Read Runners discussion
This topic is about
Company of Liars
Historical Fiction
>
HF June 2016 - Company of Liars
Prologue was intriguing and am wondering who the dead woman is.
@Syl, its nothing like Burial Rites, I find it better than that book. :)
@Syl, its nothing like Burial Rites, I find it better than that book. :)
Just read two chapters, why do I feel that I already know who is the dead woman, about who are talking about in the prologue
Jaya wrote: "Just read two chapters, why do I feel that I already know who is the dead woman, they are talking about in the prologue"
who is it? my guess is (view spoiler)
who is it? my guess is (view spoiler)
Am 53% done and it is turning out tk be very mesmerizing tale. Every person in the 'Company' has a story to tell, a secret to hide and they all need each other to survive.
At 5% am finding it good going. The olden day epidemics, their spread and beliefs associated therewith had always interested me. Tried readingFever 1793about yellow fever, but found it a bit drab and gave it up halfway through.
I have only read about this period in terms of economic and political history and thus the mention of the plagues...this approach is quite interesting.
Only at 12%, but it is so engrossing. No wonder Manju is on a roll.:-)
Loving those fantasy weaved into reality stories of mermaids, werewolves etc.
Camelot seems to be advanced for the century he is living in. His thoughts are almost fitting into this era.
Loving those fantasy weaved into reality stories of mermaids, werewolves etc.
Camelot seems to be advanced for the century he is living in. His thoughts are almost fitting into this era.
I like Camelot and hate the magician. I also like the elder musician. Others seem namby pamby.
sorry, I never seem to remember names unless the book is with me for ready referral.
sorry, I never seem to remember names unless the book is with me for ready referral.
Seeing my buddy racing through this book, I couldn't help but start reading and now I am hooked! Thanks Manu for making me deviate once again from my planned reads! :P
Loved the prologue and yes I agree with Syl on the Burial Rites tinge to it. Am about roughly 10% into the story, had to put it down to sleep last night, which my brain thought was an unwanted thing. Anyway, hope to read more and experience all the characters that you are talking about. :)
Lin - Do read Burial Rites. I think you will like it. :)
Loved the prologue and yes I agree with Syl on the Burial Rites tinge to it. Am about roughly 10% into the story, had to put it down to sleep last night, which my brain thought was an unwanted thing. Anyway, hope to read more and experience all the characters that you are talking about. :)
Lin - Do read Burial Rites. I think you will like it. :)
I'm starting chapter five. I must admit that the story is very interesting so far, but I have one problem with the book so far. Don't you feel like it lacks a bit in setting? Maybe I have too high expectations - after all the last Historical fiction set in the MidleAges I read were The Pillars of the Earth - but, I feel that this story is mostly adventure/mystery and less historical fiction (at least at this moment).
I enjoy it nonetheless :)
I enjoy it nonetheless :)
Karolina wrote: "I'm starting chapter five. I must admit that the story is very interesting so far, but I have one problem with the book so far. Don't you feel like it lacks a bit in setting? Maybe I have too high ..."
Yes, it seems more like adventure/mystery.
But somehow I am enjoying it despite the lack of the setting, and to be frank I noticed the fact only after you pointed it out. :)
Pillars of the Earth was an epic.
Yes, it seems more like adventure/mystery.
But somehow I am enjoying it despite the lack of the setting, and to be frank I noticed the fact only after you pointed it out. :)
Pillars of the Earth was an epic.
@Syl - I wouldn't call it an epic in the literary genre sense, as it didn't focus on a theme of grandeur and heroism, it was a great and wonderful book though anyway, and has a special place in my heart :)
But I'm not a fan of generalizing by genre anyway. It's just that when I read a book, that is set in historical period, I love reading more abou the setting, so that I can sink in the universe.
And as I said - I'm still enjoying it too :)
But I'm not a fan of generalizing by genre anyway. It's just that when I read a book, that is set in historical period, I love reading more abou the setting, so that I can sink in the universe.
And as I said - I'm still enjoying it too :)
Manju wrote: "Jaya wrote: "Just read two chapters, why do I feel that I already know who is the dead woman, they are talking about in the prologue"
who is it? my guess is [spoilers removed]"
I guess it is
(view spoiler)
who is it? my guess is [spoilers removed]"
I guess it is
(view spoiler)
Finished and it was an entertaining read. :)
So what is happening in the story now? Are you liking the stories that characters making up?
So what is happening in the story now? Are you liking the stories that characters making up?
Syl: Oh it was cruel and nasty but they used to do that kind of rituals all over the Europe in that period. (Read that in historical notes in the end of the book.)
Finished it! Astonished at myself for doing that though! ;)
Waiting for more of you to finish for discussions.
Manu - For once our ratings match! :P
Waiting for more of you to finish for discussions.
Manu - For once our ratings match! :P
I am in chapter 2. Not sure what you all found so funny. Maybe it will lighten up in the next chapters
I didn't find it funny. It was entertaining, definitely, in the way all of them meet and then there is a certain suspense angle till about 70%. That's about it, I guess, at least for me.
Jaya - that's the best way to go in. I went in with zero expectations other than it being a fast read. It was a fast read, so I was happy. Other stuff will discuss once you all finish. :)
It was fun for me in first 25%, how they met and different stories were good. It was the 'end' that made me give it three stars.
Manju wrote: "It was fun for me in first 25%, how they met and different stories were good. It was the 'end' that made me give it three stars."
Same pinch.
Spoiler only for those who have finished
In fact, I felt (view spoiler)
Same pinch.
Spoiler only for those who have finished
In fact, I felt (view spoiler)
@Akshay - I consider 3 stars rating a positive one. It says "I liked it", so I wouldn't be put off by someone's rating of 3 :)
To be honest though after around 30% I don't find this book as appealing as the rest of people here. It's fine but nothing extraordinary...
To be honest though after around 30% I don't find this book as appealing as the rest of people here. It's fine but nothing extraordinary...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Pillars of the Earth (other topics)Fever 1793 (other topics)
Burial Rites (other topics)
The year is 1348. The Black Plague grips the country. In a world ruled by faith and fear, nine desperate strangers, brought together by chance, attempt to outrun the certain death that is running inexorably toward them.
Each member of this motley company has a story to tell. From Camelot, the relic-seller who will become the group's leader, to Cygnus, the one-armed storyteller . . . from the strange, silent child called Narigorm to a painter and his pregnant wife, each has a secret. None is what they seem. And one among them conceals the darkest secret of all--propelling these liars to a destiny they never saw coming.
Come join us as we read and discuss this book. As always, please mark any spoilers within spoiler tags. Enjoy reading and discussing!