Mary - Buried Under Romance 's Reviews > No Good Duke Goes Unpunished
No Good Duke Goes Unpunished (The Rules of Scoundrels, #3)
by
by
What an amazing book. Sarah MacLean’s eloquent, powerful language reverberated within my heart; it transformed sympathy to empathy, thoughts and feelings to a canvas of emotions, and even when I hated the heroine, I understood her perfectly. It takes an astounding raw talent to center a hero who had been hurt so much by the heroine, inspiring in the readers a dislike for the heroine, yet make her just as lovable as he in the end, a wonderfully moving ending of a perfectly matched couple.
William Harrow, heir to the Duke of Lamont, had awoken naked and in a bed of blood on the wedding date of his father’s fourth marriage. His stepmother-to-be, heiress Mara Lowe, had disappeared without a trace, and he was presumed to be her killer. From that day onward, he became The Killer Duke, and soon, Temple. Temple was the champion gladiator, the guardian at the Fallen Angel, a gambling club formed by four fallen gentlemen to fleece the greedy of their wealth, the losers’ last chance at redemption, of winning back their debts. And through blood and sweat, he never lost for twelve years, because in his bones he believed in redemption least of all. He did not look down on others’ weakness, but that thing called hope which caused them to challenge him again and again, to only be crushed down because Temple symbolized violence in its truest form – elemental, focused, and holiness in its purity of heart. It was all that he had left of himself after that fateful day, the manifestation of unmitigated self-misery. Fate overtook his world that day, when he was accused of taking a life, and now he works through taking the livelihoods of other men.
On the eve of her wedding, Mara planned a reckless escape and never looked back. She took on the role of Mrs. MacIntyre, widowed proprietress of an orphanage. But when her brother gambled away their funds, she needed to reclaim her money for the orphanage. To resurface in twelve years, she sought the only person with whom she can bargain – Temple. Her truth for canceling her brother’s debt. But Temple is looking for more than that; he wants retribution.
“He hadn’t killed her
The realization remained a shock.
He hadn’t known. All those years – he’d lived with the idea that he might have been a killer. All those years
She’d stolen them from him”
To live with the idea that one is a killer is a frightening thing, and to do so for years is even more. Mara did not give a thought to Temple during her foolish “escape.” She claims to feel no remorse due to her self-interest. Her selfishness made me question whether I can like her for causing Temple so much misery, or appreciate that she did what she believed was right, because she is imperfect, as are all of us. Her conviction and determination are admirable, but are they worthy of praise when they have ruined another? I could not understand how given her compassion for the poor and needy that she did not care as a happy lord was relegated into a fighter of the underworld. It is true that Mara chose the path that benefited her, which trapped an innocent man in the darkness. However, the pieces of her puzzle slowly merges together to reveal the depth of complexity of her character - that of someone so perfectly imperfect who, armed with immature confidence, had simply made a vast mistake. That was when I realized this tale, while focusing on Temple, has a deeper layer of intricacy centered on Mara's redemption.
As Mara strove to keep her secrets, she was caught between remorse and fear, fear of letting anyone in, of knowing her heart. Her independence and steely determination drew Temple in. Even when he planned for retribution, Temple fell in love with her, and sacrificed himself yet again; He unknowingly protected her once, and knowingly did so again; yet his inward gentleness only caused himself more grief as Mara’s secrets and untrusting heart endangered him. This is where the book has been neatly juxtaposed; while Temple had only been the victim in the first half, his sacrifice for Mara awakened in her a protectiveness towards him, which turned her into his protector in the second half. This seamlessly balanced reversal of roles carried with it a viseral, heartwrenching love that blossomed between Temple and Mara, two of the most unlikeliest characters you'll ever meet (because of what Mara did), and there is no word but beautiful to describe their connection.
By the end of the book, Sarah MacLean proved to be a true storyteller as Temple’s faith was restored, along with Mara’s trust. The belief that fighting for a purpose was strength, not a weakness. Hope was no longer a danger, nor was trust. Instead, both were strands that unified his claim on love, and solidified Mara’s need for him in her life. The gentle giant was protected by the very same woman who sent him to hell. On that journey, Temple realized that inwardly, a part of him was "fallen" to begin with, and through Mara's reflective journey, she came to see atonement as doing her best to love the man who, in spite of all odds, fell in love with her. Is there anything to be said of this book other than that Sarah MacLean's skillful pen brilliantly perfected a love story to rival the ages? I think not. But if you do doubt, pick this up and be warned that you'll be immersed in the story for hours.
Beginning from the first book in the series, Sarah MacLean had started to leave subtle clues regarding the founder of the Fallen Angel, Chase. By this book, the clues have become more obvious to the more discriminating readers. But only in the epilogue is Chase's identity revealed...which is, without a doubt, a revelation. I was left plagued by questions, which will finally be answered in the 2014, with the highly anticipated release of Chase's book that will explain how everything came together.
*Review copy received from the published via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review
Originally published on Buried Under Romance
William Harrow, heir to the Duke of Lamont, had awoken naked and in a bed of blood on the wedding date of his father’s fourth marriage. His stepmother-to-be, heiress Mara Lowe, had disappeared without a trace, and he was presumed to be her killer. From that day onward, he became The Killer Duke, and soon, Temple. Temple was the champion gladiator, the guardian at the Fallen Angel, a gambling club formed by four fallen gentlemen to fleece the greedy of their wealth, the losers’ last chance at redemption, of winning back their debts. And through blood and sweat, he never lost for twelve years, because in his bones he believed in redemption least of all. He did not look down on others’ weakness, but that thing called hope which caused them to challenge him again and again, to only be crushed down because Temple symbolized violence in its truest form – elemental, focused, and holiness in its purity of heart. It was all that he had left of himself after that fateful day, the manifestation of unmitigated self-misery. Fate overtook his world that day, when he was accused of taking a life, and now he works through taking the livelihoods of other men.
On the eve of her wedding, Mara planned a reckless escape and never looked back. She took on the role of Mrs. MacIntyre, widowed proprietress of an orphanage. But when her brother gambled away their funds, she needed to reclaim her money for the orphanage. To resurface in twelve years, she sought the only person with whom she can bargain – Temple. Her truth for canceling her brother’s debt. But Temple is looking for more than that; he wants retribution.
“He hadn’t killed her
The realization remained a shock.
He hadn’t known. All those years – he’d lived with the idea that he might have been a killer. All those years
She’d stolen them from him”
To live with the idea that one is a killer is a frightening thing, and to do so for years is even more. Mara did not give a thought to Temple during her foolish “escape.” She claims to feel no remorse due to her self-interest. Her selfishness made me question whether I can like her for causing Temple so much misery, or appreciate that she did what she believed was right, because she is imperfect, as are all of us. Her conviction and determination are admirable, but are they worthy of praise when they have ruined another? I could not understand how given her compassion for the poor and needy that she did not care as a happy lord was relegated into a fighter of the underworld. It is true that Mara chose the path that benefited her, which trapped an innocent man in the darkness. However, the pieces of her puzzle slowly merges together to reveal the depth of complexity of her character - that of someone so perfectly imperfect who, armed with immature confidence, had simply made a vast mistake. That was when I realized this tale, while focusing on Temple, has a deeper layer of intricacy centered on Mara's redemption.
As Mara strove to keep her secrets, she was caught between remorse and fear, fear of letting anyone in, of knowing her heart. Her independence and steely determination drew Temple in. Even when he planned for retribution, Temple fell in love with her, and sacrificed himself yet again; He unknowingly protected her once, and knowingly did so again; yet his inward gentleness only caused himself more grief as Mara’s secrets and untrusting heart endangered him. This is where the book has been neatly juxtaposed; while Temple had only been the victim in the first half, his sacrifice for Mara awakened in her a protectiveness towards him, which turned her into his protector in the second half. This seamlessly balanced reversal of roles carried with it a viseral, heartwrenching love that blossomed between Temple and Mara, two of the most unlikeliest characters you'll ever meet (because of what Mara did), and there is no word but beautiful to describe their connection.
By the end of the book, Sarah MacLean proved to be a true storyteller as Temple’s faith was restored, along with Mara’s trust. The belief that fighting for a purpose was strength, not a weakness. Hope was no longer a danger, nor was trust. Instead, both were strands that unified his claim on love, and solidified Mara’s need for him in her life. The gentle giant was protected by the very same woman who sent him to hell. On that journey, Temple realized that inwardly, a part of him was "fallen" to begin with, and through Mara's reflective journey, she came to see atonement as doing her best to love the man who, in spite of all odds, fell in love with her. Is there anything to be said of this book other than that Sarah MacLean's skillful pen brilliantly perfected a love story to rival the ages? I think not. But if you do doubt, pick this up and be warned that you'll be immersed in the story for hours.
Beginning from the first book in the series, Sarah MacLean had started to leave subtle clues regarding the founder of the Fallen Angel, Chase. By this book, the clues have become more obvious to the more discriminating readers. But only in the epilogue is Chase's identity revealed...which is, without a doubt, a revelation. I was left plagued by questions, which will finally be answered in the 2014, with the highly anticipated release of Chase's book that will explain how everything came together.
*Review copy received from the published via Edelweiss in exchange for an honest review
Originally published on Buried Under Romance
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
No Good Duke Goes Unpunished.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
January 2, 2013
– Shelved
Started Reading
November 19, 2013
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Mary - Buried Under Romance
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 19, 2013 09:59AM
Come visit my blog for a giveaway hosted by Avon, of A Rogue by Any Other Name and One Good Earl Deserves a Lover!!
reply
|
flag
Great review. Quite an unusual story line. Sounds like an imperfect heroine, but that is more interesting.
Please oh please tell me the heroine didn't suffer from sexual abuse, with many comments saying it was a more "dark" read. That is one I have a real hard time with...
Ep wrote: "Please oh please tell me the heroine didn't suffer from sexual abuse, with many comments saying it was a more "dark" read. That is one I have a real hard time with..."
Well, it's dark already with the whole supposedly murdered thing...but is it REALLY dark? I don't think so.
Well, it's dark already with the whole supposedly murdered thing...but is it REALLY dark? I don't think so.
Kathleen❄ wrote: "Great review. Quite an unusual story line. Sounds like an imperfect heroine, but that is more interesting."
It is an unusual story line with a very imperfect heroine. My first assessment of her was, I should say, too caught up in raw feelings (that's how good an author she is). I have since revised my review.
It is an unusual story line with a very imperfect heroine. My first assessment of her was, I should say, too caught up in raw feelings (that's how good an author she is). I have since revised my review.
Well...due to some sudden circumstances, I was pressed to finish my post for the blog tour, and skimmed through some of the book. Upon re-reading them an hour ago, I understand more character motivations and therefore revised my review to shed the wholly unflattering light in which I painted the heroine in my initial review. *hides in embarrassment* -- never procrastinate again
Susanne wrote: "Great review, Mary! I'm reading the second one now! <3"
Thanks Susanne! The second one is really good too :D
Thanks Susanne! The second one is really good too :D
Caz wrote: "Great review, Mary :) I loved this one, too."
Caz, I pretty much know that every book you like I should put a stamp of approval on it. :)
Caz, I pretty much know that every book you like I should put a stamp of approval on it. :)
Lol I'm suddenly reminded of that scene in the movie Forrest Gump with "shit happens." ...which oddly, was sort of what happened last night....=.=
I think my current review is better now, less ranting of the heroine. I hate to write too subjective a review. :/
I think my current review is better now, less ranting of the heroine. I hate to write too subjective a review. :/
June wrote: "Great review Mary. I must say that my favorite part is Temple holding Lavender :D"
Oh yes, I love a hero who loves the heroine so much that he loves her pet pig too. lol :D
Oh yes, I love a hero who loves the heroine so much that he loves her pet pig too. lol :D
Sebina~☆~ClassicMaiden~☆ wrote: "Mary, this is truly such a wonderful review, and *sigh*, I can't wait to read it. I feel like I'm the last person to be going on the MacLean band wagon lol! I have the first two books in this serie..."
Thanks, Sebina! Given that this book jumped to #1 best seller in historical romance in just one day, yep, you should jump on this wagon :)
Thanks, Sebina! Given that this book jumped to #1 best seller in historical romance in just one day, yep, you should jump on this wagon :)
Hehe awesome! It's best to read this from bk1 to bk3 as you get closer to finding out who the mysterious Chase is...hehehe :)
I recently introduced a friend to Sarah MacLean's books and she regretted not reading her sooner. lol
Yup, Chase's book is the 4th one. There's a huge spoilers in book 3 so don't read that one before you read the first two. I will be so sad when this series ends!
Yup, Chase's book is the 4th one. There's a huge spoilers in book 3 so don't read that one before you read the first two. I will be so sad when this series ends!
Most say Nine Rules was their favorite, and that's mine too. Eleven Scandals wasn't bad either thought the hero was a serious blockhead at times. I haven't read Ten Ways yet.
The review was thought-out neatly. There are somethings I am feeling curious about, but to satisfy my curiosity, I need to read the series. Will talk more over this book when I finish it, which is not gonna happen very soon.
This review was more analytical in nature, I see your point now. It was kinda...less subjective, but it was a treat to have read it. Though I wish the review had your emotions bubbling out uncontrollably, because you certainly gave the book a lot of thought and care, evident from the 1st and the 6th paragraph, I think this review will make many readers eager to know Sarah Maclean's works in depth. I wonder again, what induced this intricately-worded, neatly-woven, well-grounded review. Was it the well-execution of the plot of this book in particular, the author's writing style, the understanding of the main female character(who I feel I'll hate too and yet 'empathize' with her), or your own unparalleled, unusual way of seeing and thinking things?
:D
-Sarina. Please remember. Not Syeda.
This review was more analytical in nature, I see your point now. It was kinda...less subjective, but it was a treat to have read it. Though I wish the review had your emotions bubbling out uncontrollably, because you certainly gave the book a lot of thought and care, evident from the 1st and the 6th paragraph, I think this review will make many readers eager to know Sarah Maclean's works in depth. I wonder again, what induced this intricately-worded, neatly-woven, well-grounded review. Was it the well-execution of the plot of this book in particular, the author's writing style, the understanding of the main female character(who I feel I'll hate too and yet 'empathize' with her), or your own unparalleled, unusual way of seeing and thinking things?
:D
-Sarina. Please remember. Not Syeda.
Ah, what a delightful, well written review. I couldn't say I was interested in this one because of the main character, Mara, but I am now!
Steamy
Steamy
Steamywindows♥♫ wrote: "Ah, what a delightful, well written review. I couldn't say I was interested in this one because of the main character, Mara, but I am now!
Steamy"
Thanks, Steamy. :) I have to admit that I wanted to strangle her for a good half of the book, but she does redeem herself in her own way.
Steamy"
Thanks, Steamy. :) I have to admit that I wanted to strangle her for a good half of the book, but she does redeem herself in her own way.
Sarina wrote: "The review was thought-out neatly. There are somethings I am feeling curious about, but to satisfy my curiosity, I need to read the series. Will talk more over this book when I finish it, which is ..."
Sometimes inspiration just comes to me. A certain idea takes shape as I read along that allows me to suitably (at times better than usual) my thoughts into a formatted review). :) Your fantastic praise puts me to the blush.
Sometimes inspiration just comes to me. A certain idea takes shape as I read along that allows me to suitably (at times better than usual) my thoughts into a formatted review). :) Your fantastic praise puts me to the blush.
Diana wrote: "Such a great book"
I agree, Diana! It won the 2014 RITA for Best Historical Romance! :D
I agree, Diana! It won the 2014 RITA for Best Historical Romance! :D
I've started it today, am halfway through chapter 2 and am already intrigued! I hope Mara's reason for disappearing like that is good enough... No! Don't tell me, I wanna find out for myself... Am not gonna reread your review, for fear of spoiling myself. :D
BUT...your review is what introduced me to this book in the first place... For that, I want to thank you, Mary Chen. For taking up the time to conjure up luscious reviews such as this one. For making my, and other goodreaders';) time so very worthwhile.
I'm looking forward to the mystery and how it will be resolved in this story. Not concerned about the romance much, but then.... I've only just begun! I hope to be delighted in many ways I'm not expecting as I delve deeper and deeper into this book... ^_^
BUT...your review is what introduced me to this book in the first place... For that, I want to thank you, Mary Chen. For taking up the time to conjure up luscious reviews such as this one. For making my, and other goodreaders';) time so very worthwhile.
I'm looking forward to the mystery and how it will be resolved in this story. Not concerned about the romance much, but then.... I've only just begun! I hope to be delighted in many ways I'm not expecting as I delve deeper and deeper into this book... ^_^
Sarina wrote: "I've started it today, am halfway through chapter 2 and am already intrigued! I hope Mara's reason for disappearing like that is good enough... No! Don't tell me, I wanna find out for myself... Am ..."
^_^ I tried not to give too many spoilers in my review...you might find Mara very unlikable for the first half of the book...but you'll understand her reason for it. I hope you'll finish this book, Sarina!
^_^ I tried not to give too many spoilers in my review...you might find Mara very unlikable for the first half of the book...but you'll understand her reason for it. I hope you'll finish this book, Sarina!
Nope, I like her just fine... for now. Oh, don't worry about that. I WILL finish it...by hook or by crook! ;)
Sarina wrote: "Nope, I like her just fine... for now. Oh, don't worry about that. I WILL finish it...by hook or by crook! ;)"
Haha, that's the spirit!
Haha, that's the spirit!
AMAZING REVIEW!!!!! So detailed & persuasive that one simply has to read this novel now!!!!!! :) great job!!!!!
Vampire-lk wrote: "AMAZING REVIEW!!!!! So detailed & persuasive that one simply has to read this novel now!!!!!! :) great job!!!!!"
Thanks, Vampire-Ik! ^_^ So sorry I didn't reply to your comment earlier.
Thanks, Vampire-Ik! ^_^ So sorry I didn't reply to your comment earlier.