What do you think?
Rate this book
Patternmaster #1
Wild Seed
In an "epic, game-changing, moving and brilliant" story of love and hate, two immortals chase each other across continents and centuries, binding their fates together -- and changing the destiny of the human race (Viola Davis). Doro knows no higher authority than himself. An ancient spirit with boundless powers, he possesses humans, killing without remorse as he jumps from body to body to sustain his own life. With a lonely eternity ahead of him, Doro breeds supernaturally gifted humans into empires that obey his every desire. He fears no one -- until he meets Anyanwu. Anyanwu is an entity like Doro and yet different. She can heal with a bite and transform her own body, mending injuries and reversing aging. She uses her powers to cure her neighbors and birth entire tribes, surrounding herself with kindred who both fear and respect her. No one poses a true threat to Anyanwu -- until she meets Doro. The moment Doro meets Anyanwu, he covets her; and from the villages of 17th-century Nigeria to 19th-century United States, their courtship becomes a power struggle that echoes through generations, irrevocably changing what it means to be human.
307 pages, Paperback
First published January 1, 1980
About the author
Octavia E. Butler
92 books18.8k followersOctavia Estelle Butler was an American science fiction writer, one of the best-known among the few African-American women in the field. She won both Hugo and Nebula awards. In 1995, she became the first science fiction writer to receive the MacArthur Foundation "Genius" Grant.
After her father died, Butler was raised by her widowed mother. Extremely shy as a child, Octavia found an outlet at the library reading fantasy, and in writing. She began writing science fiction as a teenager. She attended community college during the Black Power movement, and while participating in a local writer's workshop was encouraged to attend the Clarion Workshop, which focused on science fiction.
She soon sold her first stories and by the late 1970s had become sufficiently successful as an author that she was able to pursue writing full-time. Her books and short stories drew the favorable attention of the public and awards judges. She also taught writer's workshops, and eventually relocated to Washington state. Butler died of a stroke at the age of 58. Her papers are held in the research collection of the Huntington Library.
After her father died, Butler was raised by her widowed mother. Extremely shy as a child, Octavia found an outlet at the library reading fantasy, and in writing. She began writing science fiction as a teenager. She attended community college during the Black Power movement, and while participating in a local writer's workshop was encouraged to attend the Clarion Workshop, which focused on science fiction.
She soon sold her first stories and by the late 1970s had become sufficiently successful as an author that she was able to pursue writing full-time. Her books and short stories drew the favorable attention of the public and awards judges. She also taught writer's workshops, and eventually relocated to Washington state. Butler died of a stroke at the age of 58. Her papers are held in the research collection of the Huntington Library.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 3,277 reviews
February 6, 2023
This is the worst enemies to lovers I've read in a while.../s
My feelings for this book were on a rollercoaster. My hate for Doro was so strong that I wanted to DNF this book. I probably would have if I hadn't already read and loved so many of her books. By the third part, I couldn't put it down.
I wouldn't recommend it as the first book to try by her.
I need to know what happens next.
Ps. Be warned, it's painful to read... like everything she's ever written.
My feelings for this book were on a rollercoaster. My hate for Doro was so strong that I wanted to DNF this book. I probably would have if I hadn't already read and loved so many of her books. By the third part, I couldn't put it down.
I wouldn't recommend it as the first book to try by her.
I need to know what happens next.
Ps. Be warned, it's painful to read... like everything she's ever written.
August 16, 2017
“Recently, however, I began to suspect that calling myself a science fiction critic without having read anything by Octavia Butler bordered on the fraudulent.”
“Books to Look For” - Orson Scott Card
I have to thank OSC for the above-mentioned article (from 1990) which piqued my interest for reading Octavia Butler.
It is strange that I first read Wild Seed in January 2012, I loved it and it made me a lifelong fan of Octavia Butler, but since then I have not read any of the sequels. I have, however, read most of her other novels, and she has never disappointed me. Wild Seed is the first of the Patternmaster series, some of the later books in the series were written prior to this book, but in term of chronological order this is the first. I won’t do an overview of the series at this point as I have not read the other books, I will just stick to Wild Seed for now.
Wild Seed is about an African woman named Anyanwu who is immortal and has shape changing abilities. One day she encounters a man called Doro who is also a shape-changer, of a very different sort. Where Anyanwu changes her shape by metamorphosis, Doro does it by evicting people from their bodies and taking over (and thereby killing the body’s owner). At the beginning of the narrative, Anyanwu is already about three hundred years old, living in a village among her descendants. While it is not clear how old Doro is, he was born in Egypt during the reign of the Pharaohs, so he is more than twice her age. Doro coerces Anyanwu into leaving Africa with him and move to a community he built in New York, he does this mainly by threatening the safety of all her descendants. It transpires that Doro is working on a project to breed people with unusual powers (the word mutant does not appear in this book) and he perceives Anyanwu as a “wild seed” to become a potent new ingredient in this project. What follows is a story of power struggles between these two characters, involving intimidation, submission, heartbreak, courage and rebellion.
To say that Wild Seed is a page turner may give the impression that this is a sci-fi thriller that moves at breakneck speed. This is not the case at all; the story spans over a hundred years and is not particularly fast paced. However, it is very compelling, I always look forward to discovering what happens on the next page. Ms. Butler has an uncanny ability to effortlessly create vivid and believable characters. At times it seems like she can make them seem real as soon as they are introduced in the narrative. The only snag is I love her protagonist so much I wish she can just get away from this nefarious Doro, who is not only a creep but also doing a very creepy project; but if she does get away early in the book we would not have much of a story left.
Anyanwu
The book’s timeline spans over 100 years, from the late 1600s to the 1800s, at a time where slavery is prevalent in the US. Unlike Butler’s Kindred, Wild Seed is not exactly a slave narrative, Anyanwu is enslaved in a manner of speaking, without actually being a slave. The narrative is more concerned with her struggle to free herself from Doro’s project without risking the people she loves (her children and descendants). The sci-fi element of Wild Seed tends to read rather like science fantasy with all the shapeshifting going on, and no technology involved. However, Anyanwu has an ability to synthesize medicines from inside her body with the application of medical science principles. She comes up with a much more humane method of genetic engineering than Doro’s degrading version that treats human beings as seeds and animals.
What makes the novel works so well is Butler’s humanity and compassion. Anyanwu is one of sci-fi’s best protagonists who embodies the best characteristics of motherhood, even Doro is a very complex kind of villain with understandable motivations, considering his backstory you can almost forgive his heinous behaviour, but he certainly is an overbearing larger than life character. For me, Wild Seed is one of the all-time greats, and I look forward to finally moving on to the subsequent volumes soon.
Notes:
• One of the things I love most about Octavia Butler is her love of the sci-fi genre, and how she was happy to embrace it; unlike some literary authors who utilize the genre's tropes but reject the label.
• Sadly she is no longer with us, and I am running out of her books to read (｡•́︿•̀｡)
Quotes:
“Haven’t you seen the men slaves in this country who are used for breeding? They are never permitted to learn what it means to be a man. They are not permitted to care for their children. Among my people, children are wealth, they are better than money, better than anything. But to these men, warped and twisted by their masters, children are almost nothing.”
“I kill, Anyanwu. That is how I keep my youth, my strength. I can do only one thing to show you what I am, and that is kill a man and wear his body like a cloth.” He breathed deeply. “This is not the body I was born into. It’s not the tenth I’ve worn, nor the hundredth, nor the thousandth.”
He smiled a little, but could not help wondering how hard it might be to tame even partially a wild seed woman who had been helping herself for three hundred years.
Wild seed always had to be destroyed eventually. It could never conform as children born among his people conformed. But like no other wild seed, Anyanwu would learn to fear him and bend herself to his will.
Nice new cover
“Books to Look For” - Orson Scott Card
I have to thank OSC for the above-mentioned article (from 1990) which piqued my interest for reading Octavia Butler.
It is strange that I first read Wild Seed in January 2012, I loved it and it made me a lifelong fan of Octavia Butler, but since then I have not read any of the sequels. I have, however, read most of her other novels, and she has never disappointed me. Wild Seed is the first of the Patternmaster series, some of the later books in the series were written prior to this book, but in term of chronological order this is the first. I won’t do an overview of the series at this point as I have not read the other books, I will just stick to Wild Seed for now.
Wild Seed is about an African woman named Anyanwu who is immortal and has shape changing abilities. One day she encounters a man called Doro who is also a shape-changer, of a very different sort. Where Anyanwu changes her shape by metamorphosis, Doro does it by evicting people from their bodies and taking over (and thereby killing the body’s owner). At the beginning of the narrative, Anyanwu is already about three hundred years old, living in a village among her descendants. While it is not clear how old Doro is, he was born in Egypt during the reign of the Pharaohs, so he is more than twice her age. Doro coerces Anyanwu into leaving Africa with him and move to a community he built in New York, he does this mainly by threatening the safety of all her descendants. It transpires that Doro is working on a project to breed people with unusual powers (the word mutant does not appear in this book) and he perceives Anyanwu as a “wild seed” to become a potent new ingredient in this project. What follows is a story of power struggles between these two characters, involving intimidation, submission, heartbreak, courage and rebellion.
To say that Wild Seed is a page turner may give the impression that this is a sci-fi thriller that moves at breakneck speed. This is not the case at all; the story spans over a hundred years and is not particularly fast paced. However, it is very compelling, I always look forward to discovering what happens on the next page. Ms. Butler has an uncanny ability to effortlessly create vivid and believable characters. At times it seems like she can make them seem real as soon as they are introduced in the narrative. The only snag is I love her protagonist so much I wish she can just get away from this nefarious Doro, who is not only a creep but also doing a very creepy project; but if she does get away early in the book we would not have much of a story left.
Anyanwu
The book’s timeline spans over 100 years, from the late 1600s to the 1800s, at a time where slavery is prevalent in the US. Unlike Butler’s Kindred, Wild Seed is not exactly a slave narrative, Anyanwu is enslaved in a manner of speaking, without actually being a slave. The narrative is more concerned with her struggle to free herself from Doro’s project without risking the people she loves (her children and descendants). The sci-fi element of Wild Seed tends to read rather like science fantasy with all the shapeshifting going on, and no technology involved. However, Anyanwu has an ability to synthesize medicines from inside her body with the application of medical science principles. She comes up with a much more humane method of genetic engineering than Doro’s degrading version that treats human beings as seeds and animals.
What makes the novel works so well is Butler’s humanity and compassion. Anyanwu is one of sci-fi’s best protagonists who embodies the best characteristics of motherhood, even Doro is a very complex kind of villain with understandable motivations, considering his backstory you can almost forgive his heinous behaviour, but he certainly is an overbearing larger than life character. For me, Wild Seed is one of the all-time greats, and I look forward to finally moving on to the subsequent volumes soon.
Notes:
• One of the things I love most about Octavia Butler is her love of the sci-fi genre, and how she was happy to embrace it; unlike some literary authors who utilize the genre's tropes but reject the label.
• Sadly she is no longer with us, and I am running out of her books to read (｡•́︿•̀｡)
Quotes:
“Haven’t you seen the men slaves in this country who are used for breeding? They are never permitted to learn what it means to be a man. They are not permitted to care for their children. Among my people, children are wealth, they are better than money, better than anything. But to these men, warped and twisted by their masters, children are almost nothing.”
“I kill, Anyanwu. That is how I keep my youth, my strength. I can do only one thing to show you what I am, and that is kill a man and wear his body like a cloth.” He breathed deeply. “This is not the body I was born into. It’s not the tenth I’ve worn, nor the hundredth, nor the thousandth.”
He smiled a little, but could not help wondering how hard it might be to tame even partially a wild seed woman who had been helping herself for three hundred years.
Wild seed always had to be destroyed eventually. It could never conform as children born among his people conformed. But like no other wild seed, Anyanwu would learn to fear him and bend herself to his will.
Nice new cover
April 16, 2019
Dear Goodreads friends,
If you like to read science fiction / fantasy you should get to know Octavia Butler.
Love,
Lyn
Butler’s 1980 novel Wild Seed is the first chronological book in her Patternmaster series. This details the beginnings of the sub-race of humans that will, in Patternmaster, be set in the far future. Butler begins her narrative in 1390, in West Africa, where her protagonist Anyanwu meets a strange young man named Doro.
So begins a centuries old relationship, often rocky, between two immortals. Anyanwu is a healer and a shape shifter and seems to remain at about 20 years of age though she can take the shape (and apparently the DNA makeup) of other people and even animals. Doro, on the other hand, turns out to be much older and is a kind of spiritual vampire, taking the bodies of his victims and “wearing” them for a while.
The central conflict of the story is the dynamic opposition between Anyanwu and Doro in regard to Doro’s millennia project of breeding a super race. Doro, who is more spirit than man, has been gathering people with unusual talents and getting them together so that their talents may be made more usable and more apparent in the offspring. Anyanwu vehemently opposes his methods and his dehumanization of the subjects.
As interesting as this story is, and it is quintessential Butler, the magnetic tension between Doro and Anyanwu is the gripping central focus of the book. And like Milton’s Satan, Butler’s Doro is a fascinatingly complex and intriguing antagonist who displays both god-like power and transcendent ennui. Anyanwu’s humanism, and her female relational practicality and leadership offer a vital juxtaposition to Doro’s attentive but disassociated deity.
On the checklist for SF/F books that should be read and a must read for Butler fans.
If you like to read science fiction / fantasy you should get to know Octavia Butler.
Love,
Lyn
Butler’s 1980 novel Wild Seed is the first chronological book in her Patternmaster series. This details the beginnings of the sub-race of humans that will, in Patternmaster, be set in the far future. Butler begins her narrative in 1390, in West Africa, where her protagonist Anyanwu meets a strange young man named Doro.
So begins a centuries old relationship, often rocky, between two immortals. Anyanwu is a healer and a shape shifter and seems to remain at about 20 years of age though she can take the shape (and apparently the DNA makeup) of other people and even animals. Doro, on the other hand, turns out to be much older and is a kind of spiritual vampire, taking the bodies of his victims and “wearing” them for a while.
The central conflict of the story is the dynamic opposition between Anyanwu and Doro in regard to Doro’s millennia project of breeding a super race. Doro, who is more spirit than man, has been gathering people with unusual talents and getting them together so that their talents may be made more usable and more apparent in the offspring. Anyanwu vehemently opposes his methods and his dehumanization of the subjects.
As interesting as this story is, and it is quintessential Butler, the magnetic tension between Doro and Anyanwu is the gripping central focus of the book. And like Milton’s Satan, Butler’s Doro is a fascinatingly complex and intriguing antagonist who displays both god-like power and transcendent ennui. Anyanwu’s humanism, and her female relational practicality and leadership offer a vital juxtaposition to Doro’s attentive but disassociated deity.
On the checklist for SF/F books that should be read and a must read for Butler fans.
March 8, 2021
“In my years, I have seen that people must be their own gods and make their own good fortune. The bad will come or not come anyway.”
Absolutely fantastic! Wild Seed (Patternmaster #1) is my latest dip into Octavia Butler's work, and I continue be amazed by Butler's vision and talent. After her community is wiped out by slavers, Anyanwu, an immortal shape shifter and healer, travels to colonial America with another immortal named Doro. Their aims and origins are very different. Anyanwu wants to live among and support her people. Doro, on the other hand, plans to exploit Anyanwu to breed communities of people with superhuman abilities. Very engaging narrative with lots to think about. 4.5 stars
Absolutely fantastic! Wild Seed (Patternmaster #1) is my latest dip into Octavia Butler's work, and I continue be amazed by Butler's vision and talent. After her community is wiped out by slavers, Anyanwu, an immortal shape shifter and healer, travels to colonial America with another immortal named Doro. Their aims and origins are very different. Anyanwu wants to live among and support her people. Doro, on the other hand, plans to exploit Anyanwu to breed communities of people with superhuman abilities. Very engaging narrative with lots to think about. 4.5 stars
December 11, 2022
It was something of a shock to read Octavia Butler’s Wild Seed right after having read and loved her Kindred novel. Kindred, of course, is a time travel story, and, except for the time travel bit, it is realistic. On the other hand, Wild Seed is a fantasy. Wild Seed keeps the real world at the edges just outside the fantasy world it creates.
It's been decades since I've read any fantasy novels, so I wasn't quite sure how to react to the two main characters in Wild Seed (Doro and Anyamwu). My daughter reads and loves the fantasy genre and often talks about the books she's reading. I decided my daughter would love Anyamwu, and that realization kept me going during the early "world building" stage of the book.
During the rest of the novel I kept asking myself questions like: Will Doro and Anyamwu kill each other? Will Doro kill Anyamwu? Will Anyamwu kill Doro? Who, if anyone, will survive? I was Team Anyamwu throughout.
I won't say who survives at the end because that would ruin the book for future readers. I will mention this is the first book in a four book series, so it's safe to assume there are some survivors.
The next Octavia Butler novel I'm reading is Fledgling, and I'll be watching the Kindred television series on Hulu, which starts on December 13th. (We've already been warned that the television series is quite a bit different than the novel.)
It's been decades since I've read any fantasy novels, so I wasn't quite sure how to react to the two main characters in Wild Seed (Doro and Anyamwu). My daughter reads and loves the fantasy genre and often talks about the books she's reading. I decided my daughter would love Anyamwu, and that realization kept me going during the early "world building" stage of the book.
During the rest of the novel I kept asking myself questions like: Will Doro and Anyamwu kill each other? Will Doro kill Anyamwu? Will Anyamwu kill Doro? Who, if anyone, will survive? I was Team Anyamwu throughout.
I won't say who survives at the end because that would ruin the book for future readers. I will mention this is the first book in a four book series, so it's safe to assume there are some survivors.
The next Octavia Butler novel I'm reading is Fledgling, and I'll be watching the Kindred television series on Hulu, which starts on December 13th. (We've already been warned that the television series is quite a bit different than the novel.)
August 24, 2012
I really don't know where to start with this review. Wild Seed is unlike anything I have ever read before but yet it was still very accessible and easy to read. I would say this book is a combination of urban fantasy, horror, historical fiction and fantasy. Butler addresses slavery, gender roles, racial issues, sexuality, and class issues so subtlety you can miss the commentary if you want to and she does this all through the lens of a fantasy world involving supernatural beings that are seemingly immortal and have various abilities from shape shifting, body snatching, mind reading, and telekinesis. Personally, I don't want to miss the commentary and I enjoy the unique view. I tend to like my urban fantasy and fantasy stories with a slice of heaviness on the side and Octavia Butler seems to be able to deliver that every time.
This is the third book by Octavia Butler that I have read. I have come to expect that in reading her books I will have an escape from reality and a complete immersion into the characters that she writes. She writes characters that seem to breathe and live somewhere off the pages of her books, they are real and three dimensional. But such tangible characters come with a price, there is pain and anguish in her books and as a reader, I felt these emotions. Wild Seed was no exception. The characters witness some painful and sad events. This is not urban fantasy lite.
Wild Seed is a sweeping historical story that begins in Africa with ancient powerful beings. These beings get caught up in the slave trade and arrive in the now United States. These characters seem to have limitless power. One being prefers to use her power morally and compassionately. Another being, no longer sees himself as human and is not governed by any morality. And of course they clash, both romantically and otherwise. The book is surprisingly sexual in parts and raises some really interesting questions. A shapeshifter that can take on any shape -- animal and human -- and gender -- how do you feel about it taking on the opposite gender and engaging in sexual relationships? What about while it is in animal form? The sex scenes are not explicit but they are referenced. Octavia Butler is not shy about putting her toe across the border of most people's comfort zones.
I plan to continue on with the series and am excited that Butler's books are being published in e-book and audio book format.
To read more reviews like this check out www.badassbookreviews.com
This is the third book by Octavia Butler that I have read. I have come to expect that in reading her books I will have an escape from reality and a complete immersion into the characters that she writes. She writes characters that seem to breathe and live somewhere off the pages of her books, they are real and three dimensional. But such tangible characters come with a price, there is pain and anguish in her books and as a reader, I felt these emotions. Wild Seed was no exception. The characters witness some painful and sad events. This is not urban fantasy lite.
Wild Seed is a sweeping historical story that begins in Africa with ancient powerful beings. These beings get caught up in the slave trade and arrive in the now United States. These characters seem to have limitless power. One being prefers to use her power morally and compassionately. Another being, no longer sees himself as human and is not governed by any morality. And of course they clash, both romantically and otherwise. The book is surprisingly sexual in parts and raises some really interesting questions. A shapeshifter that can take on any shape -- animal and human -- and gender -- how do you feel about it taking on the opposite gender and engaging in sexual relationships? What about while it is in animal form? The sex scenes are not explicit but they are referenced. Octavia Butler is not shy about putting her toe across the border of most people's comfort zones.
I plan to continue on with the series and am excited that Butler's books are being published in e-book and audio book format.
To read more reviews like this check out www.badassbookreviews.com
October 16, 2020
As close to a perfect book as I can imagine. There’s almost nothing that one could do to improve Butler’s prose, pacing, or characterization. She never gives you an excuse to not turn the page . . . which is why I read Wild Seed in a single sitting. The moral issues Butler addresses make for fascinating drama.
![Profile Image for [Name Redacted].](https://cdn.statically.io/img/i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/users/1347082397i/287915._UY200_CR0,0,200,200_.jpg)
September 14, 2018
Butler's sci-fi classic has so much to recommend it. She is a very talented writer, and she creates a mythology and cosmology which are, if not unique, then arguably the best-developed of their kind. "Wild Seed" is beautiful and lyrical and powerful, but the rampant misandry and peculiar romanticization of pre-colonial Africa mar it -- infect it like a virus.
There is neither subtlety nor nuance in Butler's representation of the two sexes. No woman is ever a criminal or a monster or a villain -- those roles are reserved exclusively for the men. And the only men who show any virtuous traits are remarkable because they are explicitly exceptional -- aberrations who invariably die at the hands of other "true" men.
Butler presents the male as mind, male as monster, male as thief, male as predator, male as manipulator, male as sociopath, male as destroyer, male as wanderer, male as slaver, male as arrogant false-god, male as controller and dominator, male as compulsive, incurable rapist.
Butler presents the female as body, female as healer, female as savior, female as settler, female as nurturer, female as victim, female as mother, female as creatrix, female as liberator, female as rebel, female as builder, female as gardener, female as defiant and noble and inherently virtuous.
The sense is often that the male is the rude, brute beast from which the morally, ethically & spiritually superior female has evolved.
And re: her depictions of pre-colonial Africa...Well, i think this novel would have benefited from consultation of the works of Frank M. Snowden cross-referenced with that of Lloyd A. Thompson. It's moving in a Pan-Africanist sense, but it lacks reality.
Again, there is so much of worth here, and it deserves its status as a classic, but its flaws are so glaring, so appalling, that they can eclipse everything that is good about it. I was able to see more of its worth with this re-reading, able to filter out the hypocritical misandry and suspend my disbelief for the African history portions, and maybe next time I'll be able to filter out a bit more. For now I regrettably leave it as a 3 star book.
There is neither subtlety nor nuance in Butler's representation of the two sexes. No woman is ever a criminal or a monster or a villain -- those roles are reserved exclusively for the men. And the only men who show any virtuous traits are remarkable because they are explicitly exceptional -- aberrations who invariably die at the hands of other "true" men.
Butler presents the male as mind, male as monster, male as thief, male as predator, male as manipulator, male as sociopath, male as destroyer, male as wanderer, male as slaver, male as arrogant false-god, male as controller and dominator, male as compulsive, incurable rapist.
Butler presents the female as body, female as healer, female as savior, female as settler, female as nurturer, female as victim, female as mother, female as creatrix, female as liberator, female as rebel, female as builder, female as gardener, female as defiant and noble and inherently virtuous.
The sense is often that the male is the rude, brute beast from which the morally, ethically & spiritually superior female has evolved.
And re: her depictions of pre-colonial Africa...Well, i think this novel would have benefited from consultation of the works of Frank M. Snowden cross-referenced with that of Lloyd A. Thompson. It's moving in a Pan-Africanist sense, but it lacks reality.
Again, there is so much of worth here, and it deserves its status as a classic, but its flaws are so glaring, so appalling, that they can eclipse everything that is good about it. I was able to see more of its worth with this re-reading, able to filter out the hypocritical misandry and suspend my disbelief for the African history portions, and maybe next time I'll be able to filter out a bit more. For now I regrettably leave it as a 3 star book.
September 26, 2023
Octavia Butler just does not miss for me! As a speculative historical novel, Wild Seed is such an interesting take on personhood, slavery, eugenics, gender, and the morality of different kinds of sexual relationships. She's always interested in power, oppression, gender, and sexuality- this time in a sci-fi version of the 1700's (mostly) following two immortal beings who both love and hate each other. I'm very interested to see where this series goes, but this was nuanced and thought-provoking. Butler isn't afraid to make readers uncomfortable, and there are plenty of uncomfortable, violent, and horrifying things here, but the point isn't to make those things okay. It's drawing parallels to real-world things in a way that allows for enough distance to unpack them.
June 5, 2007
I really like what I've read by Octavia Butler so far and I wish I could give this at least three stars, but I can't because I hate Doro with a passionate fiery hatred and I wish he would die. I do not care if he is secretly a brain-hopping alien parasite and so thinks differently and that makes it okay for him to do eugenics. (Although, ooh, it will be supercool generations later when his offspring develop the power of flight and stop being crazy about their telepathy and basically become the X-Men, only incestuous -- but no! I hate Doro! I do not care about his awesome incestuous future X-Men!)
Anyanwu is cool. She is like the Animorphs, or Arthur in T. H. White's The Once And Future King. I liked how she could tie her Fallopian tubes using the power of her brain.
Anyanwu is cool. She is like the Animorphs, or Arthur in T. H. White's The Once And Future King. I liked how she could tie her Fallopian tubes using the power of her brain.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
December 16, 2022
Everyone hand-wringing about popular books depicting toxic relationships has never read Octavia Butler and it shows. Anyanwu and Doro are fucking unhinged. Truly deranged, malevolent behavior is contained within these pages. 11/10.
April 11, 2016
blog | goodreads
And forever is a long time to endure one another when you are two of the only immortal beings on the planet. Theirs is a love story that goes beyond physical desire; Anyanwu needs Doro as much as he needs her, whether either are willing to accept it or not.
Having lived long before the Son of God even walked the earth, Doro has developed his own moral compass -- or lack thereof. He has very utilitarian motives, is constrained by no societal boundaries, and therefore much of the contents of this book would strike the reader as outrageous, disgusting, and their abhorrence inevitably directed towards our antihero.
But I could not bring myself to hate him. This is what it should be like to be immortal and see your loved ones die one after the other. To bury your lovers, children, grandchildren ... you don't live for thousands of years without these kinds of things changing you.
Doro could have been intentionally malevolent and put his power to actively harm people. Instead, all he seeks for is a way to simply endure. And in this aspect, I sympathized for him.
But this is what Anyanwu has a hard time accepting -- and I do not blame her one bit! How can a healer, a mother, a being that respects all forms of life such as her, submit to the heartless demands of a sociopath?
For Doro, Anyanwu is the only one who could last long enough to keep him rooted to his long-forgotten humanity; and for Anyanwu, Doro is the only one who can understand her with an intimacy no mortal man ever could.
But please, if you are daunted by romance novels (such as I am), do not be hesitant about Wild Seed. Despite my gushing on and on and on about Anyanwu and Doro's beautiful love, this was not a romance book. Well, it is, at the core. But in no way, shape, or form does it torment you with romance. It is only there subtly, being hinted at in our two main characters' interaction and behaviour towards each other.
But for those of you undaunted by exposition, and those of you who enjoy complex and subtle romances; for me this book was heartbreaking and uplifting at the same time -- and I cannot recommend it enough.
***
more reviews are also available at my blog
Most of us don't believe in gods and spirits and devils who must be pleased or feared. We have Doro, and he's enough.What can I say about Wild Seed that could come anywhere close to doing it justice? This is the story of how Doro met Anyanwu, the only living soul on Earth who could possibly match his will; test his patience, endure his passive cruelty, and time and again defy him in ways even she could not possibly understand.
And forever is a long time to endure one another when you are two of the only immortal beings on the planet. Theirs is a love story that goes beyond physical desire; Anyanwu needs Doro as much as he needs her, whether either are willing to accept it or not.
Doro looked up. He held Isaac's gaze, not questioningly or challengingly, not with any reassurance or compassion. He only looked back. Isaac had seen cats stare at people that way. Cats. That was apt. More and more often, nothing human looked out of Doro's eyes.Doro is both our antihero and villain. An ogbanje -- evil spirit -- as Anyanwu would call him, he is not malicious through any evil intent of his own. He simply is. Much like fire must burn and virus must spread, Doro's nature is simply a part of him he cannot destroy.
Having lived long before the Son of God even walked the earth, Doro has developed his own moral compass -- or lack thereof. He has very utilitarian motives, is constrained by no societal boundaries, and therefore much of the contents of this book would strike the reader as outrageous, disgusting, and their abhorrence inevitably directed towards our antihero.
But I could not bring myself to hate him. This is what it should be like to be immortal and see your loved ones die one after the other. To bury your lovers, children, grandchildren ... you don't live for thousands of years without these kinds of things changing you.
Doro could have been intentionally malevolent and put his power to actively harm people. Instead, all he seeks for is a way to simply endure. And in this aspect, I sympathized for him.
But this is what Anyanwu has a hard time accepting -- and I do not blame her one bit! How can a healer, a mother, a being that respects all forms of life such as her, submit to the heartless demands of a sociopath?
Doro looked at people, healthy or ill, and wondered what kind of young they could produce. Anyanwu looked at the sick — especially those with problems she had not seen before — and wondered whether she could defeat their disease.And when people say opposites attract, this is what they're talking about. Anyanwu and Doro are two very opposing beings who complement each other perfectly. Their love for each other is so complex it's beautiful. They hate each other for completely different reason, they need each other for equally different reasons, and they are inevitably, constantly drawn back towards one another.
For Doro, Anyanwu is the only one who could last long enough to keep him rooted to his long-forgotten humanity; and for Anyanwu, Doro is the only one who can understand her with an intimacy no mortal man ever could.
But please, if you are daunted by romance novels (such as I am), do not be hesitant about Wild Seed. Despite my gushing on and on and on about Anyanwu and Doro's beautiful love, this was not a romance book. Well, it is, at the core. But in no way, shape, or form does it torment you with romance. It is only there subtly, being hinted at in our two main characters' interaction and behaviour towards each other.
Power came the way a child came -- with agony.Wild Seed is a complex, multi-layered prequel to the Patternmaster series. It is a fantasy novel, rich in themes of slavery, colonialism, and subtle commentary on human morality. It is a long, deep look into multiple aspects of humanity, and as such readers looking for action and adventure are better off turning to a different book.
But for those of you undaunted by exposition, and those of you who enjoy complex and subtle romances; for me this book was heartbreaking and uplifting at the same time -- and I cannot recommend it enough.
***
more reviews are also available at my blog
May 5, 2019
I’m not sure what Butler intended readers take away from this novel but I found it demeaning toward women and largely abhorrent.
The story focuses on two “people.” Doro is an evil shade thousands of years old who survives by jumping from body to body, killing the host, and absorbing the new body’s energy to survive until jumping to the next host at few week intervals. He has thus killed some hundred thousand people when this book begins.
His entertainment over the millennia is rounding up people with special abilities—mind reading, healing, telekinesis—and breeding them like animals—stranger to stranger, father to daughter, mother to son, sons to daughters—in Joseph Mengele fashion to create offspring with enhanced abilities to no real purpose other than his amusement, and as food. The more powerful the offspring, the more satisfying when he takes their bodies. None with power enough to challenge Doro are allowed to live. He has no empathy. He rules by fear and the seductiveness of the devil.
Anyanwu is also immortal. Born with the ability to manipulate every cell in her body, she has for hundreds of years been a wife, mother and healer to those around her. Doro finds her and desires to breed her as “wild seed” in his breeding colonies.
And my problems and disgust with this novel begin.
Anyanwu initially welcomes Doro to her bed and follows him hoping to protect her extended family from also becoming breeding stock. When it becomes apparent that nothing will stop Doro, she becomes his willingness accomplice and enabler, giving birth to many children by the various incarnations of Doro himself as well as allowing herself to be prostituted to men of Doro’s choosing to beget their children, even after she is married to Doro’s son, who himself is prostituted to many women to impregnate them. All in furtherance of Doro’s breeding experiments. Like a woman with battered wife syndrome, Ananyu knowingly and willing participates as Doro’s destroys the lives of those around her, taking even some of her own children as hosts.
Late in the book Anyanwu escapes and founds her own colony bringing together people of extraordinary abilities like those sought by Doro, but with the purpose of healing their souls to lead normal lives after being ostracized from society, hunted or tortured. Doro of course eventually finds her and her community. And she takes him back like a lover, abetting him to again destroy everything she’s built.
Butler seeks to paint Anyanwu as a Florence Nightengale figure who comforts the damaged in the face of unspeakable horrors. But she is decidedly not. She enables much of the horror by actively supporting Doro’s experiments, excusing her actions as necessary to enable her to heal some of the victims. She is the accomplice who puts a bandage on your arm before allowing the serial killer to eat you.
Actions she could have taken instead: 1) Leave and never again contribute her “seed” to Doro’s experiments; 2) Marshal those outside of Doro’s colonies to act against him; 3) Kill him; 4) Imprison him where he can’t hurt anyone again.
Which brings me to the gaping plot holes in this novel.
1) With Doro’s ability, he could amass a fortune, and through fear and his apparent seductiveness create armies, conquer nations, and pretty much do anything he wants. And all he wants to do is piddle around with small scale animal husbandry that for a millennia has failed to produce any material results? Not very ambitious for a demon as sadistic as Doro.
2) What is the purpose of his experimentation? NO ONE EVER ASKS! It’s THE most obvious question and NO ONE EVER ASKS!
3) For Doro to pass from one body to the next the story suggests he must be either touching or in very close proximity to the victim. If true, there are countless means one might capture or kill him (drug him, sink his ship at sea, blow his head off when few people are around to jump to, bury him in a hole, a cell, or the ocean where he can’t connect to anyone ever again). No one in the roughly 200 years covered in the novel even tries to counter him. They all just roll over.
Finally, I believe Butler intended Wild Seed to be read as a kind of love story between two entities destined to always feel alone because they can’t die. Butler writes several times that they need each other. I call bullshit on this notion. Anyanwu is never alone. She is a mother figure, always connecting to others and birthing descendants. Over and over she speaks of loving those she surrounds herself with through the generations, and of the joy of seeing them grow and develop….And then shacks up repeatedly with the Mengele serial killer showing that she also revels in victimhood, misery and death.
This is the first book I’ve read where I cringed all the way through. It has no redeeming quality. The content far overshadows for me Butler’s writing which has won many awards. Given the book's better than four star rating on GR others clearly read this book differently. I’ll not be continuing this series nor Do I recommend this book to anyone.
The story focuses on two “people.” Doro is an evil shade thousands of years old who survives by jumping from body to body, killing the host, and absorbing the new body’s energy to survive until jumping to the next host at few week intervals. He has thus killed some hundred thousand people when this book begins.
His entertainment over the millennia is rounding up people with special abilities—mind reading, healing, telekinesis—and breeding them like animals—stranger to stranger, father to daughter, mother to son, sons to daughters—in Joseph Mengele fashion to create offspring with enhanced abilities to no real purpose other than his amusement, and as food. The more powerful the offspring, the more satisfying when he takes their bodies. None with power enough to challenge Doro are allowed to live. He has no empathy. He rules by fear and the seductiveness of the devil.
Anyanwu is also immortal. Born with the ability to manipulate every cell in her body, she has for hundreds of years been a wife, mother and healer to those around her. Doro finds her and desires to breed her as “wild seed” in his breeding colonies.
And my problems and disgust with this novel begin.
Anyanwu initially welcomes Doro to her bed and follows him hoping to protect her extended family from also becoming breeding stock. When it becomes apparent that nothing will stop Doro, she becomes his willingness accomplice and enabler, giving birth to many children by the various incarnations of Doro himself as well as allowing herself to be prostituted to men of Doro’s choosing to beget their children, even after she is married to Doro’s son, who himself is prostituted to many women to impregnate them. All in furtherance of Doro’s breeding experiments. Like a woman with battered wife syndrome, Ananyu knowingly and willing participates as Doro’s destroys the lives of those around her, taking even some of her own children as hosts.
Late in the book Anyanwu escapes and founds her own colony bringing together people of extraordinary abilities like those sought by Doro, but with the purpose of healing their souls to lead normal lives after being ostracized from society, hunted or tortured. Doro of course eventually finds her and her community. And she takes him back like a lover, abetting him to again destroy everything she’s built.
Butler seeks to paint Anyanwu as a Florence Nightengale figure who comforts the damaged in the face of unspeakable horrors. But she is decidedly not. She enables much of the horror by actively supporting Doro’s experiments, excusing her actions as necessary to enable her to heal some of the victims. She is the accomplice who puts a bandage on your arm before allowing the serial killer to eat you.
Actions she could have taken instead: 1) Leave and never again contribute her “seed” to Doro’s experiments; 2) Marshal those outside of Doro’s colonies to act against him; 3) Kill him; 4) Imprison him where he can’t hurt anyone again.
Which brings me to the gaping plot holes in this novel.
1) With Doro’s ability, he could amass a fortune, and through fear and his apparent seductiveness create armies, conquer nations, and pretty much do anything he wants. And all he wants to do is piddle around with small scale animal husbandry that for a millennia has failed to produce any material results? Not very ambitious for a demon as sadistic as Doro.
2) What is the purpose of his experimentation? NO ONE EVER ASKS! It’s THE most obvious question and NO ONE EVER ASKS!
3) For Doro to pass from one body to the next the story suggests he must be either touching or in very close proximity to the victim. If true, there are countless means one might capture or kill him (drug him, sink his ship at sea, blow his head off when few people are around to jump to, bury him in a hole, a cell, or the ocean where he can’t connect to anyone ever again). No one in the roughly 200 years covered in the novel even tries to counter him. They all just roll over.
Finally, I believe Butler intended Wild Seed to be read as a kind of love story between two entities destined to always feel alone because they can’t die. Butler writes several times that they need each other. I call bullshit on this notion. Anyanwu is never alone. She is a mother figure, always connecting to others and birthing descendants. Over and over she speaks of loving those she surrounds herself with through the generations, and of the joy of seeing them grow and develop….And then shacks up repeatedly with the Mengele serial killer showing that she also revels in victimhood, misery and death.
This is the first book I’ve read where I cringed all the way through. It has no redeeming quality. The content far overshadows for me Butler’s writing which has won many awards. Given the book's better than four star rating on GR others clearly read this book differently. I’ll not be continuing this series nor Do I recommend this book to anyone.
May 23, 2021
2021 Reread review:
The 2021 updated version of the audiobook narrated by Robin Miles is nothing short of divine.
Well worth the repurchase.
Now I demand an update to the rest of her books!
What can I say, I adore Anyanwu💜
Reread 2020 review:
Anyanwu remains my most beloved literary character ever.I CAN NOT wait until this becomes a TV show🥰
The 2021 updated version of the audiobook narrated by Robin Miles is nothing short of divine.
Well worth the repurchase.
Now I demand an update to the rest of her books!
What can I say, I adore Anyanwu💜
Reread 2020 review:
Anyanwu remains my most beloved literary character ever.I CAN NOT wait until this becomes a TV show🥰
July 11, 2021
I had heard of Octavia Butler before – I'd heard of books like kindred and the parable of the sower. But I had never heard of this series, The Patternist. And I didn’t know what to expect at all. I didn’t even really read the plot of this one. I knew it was a prequel to The Patternist – which is some sort of dystopian sci-fi. Everyone raves about Butler’s writing and prose, and when I saw a recent review of one of the later books in this series it sounded fascinating so I thought I would pick this up and try the audio version. I have been in a bit of a reading slump, I tried a few audiobooks I couldn’t get into – So I started listening to this one while hanging out the washing last week. AND OH MY GOODNESS! I couldn’t turn it off!
From the very first section of the book, I was utterly enthralled. I had no idea what was going on, but I didn’t care. I just wanted to be along for the ride.
Doro is an immortal being who jumps from body to body and lives for thousands of years. Anyanwu is also powerful, she can heal herself and shapeshift at will. When Doro finds Anyanwo in Nigeria and convinces her to travel with him she assumes she will be his wife and live in a new colony of people that he has created with special gifts. However, she soon comes to realise that she has been coerced into being a breeder for Doro’s ultimate goal of breeding a race of humans with amazing powers that will overrun the world.
How have I not read anything from Octavia Butler before? Just incredible! I adored how she wrote this one and I am hoping that all her other stories are written as flawlessly! I don’t know quite how to describe it. While other authors write stories, she weaves ideas and plot together in such an amazing seemless way. There was a point of the book where it hit me that she has just given me a big lesson in ethics and humanity. But not just delivered the lesson to me, but made me FEEL it. Made me actually FEEL the themes that she delves into.
And the audiobook! Absolutely fantastic! I would say the BEST female narrator I have ever heard (and I have over 300 titles in my library!). Her portrayal of all the characters was absolutely superb. I was gripped on to every single word and character.
Yes, parts of it were slower-moving, but I have not been able to stop thinking about this novel since I finished it! It has been a very long time that a book has moved me so much, in such an amazing way.
I would not recommend it if you are in the mood for a light read. There are some dark, bleak themes in these pages. What is humanity? Why do we do the things that we do? We live, breed and die. Is that all that we do? Is this all that we are leaving in our wake? What would happen if we could live forever – Would we view the world as Doro? Or as Anyanwu? Butler makes you consciously wonder what on earth the point of all of this is. But at the same time, captivate you with the world’s beauty. I have never read anything like this.
Doro. I loathe him but at the same time – what a magnificent character! How lonely it must be to live millennia, all alone. With nothing else to do but try and manipulate the future through advancing the human race. What would any of us do in his place?
My gosh, my brain hurts. I am thinking about things I have never even considered before. And FEELING it at a level that I never knew existed before this book. Eugenics and morality. Hope and despair. Humanity and the meaning of life.
How have I never read anything of Butlers before now? This was written BEFORE I WAS BORN and yet is so pressing to the events of today’s world.
I absolutely cannot wait to read more of her work. I have so much to catch up on! I am going straight on to the second in the Patternmaster series after Wild Seed, Mind of My Mind.
For more reviews check out my:
YouTube
Blog
Instagram
Twitter
Facebook
From the very first section of the book, I was utterly enthralled. I had no idea what was going on, but I didn’t care. I just wanted to be along for the ride.
Doro is an immortal being who jumps from body to body and lives for thousands of years. Anyanwu is also powerful, she can heal herself and shapeshift at will. When Doro finds Anyanwo in Nigeria and convinces her to travel with him she assumes she will be his wife and live in a new colony of people that he has created with special gifts. However, she soon comes to realise that she has been coerced into being a breeder for Doro’s ultimate goal of breeding a race of humans with amazing powers that will overrun the world.
How have I not read anything from Octavia Butler before? Just incredible! I adored how she wrote this one and I am hoping that all her other stories are written as flawlessly! I don’t know quite how to describe it. While other authors write stories, she weaves ideas and plot together in such an amazing seemless way. There was a point of the book where it hit me that she has just given me a big lesson in ethics and humanity. But not just delivered the lesson to me, but made me FEEL it. Made me actually FEEL the themes that she delves into.
And the audiobook! Absolutely fantastic! I would say the BEST female narrator I have ever heard (and I have over 300 titles in my library!). Her portrayal of all the characters was absolutely superb. I was gripped on to every single word and character.
Yes, parts of it were slower-moving, but I have not been able to stop thinking about this novel since I finished it! It has been a very long time that a book has moved me so much, in such an amazing way.
I would not recommend it if you are in the mood for a light read. There are some dark, bleak themes in these pages. What is humanity? Why do we do the things that we do? We live, breed and die. Is that all that we do? Is this all that we are leaving in our wake? What would happen if we could live forever – Would we view the world as Doro? Or as Anyanwu? Butler makes you consciously wonder what on earth the point of all of this is. But at the same time, captivate you with the world’s beauty. I have never read anything like this.
Doro. I loathe him but at the same time – what a magnificent character! How lonely it must be to live millennia, all alone. With nothing else to do but try and manipulate the future through advancing the human race. What would any of us do in his place?
My gosh, my brain hurts. I am thinking about things I have never even considered before. And FEELING it at a level that I never knew existed before this book. Eugenics and morality. Hope and despair. Humanity and the meaning of life.
How have I never read anything of Butlers before now? This was written BEFORE I WAS BORN and yet is so pressing to the events of today’s world.
I absolutely cannot wait to read more of her work. I have so much to catch up on! I am going straight on to the second in the Patternmaster series after Wild Seed, Mind of My Mind.
For more reviews check out my:
YouTube
Blog
June 21, 2024
Wild Seed is the story of two immortal beings and the human “families” they birth, gather, and breed. Set against the backdrop of the Atlantic slave trade, it is an unassuming epic, played out across centuries and continents—the kind of story that races headlong through time, and yet feels as if it has lingered, so distinct is the impression each part leaves. A tale of immortal lovers, of callous disregard for human life, of a world so defined by violence that even mercy is a kind of violence, even love.
Like its predecessors Patternmaster, Mind of My Mind, and Survivor, Wild Seed is tonally and thematically indeterminate—utterly horrifying, sickening, just plain sick, and then, a few pages later, almost giddy with invention, with the joy of storytelling. Here, the themes and obsessions Butler was visibly struggling to work out in the earlier Patternist novels crystalize: above all, what it means to exercise power over people’s bodies and over their minds—the kinds of power forged by legal and economic structures and the kinds of power forged within intimate relationships, amongst kin, between lovers. These registers of power outline their own negative image: a vast gray area between survival, submission, and acceptance.
The horror of slavery is a fitting backdrop for Butler’s exploration of inhumanity and unhumanity. Only the unhuman, the novel suggests, can make sense of a history so monstrous. At the same time, the novel refuses to let the violence of slavery define the parameters of community, of family, even of violence, power, race; which is, perhaps, a sideways glance at a kind of hope.
Like its predecessors Patternmaster, Mind of My Mind, and Survivor, Wild Seed is tonally and thematically indeterminate—utterly horrifying, sickening, just plain sick, and then, a few pages later, almost giddy with invention, with the joy of storytelling. Here, the themes and obsessions Butler was visibly struggling to work out in the earlier Patternist novels crystalize: above all, what it means to exercise power over people’s bodies and over their minds—the kinds of power forged by legal and economic structures and the kinds of power forged within intimate relationships, amongst kin, between lovers. These registers of power outline their own negative image: a vast gray area between survival, submission, and acceptance.
The horror of slavery is a fitting backdrop for Butler’s exploration of inhumanity and unhumanity. Only the unhuman, the novel suggests, can make sense of a history so monstrous. At the same time, the novel refuses to let the violence of slavery define the parameters of community, of family, even of violence, power, race; which is, perhaps, a sideways glance at a kind of hope.
March 9, 2018
School book this semester & was not a fan. It gave me the creeps
January 12, 2015
A great book, I can’t believe that I just discovered Octavia Butler this year. She has been one the gems that I have encountered while reading through the NPR list of classic science fiction and fantasy. This novel could easily be a stand-alone novel, but I was intrigued when I realized it was the first in a series—I will be very interested to see where Butler takes the story from here.
Although this is another book about extraordinarily long life, Butler examines it from a very different view point. Two very long-lived beings encounter one another and despite a relationship that is uneven in power, their lives remain entwined. There is as interesting exploration of the nature of slavery and the uneven power situation (examined much more directly in Butler’s novel, Kindred). But what really spoke to me was the contrasting way that Doro and Anyanwu deal with people around them.
Now, I have found over the years that I enjoy my relatives immensely. I like spending time with them, talking to them regularly, and planning events to share with them. Anyanwu was my kind of immortal. She collected family around herself, surrounding herself with children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, etc., building a community of relatives all around her and enjoying their company. Completely different from Doro, who was also surrounded by descendants, but looked at them more as a farmer would regard his livestock—breeding them in an attempt to create people with special abilities including extra-long life. One doing it out of love, the other out of utility.
I’m only guessing, but I think that Anne Rice must have read this book—it reminds me strongly of her book The Witching Hour, where the family of Mayfair women are haunted by a malevolent spirit which nudges them towards the sexual liaisons that would be required to produce the qualities it required in their children in every bit as calculating a way as Doro manipulates his progeny.
This is the 151st book that I have read from the NPR list.
Although this is another book about extraordinarily long life, Butler examines it from a very different view point. Two very long-lived beings encounter one another and despite a relationship that is uneven in power, their lives remain entwined. There is as interesting exploration of the nature of slavery and the uneven power situation (examined much more directly in Butler’s novel, Kindred). But what really spoke to me was the contrasting way that Doro and Anyanwu deal with people around them.
Now, I have found over the years that I enjoy my relatives immensely. I like spending time with them, talking to them regularly, and planning events to share with them. Anyanwu was my kind of immortal. She collected family around herself, surrounding herself with children, grandchildren, great-grandchildren, etc., building a community of relatives all around her and enjoying their company. Completely different from Doro, who was also surrounded by descendants, but looked at them more as a farmer would regard his livestock—breeding them in an attempt to create people with special abilities including extra-long life. One doing it out of love, the other out of utility.
I’m only guessing, but I think that Anne Rice must have read this book—it reminds me strongly of her book The Witching Hour, where the family of Mayfair women are haunted by a malevolent spirit which nudges them towards the sexual liaisons that would be required to produce the qualities it required in their children in every bit as calculating a way as Doro manipulates his progeny.
This is the 151st book that I have read from the NPR list.
September 5, 2022
4/5 stars.
Before I go into my review, I want to make a note of something. There are two ways to read Octavia E. Butler's Patternist series: the order in which it was published--Patternmaster (1976), Mind of My Mind (1977), Survivor (1978, disowned and never put back into publication), Wild Seed (1980), and Clay's Ark (1984); or the chronological order of the in-universe story--Wild Seed (set in the 1600s and 1700s), Mind of My Mind (set in the 70s, contemporary for when Butler wrote it), Clay' Arks (set in a futuristic dystopia), Survivor (set in space and on another planet), and Patternmaster (very far future where humanity is divided). I have chosen to read it in the chronological order at the advice of a friend and because I prefer to read it that way.
Wild Seed, as shown above, is the earliest part of the series. It follows Anyanwu, an immortal Igbo woman who can shapeshift her body into anything she can take into, or cannibalize into, her body, and Doro, an ancient Kush man (what is now North and South Sudan) who can transfer his soul or essence into the body of any person of any gender and any race who is also immortal. Doro is gifted with telepathic powers and has for centuries sired offspring and charted out his own descendants and even bred with said descendants. When he finds Anyanwu, he takes her with him to America, promising to never hurt her children and her own descendants. But Doro is a powerful man who can intimidate anyone, and he rarely keeps his promises.
This was a great introduction to Butler's work. It isn't perfect, but it's pretty darn good. Much like Frank Herbert's Dune, Butler employs an omniscient third-person to tell the story. I think it was appropriate to use in order to get into both Anyanwu and Doro's heads and emotions. However, it did sometimes lead to telling and not showing and there were some moments where the narrative was interrupted but a brief info dump of a certain character or event from some time prior to the current narrative; albeit this only happened more toward the end of the book.
I was ultimately compelled by both Anyanwu and Doro's stories and actions to keep reading. Anyanwy just wants a family and peace. She constantly struggled against the world around her to live this constantly escaping dream. She only fought when she really had to; she resisted this constantly but would have to end up fighting or fleeing in order to get what she wanted. Doro, on the other hand, was quite the villain. His entire breeding plan is pure eugenics, but it's amazing in its own twisted, messed-up way. He seeks to create more psionic descendants like him, searching for those closest like him and weeding out those with weaker or no abilities. The intimidation and fear he puts into people by merely just standing there shows just how dominating he is. Anyone he didn't need he would let them die off in one way or another or he would take over their bodies and then transfer to another one to let them die. Anyanwu prevents many of his attempts to do this, telling him he can't rule his own place or family by violent force.
This dual relationship between Anyanwu and Doro shows, at first, a common divide often shown in early sci-fi works. The male character is cold and terrifying and rules through force, and the female one is passive and nurturing and cares for others. Butler brilliant shows the gradual eroding of this dualism, or at least the beginnings of it. While Anyanwu is still generally sympathetic and compassionate to others and Doro still domineering, the stereotypical and resolute roles and personalities they fill become undone. Anyanwu realizes she can't always stay and be compassionate to defend herself and her loved ones and family. Doro realizes that the more he rules through fear the more his children and descendants will resist him and defect to Anyanwu; and he does--somewhat--become more compassionate towards the end of the book, though he still wants to control Anyanwu. Doro still represents patriarchal power, obviously, and is much more intimidating then some of Anyanwu's first Igbo husbands, however he seems to show how patriarchal power can mold to rise of culture. Anyanwu, with her constantly changing body, represented how the boundaries between culture and nature can blur and how humans are intrinsically apart of both.
It was this vie for control, this endless chase between Anyanwu and Doro, that fueled everything in the story. Both of them can change their bodies, thus transcending race and gender, but at the heart of themselves both Anyanwu and Doro are two, immortal Africans who struggle for their own freedoms. Their freedoms from not only what is going on their world at the time, but from each other as well. They are both repelled and drawn to each other in an endless dance for agency and a future for their descendants.
There were other characters I enjoyed, such as Isaac, one of Anyanwu's most beloved husbands. I was saddened by his death. He along with other members of Anyanwu and Doro's families were meant to be mirrors of their relationship and the fallout it caused. Anyanwu and Doro are like Afrocentric, super-powered, alternative versions of Adam and Eve; this is the genesis of their story and the story of their descendants and how the initial interactions and actions--their original sins, if you will--become a consequence for the future to come.
If there was anything I frustrated about, despite my praise of this book, was Anyanwu's continued ability to give Doro another chance. I understand this was apart of her nature and arc to seem sympathetic, but after everything horrible Doro did it just got more frustrating.
Overall, I can't wait to continue this series to see what happens to the rest of the world and Anyanwu and Doro's descendants.
Before I go into my review, I want to make a note of something. There are two ways to read Octavia E. Butler's Patternist series: the order in which it was published--Patternmaster (1976), Mind of My Mind (1977), Survivor (1978, disowned and never put back into publication), Wild Seed (1980), and Clay's Ark (1984); or the chronological order of the in-universe story--Wild Seed (set in the 1600s and 1700s), Mind of My Mind (set in the 70s, contemporary for when Butler wrote it), Clay' Arks (set in a futuristic dystopia), Survivor (set in space and on another planet), and Patternmaster (very far future where humanity is divided). I have chosen to read it in the chronological order at the advice of a friend and because I prefer to read it that way.
Wild Seed, as shown above, is the earliest part of the series. It follows Anyanwu, an immortal Igbo woman who can shapeshift her body into anything she can take into, or cannibalize into, her body, and Doro, an ancient Kush man (what is now North and South Sudan) who can transfer his soul or essence into the body of any person of any gender and any race who is also immortal. Doro is gifted with telepathic powers and has for centuries sired offspring and charted out his own descendants and even bred with said descendants. When he finds Anyanwu, he takes her with him to America, promising to never hurt her children and her own descendants. But Doro is a powerful man who can intimidate anyone, and he rarely keeps his promises.
This was a great introduction to Butler's work. It isn't perfect, but it's pretty darn good. Much like Frank Herbert's Dune, Butler employs an omniscient third-person to tell the story. I think it was appropriate to use in order to get into both Anyanwu and Doro's heads and emotions. However, it did sometimes lead to telling and not showing and there were some moments where the narrative was interrupted but a brief info dump of a certain character or event from some time prior to the current narrative; albeit this only happened more toward the end of the book.
I was ultimately compelled by both Anyanwu and Doro's stories and actions to keep reading. Anyanwy just wants a family and peace. She constantly struggled against the world around her to live this constantly escaping dream. She only fought when she really had to; she resisted this constantly but would have to end up fighting or fleeing in order to get what she wanted. Doro, on the other hand, was quite the villain. His entire breeding plan is pure eugenics, but it's amazing in its own twisted, messed-up way. He seeks to create more psionic descendants like him, searching for those closest like him and weeding out those with weaker or no abilities. The intimidation and fear he puts into people by merely just standing there shows just how dominating he is. Anyone he didn't need he would let them die off in one way or another or he would take over their bodies and then transfer to another one to let them die. Anyanwu prevents many of his attempts to do this, telling him he can't rule his own place or family by violent force.
This dual relationship between Anyanwu and Doro shows, at first, a common divide often shown in early sci-fi works. The male character is cold and terrifying and rules through force, and the female one is passive and nurturing and cares for others. Butler brilliant shows the gradual eroding of this dualism, or at least the beginnings of it. While Anyanwu is still generally sympathetic and compassionate to others and Doro still domineering, the stereotypical and resolute roles and personalities they fill become undone. Anyanwu realizes she can't always stay and be compassionate to defend herself and her loved ones and family. Doro realizes that the more he rules through fear the more his children and descendants will resist him and defect to Anyanwu; and he does--somewhat--become more compassionate towards the end of the book, though he still wants to control Anyanwu. Doro still represents patriarchal power, obviously, and is much more intimidating then some of Anyanwu's first Igbo husbands, however he seems to show how patriarchal power can mold to rise of culture. Anyanwu, with her constantly changing body, represented how the boundaries between culture and nature can blur and how humans are intrinsically apart of both.
It was this vie for control, this endless chase between Anyanwu and Doro, that fueled everything in the story. Both of them can change their bodies, thus transcending race and gender, but at the heart of themselves both Anyanwu and Doro are two, immortal Africans who struggle for their own freedoms. Their freedoms from not only what is going on their world at the time, but from each other as well. They are both repelled and drawn to each other in an endless dance for agency and a future for their descendants.
There were other characters I enjoyed, such as Isaac, one of Anyanwu's most beloved husbands. I was saddened by his death. He along with other members of Anyanwu and Doro's families were meant to be mirrors of their relationship and the fallout it caused. Anyanwu and Doro are like Afrocentric, super-powered, alternative versions of Adam and Eve; this is the genesis of their story and the story of their descendants and how the initial interactions and actions--their original sins, if you will--become a consequence for the future to come.
If there was anything I frustrated about, despite my praise of this book, was Anyanwu's continued ability to give Doro another chance. I understand this was apart of her nature and arc to seem sympathetic, but after everything horrible Doro did it just got more frustrating.
Overall, I can't wait to continue this series to see what happens to the rest of the world and Anyanwu and Doro's descendants.
January 1, 2023
A unique fantasy novel that centers around supernatural/superhuman characters from Africa. The story begins in the time of slavery, when slaves were captured and brought to America. I found it to be a very unique and refreshing premise, compared to the common tropes of fantasy, be they paranormal or Tolkeinian.
The two central characters (and antagonists) were interesting personalities. One seems to represent the Earth Mother--the power of healing and nature and animals. The other seems to represent Patriarchy and masculinity and control. And although they both have great power in many ways, the male force is dominant and relatively unstoppable. Doro, the male, can't be killed, and he can kill anyone at will by taking over his or her body, and then abandoing that body to move into a new one. He essentially takes over their brain and then leaves it empty when he's done. Anyanwu can heal almost any injury, sickness or disease in her own body and can transform it into an animal once she observes that animal closely. She has near total control of her body and can even disguise herself to appear as any human shape she chooses. She also does not age and like Doro may never die unless her body is physically destroyed.
Wild Seed is a story of power, of slavery, of social control and of gender issues. It's also a story filled with powerful emotions, the pain of loss and the struggle to develop empathy. It's also a story of compromises, and the choices that are made by those with less power in order to survive.
The following spoiler relates to what does NOT happen in the book, not what DOES happen. But if you are looking to avoid any tip-off, then please avoid it.
In the hands of a lesser writer,
Wonderfully told with profound and meaningful themes invoked without facile answers. This is great storytelling. Would appeal to anyone looking for an unusual refreshing take on the fantasy genre with socially powerful meaning.
The two central characters (and antagonists) were interesting personalities. One seems to represent the Earth Mother--the power of healing and nature and animals. The other seems to represent Patriarchy and masculinity and control. And although they both have great power in many ways, the male force is dominant and relatively unstoppable. Doro, the male, can't be killed, and he can kill anyone at will by taking over his or her body, and then abandoing that body to move into a new one. He essentially takes over their brain and then leaves it empty when he's done. Anyanwu can heal almost any injury, sickness or disease in her own body and can transform it into an animal once she observes that animal closely. She has near total control of her body and can even disguise herself to appear as any human shape she chooses. She also does not age and like Doro may never die unless her body is physically destroyed.
Wild Seed is a story of power, of slavery, of social control and of gender issues. It's also a story filled with powerful emotions, the pain of loss and the struggle to develop empathy. It's also a story of compromises, and the choices that are made by those with less power in order to survive.
The following spoiler relates to what does NOT happen in the book, not what DOES happen. But if you are looking to avoid any tip-off, then please avoid it.
In the hands of a lesser writer,
Wonderfully told with profound and meaningful themes invoked without facile answers. This is great storytelling. Would appeal to anyone looking for an unusual refreshing take on the fantasy genre with socially powerful meaning.
Read
February 7, 2022"You are all I have, perhaps all I would ever have." She shook her head slowly. "And you are an obscenity."
So What's It About?
Wild Seed tells the story of Anyanwu, an Igbo woman who has lived for hundreds of years through her regenerative powers and her ability to shapeshift into any living form. She catches the attention of Doro, another shapeshifter who is thousands of years old in comparison to her hundreds, and who survives by killing and inhabiting the bodies of those he kills. Doro is obsessed with a breeding project intended to create more humans with abilities like his, and he coerces Anyanwu - who he views as "wild seed" that is perfect for breeding in his program- into joining one of his American colonies by threatening her beloved descendants. This begins a centuries-long power struggle between the two.
What Did I Think?
Octavia Butler's books are spare, deliberate and relentless, and Wild Seed is no exception to this. It engages with questions of exploitation, control, and autonomy with fierce clarity. On one level, the central conflict between Anyanwu and Doro can be seen as a feminist struggle between Butler's interpretations of patriarchal and matriarchal power and society-building: Doro dehumanizes the occupants of his seed villages and thinks nothing of killing them or destroying their lives. When their powers cause them endless agony he views it as an inconvenience, worrying only about the pursuit of his own goals. Anyanwu builds flourishing communities based on compassion and the fundamental value of all human lives. It is a matter of control opposed to cooperation; destruction opposed to nurturance. Written in a time where complex and autonomous black heroines were almost a non-entity in speculative fiction, Wild Seed celebrates Anyanwu's resilience and struggle for agency, as well as her warmth, capacity for love and strong sense of morality. In addition, she gradually becomes comfortable enough to explore her ability to change genders/reproductive organs and cherish both male and female lovers. It is also a thoroughly Afrocentric novel where Anyanwu struggles to retain her Igbo values in the American colonies, and where immense emphasis is put upon her kinship networks. Anyanwu's coerced journey from her African home to the New World can be viewed as a kind of slave narrative, where her ability to reproduce is exploited for Doro's gain and she fights back and struggles with her own agency. There is also the matter of the secret plantation haven she creates to hide from Doro in the depths of the antebellum South:
'She owned no slaves. She had brought some of the people who worked for her and recruited the others among freedmen, but those she bought, she freed. They always stayed to work for her, feeling more comfortable with her and each other than they had ever been elsewhere. That always surprised the new ones. They were not used to being comfortable with other people. They were misfits, malcontents, troublemakers- though they did not make trouble for Anyanwu. They treated her as mother, older sister, teacher, and when she invited it, lover. Somehow, even this this last intimacy did nothing to diminish her authority. They knew her power. She was who she was, no matter what role she chose."
Doro's side of the story, with his relentless, ruthless drive to create a new type of human like himself, has a great deal to say about eugenics. Specifically, his cruelty demonstrates Butler's concerns about the dehumanization, devaluation of human life and abuse of power that she could not see becoming disentangled from enugenics and its goals. Doro's creation and control of "seed villages" can also be understood as a colonial project, with him as the embodiment of a colonizer in his exploitation and violence. As the book takes place in America from 1641 to 1841, there is also a great deal of commentary upon the nature of slavery. Doro works with European slavers in Africa to select and buy promising "stock" for his seed villages, and he maintains absolute control over the lives of his people, breeding them to perpetuate his own cruel goals and deciding how they live and when they live and die. The matter of his relationship with Anyanwu is at its heart one of control: he seeks to dominate her through coercion, isolation and the use of her family and community as leverage:
"Doro followed, thinking that he had better get her with a new child as quickly as he could. Her independence would vanish without a struggle. She would do whatever he asked then to keep her child safe...once she was isolated in America with an infant to care for, she would learn submissiveness."
Despite all of this, there remains a strange kind of connection and sense of kinship between them because of their shared status as immortal shapeshifters. It is with this in mind that we come to the ending. I don't know quite what to think of the ending, to be honest. I think it can be interpreted two ways. The first is this: Anyanwu continues to fight against Doro's power and leads her own prosperous community, and Doro begins to respect her autonomy a bit more. He "continue[s]" to do loathsome things" but "no longer [does] them to her," and this is as good as love for him. She is driven to the point of suicide by continual losses but changes her mind and decides that there is hope when Doro finally admits that he needs her. They come to a strange kind of compromise. The second interpretation is this: Anyanwu has struggled for centuries against Doro's abuse, and finally loses the will to fight as she has fought before, concluding that suicide is her only escape. Doro inflicts his manipulation upon her again, and she concedes to his desire that she live:
"She had submitted and submitted and submitted to keep him from killing her even though she had long ago ceased to believe what Isaac had told her - that her longevity made her the right mate for Doro...she had formed the habit of submission...habits were difficult to break."
Even if we accept the more optimistic possibility, it is still a deeply precarious resolution. Doro is not redeemed, and the changes that he has made in concession to Anyanwu at the end are not extensive: fundamentally, she "uncomfortably" settles into a life of protecting her community from Doro while maintaining a romantic relationship with him. I struggle with ambiguity in my book endings - it's difficult for me to sit with a lack of resolution. But why would I ever expect simplicity or an easy way out from Octavia Butler?
So What's It About?
Wild Seed tells the story of Anyanwu, an Igbo woman who has lived for hundreds of years through her regenerative powers and her ability to shapeshift into any living form. She catches the attention of Doro, another shapeshifter who is thousands of years old in comparison to her hundreds, and who survives by killing and inhabiting the bodies of those he kills. Doro is obsessed with a breeding project intended to create more humans with abilities like his, and he coerces Anyanwu - who he views as "wild seed" that is perfect for breeding in his program- into joining one of his American colonies by threatening her beloved descendants. This begins a centuries-long power struggle between the two.
What Did I Think?
Octavia Butler's books are spare, deliberate and relentless, and Wild Seed is no exception to this. It engages with questions of exploitation, control, and autonomy with fierce clarity. On one level, the central conflict between Anyanwu and Doro can be seen as a feminist struggle between Butler's interpretations of patriarchal and matriarchal power and society-building: Doro dehumanizes the occupants of his seed villages and thinks nothing of killing them or destroying their lives. When their powers cause them endless agony he views it as an inconvenience, worrying only about the pursuit of his own goals. Anyanwu builds flourishing communities based on compassion and the fundamental value of all human lives. It is a matter of control opposed to cooperation; destruction opposed to nurturance. Written in a time where complex and autonomous black heroines were almost a non-entity in speculative fiction, Wild Seed celebrates Anyanwu's resilience and struggle for agency, as well as her warmth, capacity for love and strong sense of morality. In addition, she gradually becomes comfortable enough to explore her ability to change genders/reproductive organs and cherish both male and female lovers. It is also a thoroughly Afrocentric novel where Anyanwu struggles to retain her Igbo values in the American colonies, and where immense emphasis is put upon her kinship networks. Anyanwu's coerced journey from her African home to the New World can be viewed as a kind of slave narrative, where her ability to reproduce is exploited for Doro's gain and she fights back and struggles with her own agency. There is also the matter of the secret plantation haven she creates to hide from Doro in the depths of the antebellum South:
'She owned no slaves. She had brought some of the people who worked for her and recruited the others among freedmen, but those she bought, she freed. They always stayed to work for her, feeling more comfortable with her and each other than they had ever been elsewhere. That always surprised the new ones. They were not used to being comfortable with other people. They were misfits, malcontents, troublemakers- though they did not make trouble for Anyanwu. They treated her as mother, older sister, teacher, and when she invited it, lover. Somehow, even this this last intimacy did nothing to diminish her authority. They knew her power. She was who she was, no matter what role she chose."
Doro's side of the story, with his relentless, ruthless drive to create a new type of human like himself, has a great deal to say about eugenics. Specifically, his cruelty demonstrates Butler's concerns about the dehumanization, devaluation of human life and abuse of power that she could not see becoming disentangled from enugenics and its goals. Doro's creation and control of "seed villages" can also be understood as a colonial project, with him as the embodiment of a colonizer in his exploitation and violence. As the book takes place in America from 1641 to 1841, there is also a great deal of commentary upon the nature of slavery. Doro works with European slavers in Africa to select and buy promising "stock" for his seed villages, and he maintains absolute control over the lives of his people, breeding them to perpetuate his own cruel goals and deciding how they live and when they live and die. The matter of his relationship with Anyanwu is at its heart one of control: he seeks to dominate her through coercion, isolation and the use of her family and community as leverage:
"Doro followed, thinking that he had better get her with a new child as quickly as he could. Her independence would vanish without a struggle. She would do whatever he asked then to keep her child safe...once she was isolated in America with an infant to care for, she would learn submissiveness."
Despite all of this, there remains a strange kind of connection and sense of kinship between them because of their shared status as immortal shapeshifters. It is with this in mind that we come to the ending. I don't know quite what to think of the ending, to be honest. I think it can be interpreted two ways. The first is this: Anyanwu continues to fight against Doro's power and leads her own prosperous community, and Doro begins to respect her autonomy a bit more. He "continue[s]" to do loathsome things" but "no longer [does] them to her," and this is as good as love for him. She is driven to the point of suicide by continual losses but changes her mind and decides that there is hope when Doro finally admits that he needs her. They come to a strange kind of compromise. The second interpretation is this: Anyanwu has struggled for centuries against Doro's abuse, and finally loses the will to fight as she has fought before, concluding that suicide is her only escape. Doro inflicts his manipulation upon her again, and she concedes to his desire that she live:
"She had submitted and submitted and submitted to keep him from killing her even though she had long ago ceased to believe what Isaac had told her - that her longevity made her the right mate for Doro...she had formed the habit of submission...habits were difficult to break."
Even if we accept the more optimistic possibility, it is still a deeply precarious resolution. Doro is not redeemed, and the changes that he has made in concession to Anyanwu at the end are not extensive: fundamentally, she "uncomfortably" settles into a life of protecting her community from Doro while maintaining a romantic relationship with him. I struggle with ambiguity in my book endings - it's difficult for me to sit with a lack of resolution. But why would I ever expect simplicity or an easy way out from Octavia Butler?
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
January 22, 2024
4.5/5
As Woolf once said Middlemarch is one of the few English books written for grown-ups, so too is this one of the few pieces of science fiction written for the real world, not marketing and academia. Of course, so chock full is this work with critical engagement and unflinching history that the cries of 'polemic' and 'bias' would not be an unlikely reaction. If that doesn't work, 'prosaic' could always be used as a strong condemnation via completely arbitrary standards of institutionalized repute. The work has too high of a rating for those sorts of epithets to have much of an effect, but not all creations inherently concerned with the same material in many of the same ways prove as undeniably excellent in their respective domains.
Black History Month as defined by the US Government has its last day tomorrow, and I wonder how much immortality would be required to value the conversation of the survival over the death of 'it's over, it's done, have a cookie to stave off the resolution cause it's never going to come.' The last of this is all white people creation, for after centuries of winning in the absolute worst ways known to humanity and then some, we can't imagine going out in any way other than that which we put upon others. A simpler explanation is that we love our money too much and would rather be run out on a rail than give it to those as reparation for a country's history of eugenicist leeching, but hey. Life's a mess and the reasons for a collective people's amnesia and hoarding of personal trauma at the expense of anyone who doesn't correctly foot the physiognomic bill must involve more than fear of violence and indoctrination via capitalism.
In this particular world of Butler's, the name of the game is power and its more subtle kin empathy. Along with the much increased measure of supernatural inclusion that I am suspect to gorging on, I liked this better than Kindred because of the vaster space Butler worked on for her creations. If there's one plus to my current philosophy class beyond my getting a measure of many an auspicious overheard name and finding the majority of them lacking, it's seeing where the body hatred came in, the disregard for existence other than the self, the splintering of mind and soul and truth that results in a class named 'Philosophy' and should really be 'Greek and English and Scottish and German Philosophy of Various Hopscotch Periods in Somewhat that Particular Order'. This is an ideological movement of centuries whose myriad challengers are still fringed around the main, so if you want to write a work that destabilizes a thought process that so smugly thinks of itself as the 'center', you need eons of time and continents of space.
Butler is not Anyanwu, but when it comes to the evil wrought by white supremacy in its breeding lines and uselessness makes waste, it's not hard to see that the main factor missing is humanity. Butler is also not Doro, but the prototype of the white serial killer bred on a millenia of alienation and instinctive thrill kill is not hard to construct with the aid of the canon of literature and film and creed. Anyone accusing this work of misandry, please. Accuse each and every vaulted work of misogyny, white supremacism, classism, heteronormativity, etc, etc, ad nauseam when appropriate, and you will actually work towards saving lives and spirits. Misandry? Try reverse racism while you're at it. If someone goes on a genocidal rampage against white men on a hegemonic scale and inculcates long lasting civilizations with the trend, I may start to take you seriously.
Will I scare away readers by saying that this work is ultimately a romance? If I do, they were not the right audience for this work anyway.
As Woolf once said Middlemarch is one of the few English books written for grown-ups, so too is this one of the few pieces of science fiction written for the real world, not marketing and academia. Of course, so chock full is this work with critical engagement and unflinching history that the cries of 'polemic' and 'bias' would not be an unlikely reaction. If that doesn't work, 'prosaic' could always be used as a strong condemnation via completely arbitrary standards of institutionalized repute. The work has too high of a rating for those sorts of epithets to have much of an effect, but not all creations inherently concerned with the same material in many of the same ways prove as undeniably excellent in their respective domains.
Black History Month as defined by the US Government has its last day tomorrow, and I wonder how much immortality would be required to value the conversation of the survival over the death of 'it's over, it's done, have a cookie to stave off the resolution cause it's never going to come.' The last of this is all white people creation, for after centuries of winning in the absolute worst ways known to humanity and then some, we can't imagine going out in any way other than that which we put upon others. A simpler explanation is that we love our money too much and would rather be run out on a rail than give it to those as reparation for a country's history of eugenicist leeching, but hey. Life's a mess and the reasons for a collective people's amnesia and hoarding of personal trauma at the expense of anyone who doesn't correctly foot the physiognomic bill must involve more than fear of violence and indoctrination via capitalism.
In this particular world of Butler's, the name of the game is power and its more subtle kin empathy. Along with the much increased measure of supernatural inclusion that I am suspect to gorging on, I liked this better than Kindred because of the vaster space Butler worked on for her creations. If there's one plus to my current philosophy class beyond my getting a measure of many an auspicious overheard name and finding the majority of them lacking, it's seeing where the body hatred came in, the disregard for existence other than the self, the splintering of mind and soul and truth that results in a class named 'Philosophy' and should really be 'Greek and English and Scottish and German Philosophy of Various Hopscotch Periods in Somewhat that Particular Order'. This is an ideological movement of centuries whose myriad challengers are still fringed around the main, so if you want to write a work that destabilizes a thought process that so smugly thinks of itself as the 'center', you need eons of time and continents of space.
Butler is not Anyanwu, but when it comes to the evil wrought by white supremacy in its breeding lines and uselessness makes waste, it's not hard to see that the main factor missing is humanity. Butler is also not Doro, but the prototype of the white serial killer bred on a millenia of alienation and instinctive thrill kill is not hard to construct with the aid of the canon of literature and film and creed. Anyone accusing this work of misandry, please. Accuse each and every vaulted work of misogyny, white supremacism, classism, heteronormativity, etc, etc, ad nauseam when appropriate, and you will actually work towards saving lives and spirits. Misandry? Try reverse racism while you're at it. If someone goes on a genocidal rampage against white men on a hegemonic scale and inculcates long lasting civilizations with the trend, I may start to take you seriously.
Will I scare away readers by saying that this work is ultimately a romance? If I do, they were not the right audience for this work anyway.
August 27, 2019
Octavia Butler enchanted me again with this hundreds of years tale of a shapeshifter and a bodysnatcher. At first I thought this was SF, but then it became fantasy. Not that I mind since it was so engrossing. Strong characters and stories that invoked emotions, from wonder, sadness, anger, frustration and a little bit of hope. Same formula with her Parable novels, this one also has a great, tenacious female main character, who still had lots of love to share despite living in a cruel world with horrible men.
March 5, 2016
Wild Seed: Two African immortals battle for supremacy in early America
Originally posted at Fantasy Literature
Wild Seed (1980) was written last in Octavia Butler’s 5-book PATTERNIST series, but comes first in chronology. The next books by internal chronology are Mind of My Mind (1977), Clay’s Ark (1984), and Patternmaster (1976). Butler was later unsatisfied with Survivor (1978) and elected to not have it reprinted, so I will focus on the main 4 volumes. Wild Seed is an origin story set well before later books and can stand on its own. It’s one of those books whose basic plot could be described in just a few paragraphs, but the themes it explores are deep, challenging, and thought-provoking. I’ve read a lot of academic discussion of the book, but my approach is always on whether the book is engaging as a SFF story.
It’s the story of Doro, a being who inhabits and discards human bodies at will, who first arose in the time of the Pharaohs in Egypt. Initially he was a just the sickly youngest child of 12 siblings, but when he was dying he accidentally took over his mother and father’s bodies to survive. After that he spent millennia continually switching bodies and creating seed colonies in West Africa where to attempts to breed people with psychic abilities, creating more and more powerful beings. However, if they ever become a threat to him, he destroys them without hesitation. For reasons unknown even to himself, he takes the greatest pleasure in taking the bodies of such psychic beings.
One day Doro detects the presence of Anyanwu, a powerful black female shape-shifter and healer. She can heal her own body and change into the shape of any animal or person, and has lived for over 300 years. Doro knows her genetic abilities could be tremendous if he breeds her with the right partners. Because Doro thinks of humans as merely livestock intended to further his psychic breeding projects. She is a proud creature, but she recognizes that his power is even greater and more lethal, so eventually she agrees to be taken to the New World on a slaver ship, taking the Middle Passage that so many slaves from Africa travelled. But because Doro rules the crew, who are mostly his ‘people’, including his white son Isaac, they don’t make the trip in chains. During the trip Anyanwu, who knows no English or Western customs, is slowly taught the ways of the New World.
Upon reaching the New World, Doro mates with Anyanwu but then decides that she should marry his son Isaac, as he thinks this union will produce the most promising offspring. Initially she is unhappy with this situation, but as she learns that Isaac is a decent man and nothing like his ruthless immortal father, she settles into this new life in the town of Wheatley. It turns out that Doro has numerous seed communities, and they revere and fear him as a god-like being who can take their lives at his whim. But he also provides them protection from Indian attacks and sometimes from White racism. Sometimes he takes white bodies, other times black bodies, but his freedom of movement is better with the former. So he comes and goes, checking on each place, mating with the most promising women, and then moving on.
The relationship of Doro and Anyanwu is an uneasy one – he knows that she does not love him and resents his ruthless killing and domination of his people. Yet he recognizes her value as a breeder. She is also a strong-willed woman who does not easily submit to him, a situation unthinkable for an all-powerful being like himself. One day fateful events involving Isaac and their daughter Nweke drive her to turn into an animal and run away, since Doro cannot track her in that form.
A hundred years later, Doro discovers Anyanwu in a Southern plantation colony, where she has been conducting her own version of a seed village, one lacking the fear of death and oppression of Doro. When he tries to force himself into this community, Anyanwu threatens to kill herself, the only viable threat for Doro. He agrees to back off and be less contemptuous of his seed people, but it is an ambiguous victory.
There are so many themes and dichotomies to explore here: master vs slave, man vs woman, white vs black, killer vs healer, Africa vs New World, African tribal networks vs modern Western communities, Colonialism vs Autonomy, Coercion vs Cooperation, etc. The genius about Butler’s books is that they dive into these complicated themes without resorting to convenient moralizing or stereotypes. The book is almost exclusively focused on the relationship of Doro and Anyanwu, but it is a constantly-shifting one. Certainly Doro is a capricious killer and parasite, treating his people like livestock that exist for his convenience only. But once he encounters the strong female presence of Anyanwu, whose powers manifest as a healer and protector of families and communities, he has to reassess his millennia of cruel behavior. And despite Anyanwu finding herself in the slave position initially, she does everything in her power to resist in a peaceful and reasoning way.
Their relationship is all about the struggle for control. Whether this plays itself out in gender, skin color, master vs slave, Old vs New World, we are constantly confronted with this dualism. And while Doro could be easily categorized as the dominant male, slaver and killer, he also has a paternalistic attitude towards his peoples. He also has a conflicted connection with race, taking over both black and white bodies, and understanding the New World ways of America but having millennia of experience in Africa and the Old World. Meanwhile, Anyanwu is in many ways like Dana, the protagonist of Butler’s Kindred, a strong woman forced into submission by a cruel and paternalistic master, but still retaining her resilience and strength, fighting to protect her family and children from harm. It is part of the centuries-long struggle that black women have fought against slavery and domination. This is a book that demands repeat readings, analysis, and reflection, but also remains a compulsive reading experience, a tight story focused on the complicated entwined fates of these immortal African beings.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Dion Graham, a gifted voice actor who has appeared in a number of films and dramas including The Wire. He is given a very difficult assignment here, which he pulls off magnificently. He needs to give a strong African identity to his two lead characters, Doro and Anyanwu, and also convey their immortal perspective. But once they reach America, they encounter various settlers and communities, and Doro himself is constantly switching bodies, so I was very impressed that Dion also switched accents accordingly.
Originally posted at Fantasy Literature
Wild Seed (1980) was written last in Octavia Butler’s 5-book PATTERNIST series, but comes first in chronology. The next books by internal chronology are Mind of My Mind (1977), Clay’s Ark (1984), and Patternmaster (1976). Butler was later unsatisfied with Survivor (1978) and elected to not have it reprinted, so I will focus on the main 4 volumes. Wild Seed is an origin story set well before later books and can stand on its own. It’s one of those books whose basic plot could be described in just a few paragraphs, but the themes it explores are deep, challenging, and thought-provoking. I’ve read a lot of academic discussion of the book, but my approach is always on whether the book is engaging as a SFF story.
It’s the story of Doro, a being who inhabits and discards human bodies at will, who first arose in the time of the Pharaohs in Egypt. Initially he was a just the sickly youngest child of 12 siblings, but when he was dying he accidentally took over his mother and father’s bodies to survive. After that he spent millennia continually switching bodies and creating seed colonies in West Africa where to attempts to breed people with psychic abilities, creating more and more powerful beings. However, if they ever become a threat to him, he destroys them without hesitation. For reasons unknown even to himself, he takes the greatest pleasure in taking the bodies of such psychic beings.
One day Doro detects the presence of Anyanwu, a powerful black female shape-shifter and healer. She can heal her own body and change into the shape of any animal or person, and has lived for over 300 years. Doro knows her genetic abilities could be tremendous if he breeds her with the right partners. Because Doro thinks of humans as merely livestock intended to further his psychic breeding projects. She is a proud creature, but she recognizes that his power is even greater and more lethal, so eventually she agrees to be taken to the New World on a slaver ship, taking the Middle Passage that so many slaves from Africa travelled. But because Doro rules the crew, who are mostly his ‘people’, including his white son Isaac, they don’t make the trip in chains. During the trip Anyanwu, who knows no English or Western customs, is slowly taught the ways of the New World.
Upon reaching the New World, Doro mates with Anyanwu but then decides that she should marry his son Isaac, as he thinks this union will produce the most promising offspring. Initially she is unhappy with this situation, but as she learns that Isaac is a decent man and nothing like his ruthless immortal father, she settles into this new life in the town of Wheatley. It turns out that Doro has numerous seed communities, and they revere and fear him as a god-like being who can take their lives at his whim. But he also provides them protection from Indian attacks and sometimes from White racism. Sometimes he takes white bodies, other times black bodies, but his freedom of movement is better with the former. So he comes and goes, checking on each place, mating with the most promising women, and then moving on.
The relationship of Doro and Anyanwu is an uneasy one – he knows that she does not love him and resents his ruthless killing and domination of his people. Yet he recognizes her value as a breeder. She is also a strong-willed woman who does not easily submit to him, a situation unthinkable for an all-powerful being like himself. One day fateful events involving Isaac and their daughter Nweke drive her to turn into an animal and run away, since Doro cannot track her in that form.
A hundred years later, Doro discovers Anyanwu in a Southern plantation colony, where she has been conducting her own version of a seed village, one lacking the fear of death and oppression of Doro. When he tries to force himself into this community, Anyanwu threatens to kill herself, the only viable threat for Doro. He agrees to back off and be less contemptuous of his seed people, but it is an ambiguous victory.
There are so many themes and dichotomies to explore here: master vs slave, man vs woman, white vs black, killer vs healer, Africa vs New World, African tribal networks vs modern Western communities, Colonialism vs Autonomy, Coercion vs Cooperation, etc. The genius about Butler’s books is that they dive into these complicated themes without resorting to convenient moralizing or stereotypes. The book is almost exclusively focused on the relationship of Doro and Anyanwu, but it is a constantly-shifting one. Certainly Doro is a capricious killer and parasite, treating his people like livestock that exist for his convenience only. But once he encounters the strong female presence of Anyanwu, whose powers manifest as a healer and protector of families and communities, he has to reassess his millennia of cruel behavior. And despite Anyanwu finding herself in the slave position initially, she does everything in her power to resist in a peaceful and reasoning way.
Their relationship is all about the struggle for control. Whether this plays itself out in gender, skin color, master vs slave, Old vs New World, we are constantly confronted with this dualism. And while Doro could be easily categorized as the dominant male, slaver and killer, he also has a paternalistic attitude towards his peoples. He also has a conflicted connection with race, taking over both black and white bodies, and understanding the New World ways of America but having millennia of experience in Africa and the Old World. Meanwhile, Anyanwu is in many ways like Dana, the protagonist of Butler’s Kindred, a strong woman forced into submission by a cruel and paternalistic master, but still retaining her resilience and strength, fighting to protect her family and children from harm. It is part of the centuries-long struggle that black women have fought against slavery and domination. This is a book that demands repeat readings, analysis, and reflection, but also remains a compulsive reading experience, a tight story focused on the complicated entwined fates of these immortal African beings.
I listened to the audiobook narrated by Dion Graham, a gifted voice actor who has appeared in a number of films and dramas including The Wire. He is given a very difficult assignment here, which he pulls off magnificently. He needs to give a strong African identity to his two lead characters, Doro and Anyanwu, and also convey their immortal perspective. But once they reach America, they encounter various settlers and communities, and Doro himself is constantly switching bodies, so I was very impressed that Dion also switched accents accordingly.
January 7, 2021
A+, her best (per me). Immortal body-shifter vs. shape-changer. Awesome book, based on West African legends and folktales, with a dose of Hollywood flash (she grew up in SoCal). This would be a great graphic novel. Or Marvel comic!
There's a long-term exhibit of her papers up at the Huntington. Almost worth braving the horrors of LA traffic. She gave them her stuff: https://www.huntington.org/verso/2018... Great leading photo!
Died way too young. RIP.
Notes for 2018 reread, in progress:
Currently rereading this early Butler novel, based on (I think) West African folk tales, but fundamentally a contest between two mighty Superheros, or at least superpowered immortals: Doro the amoral body-swapper vs Anyanwu the immortal shape-changer. This is my favorite of Butler's novels, and is startling in its directness and clarity. I'm looking forward to the rest of the reread of this 1980 novel, which seems as fresh now as it did almost 40 years ago.
I didn't finish rereading it (library book came due), but I will, sometime. Third reading, per booklog.
There's a long-term exhibit of her papers up at the Huntington. Almost worth braving the horrors of LA traffic. She gave them her stuff: https://www.huntington.org/verso/2018... Great leading photo!
Died way too young. RIP.
Notes for 2018 reread, in progress:
Currently rereading this early Butler novel, based on (I think) West African folk tales, but fundamentally a contest between two mighty Superheros, or at least superpowered immortals: Doro the amoral body-swapper vs Anyanwu the immortal shape-changer. This is my favorite of Butler's novels, and is startling in its directness and clarity. I'm looking forward to the rest of the reread of this 1980 novel, which seems as fresh now as it did almost 40 years ago.
I didn't finish rereading it (library book came due), but I will, sometime. Third reading, per booklog.
September 7, 2024
Butler writes a story here about people with superhuman powers, mutants like X-Men... One is an African woman who can change her shape,becoming a leopard or an eagle or a dolphin....or? Opposing her is an immortal man who can't die as he can change bodies at will, so when one body dies, he jumps to the next. The two mutants face each other in a conflict that takes them from Africa to the English colonies in North America in the 18th Century...The characters were great, but the story seemed to be unfinished. I guess it is part of a series?
Postscript: I am not changing the above review from the first time I read this book. But I have found out that it is indeed part of a series! It's actually the origin story for Butler's "Patternmaster" series. It's followed by "Mind of my Mind," "Clay's Ark," "Survivor," and "Patternmaster." This follows the internal chronology of the series, not the order of publication. I'll be looking for the rest of the series... Regarding Octavia Butler, she passed away in 2006 at the age of 58, far far too young...
Postscript: I am not changing the above review from the first time I read this book. But I have found out that it is indeed part of a series! It's actually the origin story for Butler's "Patternmaster" series. It's followed by "Mind of my Mind," "Clay's Ark," "Survivor," and "Patternmaster." This follows the internal chronology of the series, not the order of publication. I'll be looking for the rest of the series... Regarding Octavia Butler, she passed away in 2006 at the age of 58, far far too young...
July 23, 2022
Although this is the first story of the Patternmaster in its internal chronology, and also the first I read, it was the third that was written. It was easy to follow even without knowing what it was building up towards.
I've had bristly relationships with books before, and this one was worse than most. Charismatic strongmen can be utter garbage tier bags full of dicks toward those under their thumbs. Yep, got it. "But wait! Are you sure you don't want to hear about another incident where Doro exerts his will via incest, forced breeding, or murder?"
This book could be seen as the arc of a horrible relationship
The concept of an enclave of people with supernatural powers was a cool one, and I can appreciate the idea of its not being a cozy place where everybody is happy and gets along in an "it's us against the world" way. Didn't enjoy it, though. Despite that, I'm interested in seeing what the future brings for this world, though I'm in no great hurry to find out.
I've had bristly relationships with books before, and this one was worse than most. Charismatic strongmen can be utter garbage tier bags full of dicks toward those under their thumbs. Yep, got it. "But wait! Are you sure you don't want to hear about another incident where Doro exerts his will via incest, forced breeding, or murder?"
This book could be seen as the arc of a horrible relationship
The concept of an enclave of people with supernatural powers was a cool one, and I can appreciate the idea of its not being a cozy place where everybody is happy and gets along in an "it's us against the world" way. Didn't enjoy it, though. Despite that, I'm interested in seeing what the future brings for this world, though I'm in no great hurry to find out.
December 8, 2016
This review is going to be hard, because Octavia Butler has a big reputation in the sci-fi world, and given that fact I had started this book in the series. But unfortunately this book was a huge disappointment, also I don't get as to how can I call this book sci-fi because although there were many people in this book with X-Men like abilities, but without a coherent story I just did not get the point of throwing them together.
The book has basically has two main characters with some side characters thrown together with them, but I did not get the motivation of the lead characters as to why they were doing the things they were doing.
One character keeps on making blunders one after another and other deals with its consequences, and the same pattern is repeated throughout the book, and add with it tons of mind numbing dialogue.
Also there were some time jumps in the book which I clearly failed to get.
The biggest drawback for me is the story which just seems a concoction without having any structure to it, and events just keeping without any connection to one another.
I give this book 2/5 stars.
The book has basically has two main characters with some side characters thrown together with them, but I did not get the motivation of the lead characters as to why they were doing the things they were doing.
One character keeps on making blunders one after another and other deals with its consequences, and the same pattern is repeated throughout the book, and add with it tons of mind numbing dialogue.
Also there were some time jumps in the book which I clearly failed to get.
The biggest drawback for me is the story which just seems a concoction without having any structure to it, and events just keeping without any connection to one another.
I give this book 2/5 stars.
May 1, 2008
My first foray into the unique world of Octavia Butler's imagination does not disappoint. Terrify, yes, and fascinate in an almost grotesque way, but it's oh so worth it. It is also a good example of speculative fiction and what you can do with it.
For over three thousand years Doro has wandered the Earth, gathering together those born special, with latent potential or abilities, usually mental, that can endanger themselves or others. Born human, Doro died during his own "transition" as a boy, yet cannot be killed. He is a kind of spirit, a demon it seems to me, inhabiting one body after another. He kills effortlessly and usually without a care. Because he is not the body he inhabits, he is impossible to kill. And he is lonely. Part of his aim in collecting these people is to create someone who will stay with him, or a community of them. He breeds them, and they worship him like a god. (Imagine the poor misfits of Obernewtyn brought together for such purposes... isn't it horrible?)
In 1690 he is in Africa, collecting slaves with special abilities, when he senses the presence of a Wild Seed: a person with great ability who has known too much freedom. He tracks down Anyanwu, a beautiful woman who is immortal and over three hundred years old: she never ages unless she wills it, for she has complete control over her body. She can heal herself of almost anything, and can change her body completely into any animal or bird. Doro sees great potential in her, and by threatening her descendents and promising her long-lived children, gets her to willingly accompany him back to one of his settlements in New York.
It does not take her long to understand Doro's nature, and resist where she can. His one demand is obedience, and Anyanwu is not ready to die. His breeding program is almost as scary as Doro himself. Do you remember the character Vincent from Collateral? Cold, calm, ruthless, determined, single-minded, manipulative, implacable, threatening. That's Doro, except he's worse. He's been "alive" so long his humanity is almost entirely gone. He reminds me of what commonly terrifies us most: the idea of "never". The universe never ends. This computer I am using will never biodegrade, but will always be here, in one way or another (this is my big fear, scarier than the certainty of death to me). Humans will never stop fighting, will never agree. Doro can never be killed, can never be stopped, can never be diverted from his purpose. And because of this, he "uses" people, thinking of them only in terms of the children they can produce if mated together, even incestuously, and when they have outlived their "usefulness", he takes their body, maybe even gets more children from them while inhabiting it. Sometimes the special abilities drive a person mad, but all Doro cares about, really, is what potentially great children he can get from them. Still, "his people" are well cared for, the slaves are free, and he protects them all - mostly because he is so possessive and considers them his property far more absolutely than the slave owners, for example.
You can look at Doro and Anyanwu another way: he is manufacturing, unnatural, forceful, going against nature, while Anyanwu is highly attuned to the natural world, creating medicine and food from natural products (plants etc.), and living as a bird, as a dolphin. She can change her body so completely that she can become an old white man, and father children. Perhaps this seems unnatural, but if you think about it, she possesses all of what nature is capable of, whereas Doro can really only bring an end to life, even as he seeks to create the ultimate companion. Creation and Destruction - it's a bit black-and-white, a bit obvious, but the comparison is there to be made.
Considering how long this book has been out, it has way too many typos and other errors. At times words are doubled-up, or whole sentences and paragraphs repeated, which gets confusing. The prose, though, is deft and mostly descriptive, allowing the story to tell itself. However, especially in regards to the main characters, I often felt distant, like I was not given a decent chance to understand them. I'm not sure how well you could understand them, but I guess I was surprised at how little Anyanwu changed over the centuries, while Doro's 2nd transition, if it could be called that, happens a little too suddenly. And I never really, truly understood why Doro was doing all this. Mostly I felt thrown off track by a thought Doro has that implies he is building a kind of army of genetically-manipulated super-people, who will be no match for the weaker, ordinary humans. But this was never followed through, so maybe I read too much into it.
For over three thousand years Doro has wandered the Earth, gathering together those born special, with latent potential or abilities, usually mental, that can endanger themselves or others. Born human, Doro died during his own "transition" as a boy, yet cannot be killed. He is a kind of spirit, a demon it seems to me, inhabiting one body after another. He kills effortlessly and usually without a care. Because he is not the body he inhabits, he is impossible to kill. And he is lonely. Part of his aim in collecting these people is to create someone who will stay with him, or a community of them. He breeds them, and they worship him like a god. (Imagine the poor misfits of Obernewtyn brought together for such purposes... isn't it horrible?)
In 1690 he is in Africa, collecting slaves with special abilities, when he senses the presence of a Wild Seed: a person with great ability who has known too much freedom. He tracks down Anyanwu, a beautiful woman who is immortal and over three hundred years old: she never ages unless she wills it, for she has complete control over her body. She can heal herself of almost anything, and can change her body completely into any animal or bird. Doro sees great potential in her, and by threatening her descendents and promising her long-lived children, gets her to willingly accompany him back to one of his settlements in New York.
It does not take her long to understand Doro's nature, and resist where she can. His one demand is obedience, and Anyanwu is not ready to die. His breeding program is almost as scary as Doro himself. Do you remember the character Vincent from Collateral? Cold, calm, ruthless, determined, single-minded, manipulative, implacable, threatening. That's Doro, except he's worse. He's been "alive" so long his humanity is almost entirely gone. He reminds me of what commonly terrifies us most: the idea of "never". The universe never ends. This computer I am using will never biodegrade, but will always be here, in one way or another (this is my big fear, scarier than the certainty of death to me). Humans will never stop fighting, will never agree. Doro can never be killed, can never be stopped, can never be diverted from his purpose. And because of this, he "uses" people, thinking of them only in terms of the children they can produce if mated together, even incestuously, and when they have outlived their "usefulness", he takes their body, maybe even gets more children from them while inhabiting it. Sometimes the special abilities drive a person mad, but all Doro cares about, really, is what potentially great children he can get from them. Still, "his people" are well cared for, the slaves are free, and he protects them all - mostly because he is so possessive and considers them his property far more absolutely than the slave owners, for example.
You can look at Doro and Anyanwu another way: he is manufacturing, unnatural, forceful, going against nature, while Anyanwu is highly attuned to the natural world, creating medicine and food from natural products (plants etc.), and living as a bird, as a dolphin. She can change her body so completely that she can become an old white man, and father children. Perhaps this seems unnatural, but if you think about it, she possesses all of what nature is capable of, whereas Doro can really only bring an end to life, even as he seeks to create the ultimate companion. Creation and Destruction - it's a bit black-and-white, a bit obvious, but the comparison is there to be made.
Considering how long this book has been out, it has way too many typos and other errors. At times words are doubled-up, or whole sentences and paragraphs repeated, which gets confusing. The prose, though, is deft and mostly descriptive, allowing the story to tell itself. However, especially in regards to the main characters, I often felt distant, like I was not given a decent chance to understand them. I'm not sure how well you could understand them, but I guess I was surprised at how little Anyanwu changed over the centuries, while Doro's 2nd transition, if it could be called that, happens a little too suddenly. And I never really, truly understood why Doro was doing all this. Mostly I felt thrown off track by a thought Doro has that implies he is building a kind of army of genetically-manipulated super-people, who will be no match for the weaker, ordinary humans. But this was never followed through, so maybe I read too much into it.
February 18, 2016
4.5 stars. How do I even begin to review this? I'm going to have to think on this for a few days. If you have Kindle Unlimited, do yourself a favor and read/listen to this book. If you don't, just buy it. Doro, a man who steals the bodies of others and uses the until he must find another or he feels he deserves the body of another person, finds Anyanwu in the African forests living alone on the fringes of a village as a old medicine woman. While searching for one of his lost groups of people, people who were likely taken and sold into slavery, Anyanwu’s power pulls him toward her. This aged woman reveals herself to be a young healer with strength that could crush a grown man who has roamed the world for over 300 years, but her lifetime is still a drop in time compared to his own lifespan.
Anyanwu agrees to leave the safety of her home to help Doro forge a bloodline of children who have special abilities and share their immortality in a world where loneliness and boredom are the enemies of people like them. While her agreement is made in order to save her own bloodline from him, part of her wonders if there could truly be a time when she would no longer have to watch her children die. This book follows Doro and Anyanwu from Africa during the early years of the American slave trades to the end of slavery as love, fight, hate, and dream about everything from the ethical issues of true workings of Doro’s breeding plan to their feelings about each other.
It’s hard to pin this book down to just one thing. It’s science-fiction mixed with historical fantasy add a little romance and a generous helping of social issues (racism, gender issues, ethical issues). Even describing it like that, I don’t think I’ve capture the essence of this book. This books takes so many conventional ideas and presents them in such an unconventional way as Butler uses words to weave this tale that can really take her readers on an emotional roller coaster. I love a good light, quick, fun speculative read, but there’s nothing like speculative fiction that uses the medium to really transcend expectations of the genre. Butler managed that this with book.
Dion Graham was such a powerful, amazing narrator choice for this book. The emotion and voices that he used for the characters captured me as much as the words did themselves. Butler’s characters were already so powerful. I love characters that can really shake me to my core. There was nothing simple about any of them. Even the ones you hated had this part of them that you still recognized as human, and Butler was able to convey so much of their humanity in less words than many author’s use to get you to care about characters in books twice this size. These characters combined with Graham’s narration was fantastic. I’m hoping that he’ll be narrating the other books in this series.
Despite all the ugliness in this book, it was counteracted with so much beauty. I had one minor complaint with a transition later in the book. It seemed a little hurried as Butler tried to wrap up the story, but I did like what it transitioned into.This was my first read by Octavia Butler, and it took me so long to read her because others had told me she could be a heavy read. And while I expected something amazing, something that would probably affect me on a profound level given how many people I know read her books and praise how she touched on issues, I hadn’t expected the incongruous beauty that waited for me or the feelings and thoughts that was this book.
Anyanwu agrees to leave the safety of her home to help Doro forge a bloodline of children who have special abilities and share their immortality in a world where loneliness and boredom are the enemies of people like them. While her agreement is made in order to save her own bloodline from him, part of her wonders if there could truly be a time when she would no longer have to watch her children die. This book follows Doro and Anyanwu from Africa during the early years of the American slave trades to the end of slavery as love, fight, hate, and dream about everything from the ethical issues of true workings of Doro’s breeding plan to their feelings about each other.
It’s hard to pin this book down to just one thing. It’s science-fiction mixed with historical fantasy add a little romance and a generous helping of social issues (racism, gender issues, ethical issues). Even describing it like that, I don’t think I’ve capture the essence of this book. This books takes so many conventional ideas and presents them in such an unconventional way as Butler uses words to weave this tale that can really take her readers on an emotional roller coaster. I love a good light, quick, fun speculative read, but there’s nothing like speculative fiction that uses the medium to really transcend expectations of the genre. Butler managed that this with book.
Dion Graham was such a powerful, amazing narrator choice for this book. The emotion and voices that he used for the characters captured me as much as the words did themselves. Butler’s characters were already so powerful. I love characters that can really shake me to my core. There was nothing simple about any of them. Even the ones you hated had this part of them that you still recognized as human, and Butler was able to convey so much of their humanity in less words than many author’s use to get you to care about characters in books twice this size. These characters combined with Graham’s narration was fantastic. I’m hoping that he’ll be narrating the other books in this series.
Despite all the ugliness in this book, it was counteracted with so much beauty. I had one minor complaint with a transition later in the book. It seemed a little hurried as Butler tried to wrap up the story, but I did like what it transitioned into.This was my first read by Octavia Butler, and it took me so long to read her because others had told me she could be a heavy read. And while I expected something amazing, something that would probably affect me on a profound level given how many people I know read her books and praise how she touched on issues, I hadn’t expected the incongruous beauty that waited for me or the feelings and thoughts that was this book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 3,277 reviews