juxtapose with her current attempts to overcome loneliness and mistrust. This is not an easy battle for Lila and we, along with John, are witness to her lapses back to the familiar and painful feelings.

"The problem is, she thought, that if someday she opened the front door and there, where the flower gardens and the fence and the gate ought to be, was that old life, the raggedy meadows and pastures and the cornfields and the orchards, she might just set the child on her hip and walk out into it, the buzz and the smell and the damp of it, the breath of it like her own breath, her own sweat. Stepping back into the loneliness, a dreadful thing, like walking into cold water, waiting for the numbness to set in that was the body taking the care it could, so that what you knew you didn’t have to feel."

After much reflection, I really must change my rating to 5 stars. This book and the entire trilogy, including Gilead and Home, are definitely worthy of that rating. Highly recommended.
136 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Lila.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 18, 2014 – Shelved
September 18, 2014 – Shelved as: to-read
February 15, 2015 – Shelved as: contemporary-literary
November 21, 2015 – Shelved as: book-i-own
September 19, 2016 – Started Reading
September 25, 2016 – Finished Reading
March 27, 2017 – Shelved as: favorites

Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)


Kris (My Novelesque Life) I read Housekeeping last year and enjoyed it..so am looking forward to this one. Can't wait to hear your thoughts :)


Candi Kris - My Novelesque Life wrote: "I read Housekeeping last year and enjoyed it..so am looking forward to this one. Can't wait to hear your thoughts :)"

I adore this author, Kris. I liked this one a little less than Gilead and Home, but still a great read!


Kris (My Novelesque Life) Good to know! Thanks, Candi :)


message 4: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Oh this looks good! I'm looking forward to your review :)


Candi Deanna wrote: "Oh this looks good! I'm looking forward to your review :)"

It was wonderful, Deanna! I would recommend every one of her books. Stay tuned :)


Cheri Lovely review, Candi. I love everything of hers that I've read, someday I will tackle her non-fiction, but Robinson's a treasure. I'd like to re-read these (Gilead, Home, Lila) someday!


Cathrine ☯️ Well, I'm jealous. Your response was what I hoped mine would be. I agree with all you wrote Candi, I just could not love it like the others.


Candi Stephanie wrote: "Great review, Candi! Funny how stepping back can help solidify rating! :D"

Thanks, Stephanie! I have been thinking about this one so much since finishing, and then while writing my review I decided it really need to be upgraded!


Candi Cheri wrote: "Lovely review, Candi. I love everything of hers that I've read, someday I will tackle her non-fiction, but Robinson's a treasure. I'd like to re-read these (Gilead, Home, Lila) someday!"

Thank you, Cheri. I adore Robinson's writing. I am planning a re-read of Housekeeping soon. I have not yet tried her non-fiction either. Something I should probably remedy!


Candi Cathrine ☯ wrote: "Well, I'm jealous. Your response was what I hoped mine would be. I agree with all you wrote Candi, I just could not love it like the others."

Cathrine, I'm sorry that your response wasn't quite what you hoped for - I definitely understand that feeling! I had many interruptions reading this one and at first gave it 4 stars. But then I realized that the fault wasn't in the book but just with me. I took lots of notes and it has been on my mind so much that I just had to give it the 5 stars. I did like Gilead better, but this one still felt like a 5 star for me personally, based on my reaction to it.


Diane S ☔ Beautiful review.


message 12: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Yes, beautiful.


message 13: by Arah-Lynda (new)

Arah-Lynda Simply stated, an absolutely beautiful review Candi.


Candi Diane, Kelli and Arah-Lynda - thank you so much!


message 15: by Dana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Dana Beautiful review for a beautiful book. I loved it...and Home. I'm hoping to revisit Gilead, as I could not get interested in it at the time I tried. It had to be timing as these books are some of my favorites. Everyone else has loved Gilead the most... so it's me. :)


message 16: by Zoeytron (new)

Zoeytron You put so much heart and care into your reviews, Angela, and it shows.


Candi Dana wrote: "Beautiful review for a beautiful book. I loved it...and Home. I'm hoping to revisit Gilead, as I could not get interested in it at the time I tried. It had to be timing as these books are some of m..."

Thank you, Dana. I'm so glad you loved this one, too. Do try Gilead again some time. I know timing can make a big difference for me at times as well :)


message 18: by Renata (new) - added it

Renata What a beautifully written review. I could feel how much Lila touched your heart in its deepest places, and the high regard you have for John. I read Gilead years ago and faint shadows of it remain in my mind. Perhaps reading Lila will bring that moving story back, too.


Candi Zoeytron, thank you :)


Candi Thank you very much, Renata. Reading Lila did bring back much of Gilead, but now I feel I really want to read that one again!


message 21: by Sara (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sara What a fantastic review of this wonderful book. Your review touched on all the things I felt while reading it. Some books won't let us go until we have properly digested them...sounds like Lila was one of those for you. I seldom want to re-read books the moment I have finished them, but I would love to sit down again with this trilogy and read it back to back without interruption. I feel there is so much more there that might be mined. I am going to keep an eye out for a group discussion as well.

Thank you, Candi, for your always meaningful insight that helps me to enjoy my reading at a completely different level.


Candi Sara wrote: "What a fantastic review of this wonderful book. Your review touched on all the things I felt while reading it. Some books won't let us go until we have properly digested them...sounds like Lila was..."

Sara, thank you so much for your kind words. This book really just resonated with me more and more once I finished it. I couldn't stop thinking about it. I agree, if I thought I could get a large chunk of uninterrupted reading time, I would most definitely re-read the entire trilogy. I think that is something I will do when the kids head off to college!


message 23: by Bionic Jean (new)

Bionic Jean Wow these books sound exceptional! Thank you for such a well crafted and highly readable review Candi.


message 24: by Marilyn (new)

Marilyn C. Terrific review, Candi :)


Candi Jean wrote: "Wow these books sound exceptional! Thank you for such a well crafted and highly readable review Candi."

Jean, thank you for saying so :) And, yes, these books are quite exceptional!


Candi Marilyn wrote: "Terrific review, Candi :)"

Thank you, Marilyn :)


message 27: by Karen (new)

Karen Candi, your beautiful review was written right from your heart. I had Housekeeping and Gilead and had trouble getting into Gilead. It must have been the timing because so many people have been touched to the soul by them. I am inspired to try them again. Did you like Gilead more than Housekeeping?


Candi Karen wrote: "Candi, your beautiful review was written right from your heart. I had Housekeeping and Gilead and had trouble getting into Gilead. It must have been the timing because so many people have been touc..."

Oh, thank you so much, Karen. It's strange because I really didn't know how I was going to write this review, how to get my point across, so I'm glad it seems I managed to articulate some of my feelings about this one! I loved Gilead. Housekeeping is one I read longer ago so I can't really compare. Right now it's just a memory of a good book, but I can't recall the details. I have a copy and plan to read it again soon. I know other friends have had trouble with Gilead also. In fact, I do recall it taking me a bit of time as well, but then at some point it just really clicked with me. I hope you can try again one day and that it works for you. If not, well, that's okay too! We're all different :)


message 29: by PorshaJo (new)

PorshaJo Great review Candi! I've yet to read Marilynne Robison but after this review I really need to give her a try.


message 30: by Karen (last edited Oct 09, 2016 07:05PM) (new)

Karen Thank you Candi. I do think I will try it again because this trilogy seems to touch people so deeply. I think Gilead won the national book critics award and then went on to win the Pulitzer. A lot of times it can be the timing. In my case I think I should have given it more time. I can think of two five star reads that I almost put down, but was so glad that I stuck it out, because they turned out to be one of my favorate authors. Xxoo


message 31: by Eileen (new)

Eileen Nice review, Candi. I'll definitely have to take a look at the trilogy. :)


Candi PorshaJo wrote: "Great review Candi! I've yet to read Marilynne Robison but after this review I really need to give her a try."

Thank you, PorshaJo!


Candi Eileen wrote: "Nice review, Candi. I'll definitely have to take a look at the trilogy. :)"

Thanks, Eileen! I hope you decide to give it a try!


message 34: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Candi you highly recommend this book.

Jaidee highly recommends your review. Gorgeous and heartfelt. You are so dear Candi !!


Candi Jaidee wrote: "Candi you highly recommend this book.

Jaidee highly recommends your review. Gorgeous and heartfelt. You are so dear Candi !!"


Thank you so much, Jaidee!! Really very kind of you to say so. I appreciate it :)


message 36: by Guy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Guy Austin Loved them all, but Lila was actually my favorite of the three. I believe I'm in the minority.


Candi Guy wrote: "Loved them all, but Lila was actually my favorite of the three. I believe I'm in the minority."

That's great, Guy! I'm glad that you enjoyed all of them :)


Candi Elyse wrote: "Beautiful Candi!!!!!"

Thanks so much, Elyse! What a fantastic writer we have in Marilynn Robinson! Glad you had the opportunity to immerse yourself in her work :)


message 39: by Jola (last edited Aug 06, 2017 01:24PM) (new)

Jola I haven't read anything by Marilynne Robinson yet and your insightful review made me wonder why, as her books seem to be definitely to my liking. Thank you, Candi.
My first and immediate association when I saw the title of this novel, was Elena Ferrante's character. :)


Candi Jola wrote: "I haven't read anything by Marilynne Robinson yet and your insightful review made me wonder why, as her books seem to be definitely to my liking. Thank you, Candi.
My first and immediate associatio..."


Thanks so much, Jola :) Marilynne Robinson ranks right up there near the top on my mental list of favorite authors. I hope you try one of her novels some time - the writing is just so moving. When I read this I was not yet familiar with Ferrante's character, but now it does make me think of her as well! Definitely completely different though :)


Angela M is taking a break. Beautiful review, Candi . Don't know how I missed it but glad to have read it now . She is an exceptional writer for sure ,


message 42: by Julie (new)

Julie G Candi, I can feel the love. I added it!


message 43: by Candi (last edited Aug 06, 2017 06:08PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Candi Angela M wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi . Don't know how I missed it but glad to have read it now . She is an exceptional writer for sure ,"

Thank you, Angela! An outstanding author for sure. I read this a while back, but the review seems to be circulating again now that Elyse just read this book and commented here!

P.S. Thanks, Elyse! LOL :)


Candi Julie wrote: "Candi, I can feel the love. I added it!"

Thank you, Julie! I'm glad my admiration for this book and author came across in the review :) I can't wait to hear what you think when you get to it!


Josephine Briggs Wonderful review. Robinson's "Gilead" books are all so great and good reads.


Candi Josephine wrote: "Wonderful review. Robinson's "Gilead" books are all so great and good reads."

Thank you, Josephine! I am a huge fan of Robinson :)


Laysee Beautiful review, Candi. You articulated Lila's struggles so well. One empathized with her loneliness and mistrust. It was good to see Gilead this time from Lila's perspective.


Candi Laysee wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. You articulated Lila's struggles so well. One empathized with her loneliness and mistrust. It was good to see Gilead this time from Lila's perspective."

Thanks very much, Laysee! Robinson's books will be classics for sure, and I'm happy to have this and Gilead on my favorites shelf. They are all worth a re-read someday!


message 49: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Beautiful review, Candi. How marvelously you have defined the human relationship through the portrait of Lila's life. Though I has Gilead on my TBR but have not read any books by her, adding this one too.


Candi Gaurav wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. How marvelously you have defined the human relationship through the portrait of Lila's life. Though I has Gilead on my TBR but have not read any books by her, adding this o..."

Thank you very much, Gaurav! Robinson's books are pure genius and a joy to read. Do carve a place for Gilead in your reading schedule sooner rather than later! I'd love to hear your thoughts on it :)


« previous 1
back to top