Maja (The Nocturnal Library)'s Reviews > Blood Red Road
Blood Red Road (Dust Lands, #1)
by
by
Maja (The Nocturnal Library)'s review
bookshelves: young-adult, readalong, dystopia, huge-disappointment, incredibly-stupid-choices, moments-of-great-frustration, totally-saw-that-coming, reviewed-in-2011
Jun 06, 2011
bookshelves: young-adult, readalong, dystopia, huge-disappointment, incredibly-stupid-choices, moments-of-great-frustration, totally-saw-that-coming, reviewed-in-2011
2.5 stars
I believe that, consciously or unconsciously, every author has a list of priorities he/she keeps in mind when writing a book. I know that every reader has priorities/expectations/preferences when choosing what to read. Unfortunately, Moira Young’s priorities and mine are very, very different.
To be perfectly fair here, she didn’t write this book for me. She wrote it for teenagers who have a hard time focusing on anything for too long. And I have to give it to her, the book is an attention gripper from start to finish. It will entertain you as long as you don’t think too hard about it. Because once you start thinking, it all goes down the drain. I also think that Blood Red Road was written for people who need to visualize something clearly in order to enjoy it. I’m not one of those people. I have to feel and then feel some more, and the only thing Saba made me feel was annoyance.
There were so many inconsistencies in Saba’s character. Her life was described as completely isolated, from when she was born until the men showed up and took her twin brother away, shortly after their 18th birthday. Her mother died giving birth to her younger sister Emmi, and for the first 18 years of her life, the only people Saba ever talked to were her father and her brother Lugh. She mostly ignored poor Emmi. Knowing that, her understanding of people’s nature and behavior later in the book really bothered me. She was too insightful for someone who had no experience with other people. I thought about it a lot last night, and then this morning, entirely by accident, I stumbled upon a blog post written by Ann Aguirre in which she addressed this very issue. Her character Deuce (Enclave) also grew up pretty isolated, in a small community that lived underground. Ann was asked about the much hated love triangle she included in the book. This was (part of) her answer:
Her (Deuce's) emotional intuition is pretty close to nonexistent, and she misses cues that seem obvious to us because she's very underdeveloped in that regard. Yes, it's obvious to us that Fade digs her and that Stalker does too, and that by training with him, she's making Fade think she doesn't like him. But Deuce doesn't think in those terms. Stone and Thimble were her closest friends in brat-hood, and she never encountered an either/or situation with them. And that's really her primary source of social experience. She has no romantic history whatsoever.
And that's why Aguirre is one of my favorite authors. If an author wants me to really understand the character, he/she must do the same first.
I know many people had problems with the dialect that was used in this book, but for me, that was the best part. It was extremely well done, very consistent, and it made the rest a little more bearable.
I can’t really recommend this book, but considering how most of my friends rated it, I can’t not recommend it either. All I can say is that I won’t be continuing the series.
I believe that, consciously or unconsciously, every author has a list of priorities he/she keeps in mind when writing a book. I know that every reader has priorities/expectations/preferences when choosing what to read. Unfortunately, Moira Young’s priorities and mine are very, very different.
To be perfectly fair here, she didn’t write this book for me. She wrote it for teenagers who have a hard time focusing on anything for too long. And I have to give it to her, the book is an attention gripper from start to finish. It will entertain you as long as you don’t think too hard about it. Because once you start thinking, it all goes down the drain. I also think that Blood Red Road was written for people who need to visualize something clearly in order to enjoy it. I’m not one of those people. I have to feel and then feel some more, and the only thing Saba made me feel was annoyance.
There were so many inconsistencies in Saba’s character. Her life was described as completely isolated, from when she was born until the men showed up and took her twin brother away, shortly after their 18th birthday. Her mother died giving birth to her younger sister Emmi, and for the first 18 years of her life, the only people Saba ever talked to were her father and her brother Lugh. She mostly ignored poor Emmi. Knowing that, her understanding of people’s nature and behavior later in the book really bothered me. She was too insightful for someone who had no experience with other people. I thought about it a lot last night, and then this morning, entirely by accident, I stumbled upon a blog post written by Ann Aguirre in which she addressed this very issue. Her character Deuce (Enclave) also grew up pretty isolated, in a small community that lived underground. Ann was asked about the much hated love triangle she included in the book. This was (part of) her answer:
Her (Deuce's) emotional intuition is pretty close to nonexistent, and she misses cues that seem obvious to us because she's very underdeveloped in that regard. Yes, it's obvious to us that Fade digs her and that Stalker does too, and that by training with him, she's making Fade think she doesn't like him. But Deuce doesn't think in those terms. Stone and Thimble were her closest friends in brat-hood, and she never encountered an either/or situation with them. And that's really her primary source of social experience. She has no romantic history whatsoever.
And that's why Aguirre is one of my favorite authors. If an author wants me to really understand the character, he/she must do the same first.
I know many people had problems with the dialect that was used in this book, but for me, that was the best part. It was extremely well done, very consistent, and it made the rest a little more bearable.
I can’t really recommend this book, but considering how most of my friends rated it, I can’t not recommend it either. All I can say is that I won’t be continuing the series.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Blood Red Road.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-35 of 35 (35 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Wendy Darling
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Jun 06, 2011 11:44PM
Tell the truth. It was the giant killer worms, wasn't it?
reply
|
flag
Absolutely! Who could resist that?! I've read some pretty decent reviews of this book, but yours was the first that made me want to read it.
I'd want to know about them, too! It's kind of a spoiler, I guess, but I figured it was something that would make someone actually pick up the book.
It's not really a spoiler. I still don't know what they do (or who they eat) but they sound great. :D
I'm going to warn you already that tomorrow is national holiday here and I have the whole troop at home so I might be slow. But Tuesday I will catch up.
Oooh, but it doesn't matter. I'm the one who's on vacation so I'll just follow your lead. I have these short stories I need to catch up on anyway.
Ferragosto is my least favorite day of the year, btw.
Catie, drama camp at 5? That is Just. So. Cute!
Ferragosto is my least favorite day of the year, btw.
Catie, drama camp at 5? That is Just. So. Cute!
Drama camp at 5 IS great!
Maja, I know. I know. That is why tomorrow we will be staying at home all day, I am not driving (if I could drive but I doubt I can) anywhere.
Maja, I know. I know. That is why tomorrow we will be staying at home all day, I am not driving (if I could drive but I doubt I can) anywhere.
YOU don't have to stay at home at all. Your entire population is right here in my back yard. :D But we digress. (Oh, Chris!)
Is this the thread then? Or does someone want to start an official one? Poor Wen will get a trillion emails if we do the entire thing here. :D
Is this the thread then? Or does someone want to start an official one? Poor Wen will get a trillion emails if we do the entire thing here. :D
I'm trying to write something down, but I am very, very disappointed. I thought this was a safe bet.
message 18:
by
Maja (The Nocturnal Library)
(last edited Aug 17, 2011 05:30AM)
(new)
-
rated it 3 stars
Aren't you and Jo reading The Reapers?!? I wouldn't dream of interfering with that. :D
I'll just be spying, of course.
But, would you be interested in reading Imaginary Girls any time soon?
I'll just be spying, of course.
But, would you be interested in reading Imaginary Girls any time soon?
Wow!!!!
I love these kinds of reviews. Honest and insightful.
You didn't really like the book and you give great insight into why you didn't like it....and now I want to read it ;)
Isn't it interesting how an amazingly written "bad" review of a book could make you want to read it, just to see for yourself why the reviewer didn't like it?
Why didn't you put the (official) rating?
I love these kinds of reviews. Honest and insightful.
You didn't really like the book and you give great insight into why you didn't like it....and now I want to read it ;)
Isn't it interesting how an amazingly written "bad" review of a book could make you want to read it, just to see for yourself why the reviewer didn't like it?
Why didn't you put the (official) rating?
Very nice review, Maja. I have read mostly positive reviews on this, so it is nice to hear an opinion from the other side of the spectrum.
And thanks for including that part about Deuce. I really liked her character but I was frustrated with how she acted with Stalker. Now I understand why she did. Poor girl!
And thanks for including that part about Deuce. I really liked her character but I was frustrated with how she acted with Stalker. Now I understand why she did. Poor girl!
Okay looks like we're going to have to put bells on yours too. Only reason I got this was because Jo liked it! Stupid feed.
You know I loved this book because it was fun. It was one of those books that I didn't see the flaws until reviewers after me, pointed them out and I kept thinking "oh yeah, why didn't I notice that". Sometimes, I just get so into a book that gigantic worms just inch past my notice without a 2nd glance by me. LOL
Michelle, the Bookshelf Stalking wrote: "You know I loved this book because it was fun. It was one of those books that I didn't see the flaws until reviewers after me, pointed them out and I kept thinking "oh yeah, why didn't I notice tha..."
Michelle, that is so true. It happens to me with so many books. Not with this one though :D
Michelle, that is so true. It happens to me with so many books. Not with this one though :D
Lisa O. wrote: "Michelle, the Bookshelf Stalking wrote: "You know I loved this book because it was fun. It was one of those books that I didn't see the flaws until reviewers after me, pointed them out and I kept t..."
It is one of the reasons I dislike being one of the first reviewers for a book, I sometimes don't see the flaws of a book until they are pointed out to me in black and white.
It is one of the reasons I dislike being one of the first reviewers for a book, I sometimes don't see the flaws of a book until they are pointed out to me in black and white.
Michelle, I think it all comes down to one's enjoyment of the book. It might be flawed, it might have plot holes or too stupid to live characters but, end in end, your level of enjoyment is all that matters right? Regardless of other reviewers' opinions.
Lisa O. wrote: "Michelle, I think it all comes down to one's enjoyment of the book. It might be flawed, it might have plot holes or too stupid to live characters but, end in end, your level of enjoyment is all tha..."
Very true.
Very true.
Michelle, the Bookshelf Stalking wrote: "You know I loved this book because it was fun. It was one of those books that I didn't see the flaws until reviewers after me, pointed them out and I kept thinking "oh yeah, why didn't I notice tha..."
I felt the exact same way after reading all of these reviews Michelle... I remember reading Blood Red Road and loving it! But after reading a few of these newer reviews I'm scratching my head saying, 'Hmm... that's a good point. Those gigantic worms were kind of stupid.'
I felt the exact same way after reading all of these reviews Michelle... I remember reading Blood Red Road and loving it! But after reading a few of these newer reviews I'm scratching my head saying, 'Hmm... that's a good point. Those gigantic worms were kind of stupid.'
Bonnie wrote: "I felt the exact same way after reading all of these reviews Michelle... I remember reading Blood Red Road and loving it! But after reading a few of these newer reviews I'm scratching my head saying, 'Hmm... that's a good point. Those gigantic worms were kind of stupid..."
That is exactly me!
That is exactly me!
You know, I rated this a 3.5 and I still think it was fun...but looking back at it after having read The Reapers Are the Angels and many other post-apocalyptic books since, this one really does come out to be a fairly fluffy and insubstantial book. Still, I'm hoping the movie will be enjoyable...mostly since the book seems to have been more of a blueprint for that than an actual novel. :)
I think they should really be able to turn this into a good movie. It has potential for sure... I think. :)