Mizuki's Reviews > Heretics of Dune

Heretics of Dune by Frank Herbert
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
16842102
's review

liked it
bookshelves: chinese-translation, it-is-okay

Premise: 1000-plus years after the regime of Leto II, human races had spread across the known galaxies and beyond, with the godlike tyrant (Leto II) out of the picture, different races and power groups/religious groups now ruled different parts and corners of the different civilizations, and the power struggle and scheme continued.

I enjoy the first four books of the Dune series, but by the fifth book, I must admit something in the story is getting old. I mean, you can only reuse the idea of weird breeding program, court intrigue, characters hiding and giving chase in the desert etc etc that many times.

Plus, hardly any character stand out in the book. The main characters are a reasonable enough bunch but they just aren't very remarkable, as to the 'villains'.........they are even more unmemorable. For example, in book 4 I can always see Leto II clearly but in this book, I can't picture any of the characters as a lively being and the ideal they stand for, in my mind. *sighs*

Furthermore, what I really don't like about this volume is, the slut shaming is getting really much, I mean, the Bene Geserit had been using sex as weapon for god know how long, but when there is a bunch of newcomers coming along, also using sex to control men (okay, as usual homosexuality is not mentioned), said newcomers were labeled as sluts nonstop, I mean, come on.

PS: I also don't think this volume brings much insight for its readers, but I will read the next book anyway.
34 likes · flag

Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read Heretics of Dune.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 11, 2021 – Shelved
December 11, 2021 – Shelved as: to-read
April 27, 2022 – Started Reading
April 28, 2022 –
page 30
4.48% "Another breeding program, argh."
April 28, 2022 –
page 58
8.67%
April 29, 2022 –
page 90
13.45%
April 29, 2022 –
page 91
13.6% "It's just really slow."
April 30, 2022 –
page 112
16.74% "Another deadly power struggle."
April 30, 2022 –
page 120
17.94% "It's slow"
April 30, 2022 –
page 130
19.43% "Too much religion stuff."
May 1, 2022 –
page 170
25.41% "Okay, more things about schemes, economic development and power play!"
May 1, 2022 – Shelved as: chinese-translation
May 1, 2022 –
page 215
32.14%
May 2, 2022 –
page 222
33.18% "So much scheming and plotting."
May 2, 2022 –
page 254
37.97% "Another escape plan"
May 5, 2022 –
page 259
38.71%
May 6, 2022 –
page 276
41.26% "Who to trust and who should they be suspicious of?"
May 8, 2022 –
page 308
46.04% "Two storylines so far."
May 11, 2022 –
page 332
49.63% "More hide and seek in the desert."
May 14, 2022 –
page 346
51.72%
May 14, 2022 –
page 384
57.4% "More secrets"
May 15, 2022 –
page 394
58.89%
May 18, 2022 –
page 428
63.98% "Some more weird talk about sex and religion."
May 23, 2022 –
page 520
77.73% "Are they going to kill him then revive him somehow?"
May 23, 2022 –
page 522
78.03% "So many schemes!"
May 24, 2022 –
page 523
78.18%
May 24, 2022 –
page 523
78.18%
May 24, 2022 –
page 600
89.69% "It took a lot of time but I'd finished!"
May 27, 2022 – Shelved as: it-is-okay
May 27, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-1 of 1 (1 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Thomas I think you misunderstood why the Bene Gesserit call the Honored Matres whores. The point is not that they use sex at all but that their motivations are depraved. Odrade reflects throughout the book that the BG are always just a step away from falling into this trap themselves.


back to top