Diane S ☔'s Reviews > The Good Daughter
The Good Daughter (Good Daughter, #1)
by
by
2.5 I am giving this three stars because I kept reading, and did want to find out what happened. This was, however, much more graphic than I am comfortable with, and I resented the fact that it was repeated three different times in the book. While I know it was told from different viewpoints, and more details were uncovered in each telling, I thought it could have been done differently. Felt manipulated in the repetition of this horrific telling,as if it was used only for shock value. An additional plot line that brings the sisters back together, I felt became kind of lost, and became mostly a vehicle to further the main story.
I did like the characters, though I found much of this story unbelievable, that is within the parameters of the story. I can do unbelievable if it fits, which this did not. The last quarter of the book was a convoluted untangling of the storyline, where too much happens in a short space of time. Once again some of this had me rolling my eyes.
I have loved this authors books in the past, so my expectations were much higher. I did enjoy parts of this but as a whole, and after thinking it through for a day, I was disappointed. Another sisters read, with mixed results by the readers.
ARC from edelweiss.
I did like the characters, though I found much of this story unbelievable, that is within the parameters of the story. I can do unbelievable if it fits, which this did not. The last quarter of the book was a convoluted untangling of the storyline, where too much happens in a short space of time. Once again some of this had me rolling my eyes.
I have loved this authors books in the past, so my expectations were much higher. I did enjoy parts of this but as a whole, and after thinking it through for a day, I was disappointed. Another sisters read, with mixed results by the readers.
ARC from edelweiss.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
The Good Daughter.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
July 21, 2017
– Shelved
(ebook Edition)
July 21, 2017
– Shelved as:
to-read
(ebook Edition)
October 21, 2017
–
Started Reading
October 21, 2017
– Shelved
October 24, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Angela M is taking a break.
(new)
Oct 25, 2017 01:42PM
One I’ll skip , Diane . Thanks for a great review.
reply
|
flag
Nice Review Diane and I I did find it quite graphic too. This was my first novel by this author but am glad to see that you have liked others by her.
What a great review Diane are very articulate. I appreciated your comment: “Felt manipulated in the repetition of this horrific telling,as if it was used only for shock value.” as I was reading something this week and had a very similar experience. Aggravated me immensely. xx
Good grief - I haven't read anything by Slaughter yet, but having read your review, Diane, I am hesitant. Yikes.
Interesting Diane, I was wavering on this one, so this helps me decide. I did like a couple of Grant County books, but the first Will Trent was too gratuitously violent for me :P
I’m sorry this didn’t work for you, Diane. We all have different tastes, triggers, and tolerances, and that’s a good thing. Personally, I thought this was Slaughter's best one yet.
Terrific review Diane! Sorry you were disappointed in this one, and I can understand, it is very graphic. This one is a favorite of mine. Hope your next one is a lot better.
Diane, You're very kind in your review. I wish I had liked this one more than you did but as you know, it set me off on a rant 😬
Wonderful review, Diane! I completely understand all of your points. I enjoyed reading and discussing with you!
Wonderful review, Diane! I completely understand all of your points as well! I did love reading and discussing this one with you!
Thank you so much friends. I know many of you liked this much more than I did, but we all have different reactions to books. What makes this site do interesting and makes us not lemmings. Lol
great review Diane, sorry you didn't like this more! I'm actually excited to pick this one up still!
Great review Diane! Enjoyed reading and chatting with you! Yes we all felt very differently about this book! Great discussions!
Bummer . . . sorry this one didn't work for you, Diane. I enjoyed reading your thoughts though and totally understand where you're coming from.