Melissa (Trying to Catch Up)'s Reviews > Before You Knew My Name
Before You Knew My Name
by
by
Achingly beautiful.
"No one lives just one life. We start and finish our worlds many times over. And no matter how long or short a time we are here, I'm beginning to realize we all want more than we get."
This is a story that shouldn't have worked for me, but it did. It's the story of two women who come to New York City: Alice, who at age 18 is just embarking on her life after a rough childhood and a series of bad choices, and Ruby, a 36-year-old Australian woman who is looking for a fresh start. We know from the beginning that Alice has died and Ruby finds her body, but we don't know the circumstances or what happens when Ruby decides to try to figure out who Alice was.
This is a gorgeously written novel that encompasses larger themes within the narrative. It's the story of life and death, grief and loss, but it is also about women and choices. It's about consent, about the default action of women to be polite and accommodating even when uncomfortable, about seeking the truth about ourselves even when it's uncomfortable. It's about regrets and missed opportunities, but it's also about diving in and taking chances even when it's difficult.
It took me a little while to get into the story, but once I did I was absolutely captivated to the point where I stayed up way too late to finish the book because I wanted to know what happened. There's a bit of mystery, yes, but the book is about so much more than that, the mystery really takes a back seat to the emotions and growth of the characters.
This is a stunning debut and I look forward to reading more by this talented writer.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
"No one lives just one life. We start and finish our worlds many times over. And no matter how long or short a time we are here, I'm beginning to realize we all want more than we get."
This is a story that shouldn't have worked for me, but it did. It's the story of two women who come to New York City: Alice, who at age 18 is just embarking on her life after a rough childhood and a series of bad choices, and Ruby, a 36-year-old Australian woman who is looking for a fresh start. We know from the beginning that Alice has died and Ruby finds her body, but we don't know the circumstances or what happens when Ruby decides to try to figure out who Alice was.
This is a gorgeously written novel that encompasses larger themes within the narrative. It's the story of life and death, grief and loss, but it is also about women and choices. It's about consent, about the default action of women to be polite and accommodating even when uncomfortable, about seeking the truth about ourselves even when it's uncomfortable. It's about regrets and missed opportunities, but it's also about diving in and taking chances even when it's difficult.
It took me a little while to get into the story, but once I did I was absolutely captivated to the point where I stayed up way too late to finish the book because I wanted to know what happened. There's a bit of mystery, yes, but the book is about so much more than that, the mystery really takes a back seat to the emotions and growth of the characters.
This is a stunning debut and I look forward to reading more by this talented writer.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Before You Knew My Name.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 12, 2022
– Shelved
April 12, 2022
– Shelved as:
to-read
October 14, 2022
–
Started Reading
October 16, 2022
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)
message 1:
by
Tina
(new)
Oct 16, 2022 09:38AM
Loving those 5 glowing stars!!
reply
|
flag
L.A. wrote: "Yes! I'm so glad you enjoyed this one too!🤩"
I hope it won't be overlooked, it's a wonderful book.
I hope it won't be overlooked, it's a wonderful book.
Margaret M - semi hiatus until end October wrote: "Now that says a lot already Melissa ✨"
Such a great book!
Such a great book!
Jasmine wrote: "Excellent review, Melissa! Maybe I should reconsider this one, especially if it’s a five star read!"
It is a beautiful read!
It is a beautiful read!
Cara wrote: "Great review, Melissa💜!!!! Glad this book was a winner for you🔥!!!!!"
Thanks Cara, it definitely was!
Thanks Cara, it definitely was!
That's quite the introductory excerpt to kick off a terrific review, Melissa. Happy to see your 5 stars for this one as well. Will look forward to getting this one into my clutches.
Mike wrote: "That's quite the introductory excerpt to kick off a terrific review, Melissa. Happy to see your 5 stars for this one as well. Will look forward to getting this one into my clutches."
It's a very emotional read, I hope you like it too.
It's a very emotional read, I hope you like it too.
I am so happy to hear this from you Melissa!!! Achingly beautiful…my heartstrings are feeling it already! LOL so happy I have this to look forward to…fantastic review!
Yun wrote: "Great review, Melissa! So glad this story touched you so deeply and you loved it! :)"
Thanks Yun!
Thanks Yun!
Catherine wrote: "I am so happy to hear this from you Melissa!!! Achingly beautiful…my heartstrings are feeling it already! LOL so happy I have this to look forward to…fantastic review!"
Can't wait to see what you think!
Can't wait to see what you think!
Suz wrote: "Absolutely agree! Lovely review, Melissa."
Thanks Suz, I am very stingy but this one deserves it!
Thanks Suz, I am very stingy but this one deserves it!
What were the bad choices Alice made? The only choice I can see was to seek safety from a predator who groomed her (hardly her fault), and then to leave when he said horrible things to her.
Binky wrote: "What were the bad choices Alice made? The only choice I can see was to seek safety from a predator who groomed her (hardly her fault), and then to leave when he said horrible things to her."
Maybe bad choices is not the right wording--unfortunate choices possibly. Lying about her age wasn't a great choice, also becoming too comfortable with her surroundings and not being wary enough. I know that it shouldn't be that way, but predators exist and people need to protect themselves and it's sad and unfortunate that she didn't.
Maybe bad choices is not the right wording--unfortunate choices possibly. Lying about her age wasn't a great choice, also becoming too comfortable with her surroundings and not being wary enough. I know that it shouldn't be that way, but predators exist and people need to protect themselves and it's sad and unfortunate that she didn't.
Wonderful review, Melissa! I'm about to start this, so I'm thrilled to see those 5 stars. I've heard so many good things about this book! 💗
Kat wrote: "Wonderful review, Melissa! I'm about to start this, so I'm thrilled to see those 5 stars. I've heard so many good things about this book! 💗"
I hope you love it too!
I hope you love it too!
Wonderful review, Melissa. Totally agree with you about this being emotional and beautiful. Thought provoking. 🧡💔 (Penelope Rawlins did a terrific job narrating)
Taina wrote: "Wonderful review, Melissa. Totally agree with you about this being emotional and beautiful. Thought provoking. 🧡💔 (Penelope Rawlins did a terrific job narrating)"
Thanks Taina, glad you loved it too!
Thanks Taina, glad you loved it too!
Jennifer SK wrote: "Such a heartfelt review Melissa, so wonderful it was a winner for you 💕💕💕"
Thanks Jennifer, it was a great book.
Thanks Jennifer, it was a great book.