What do you think?
Rate this book
Book Girl: A Journey through the Treasures and Transforming Power of a Reading Life
When you hear a riveting story, does it thrill your heart and stir your soul? Do you hunger for truth and goodness? Do you secretly relate to Belle's delight in the library in Beauty and the Beast?
If so, you may be on your way to being a book girl.
Books were always Sarah Clarkson's delight. Raised in the company of the lively Anne of Green Gables, the brave Pevensie children of Narnia, and the wise Austen heroines, she discovered reading early on as a daily gift, a way of encountering the world in all its wonder. But what she came to realize as an adult was just how powerfully books had shaped her as a woman to live a story within that world, to be a lifelong learner, to grasp hope in struggle, and to create and act with courage.
She's convinced that books can do the same for you.
Join Sarah in exploring the reading life as a gift and an adventure, one meant to enrich, broaden, and delight you in each season of your life as a woman. In Book Girl, you'll discover:
how reading can strengthen your spiritual life and deepen your faith, why a journey through classic literature might be just what you need (and where to begin), how stories form your sense of identity, how Sarah's parents raised her to be a reader--and what you can do to cultivate a love of reading in the growing readers around you, and 20+ annotated book lists, including some old favorites and many new discoveries.
Whether you've long considered yourself a reader or have dreams of becoming one, Book Girl will draw you into the life-giving journey of becoming a woman who reads and lives well.
If so, you may be on your way to being a book girl.
Books were always Sarah Clarkson's delight. Raised in the company of the lively Anne of Green Gables, the brave Pevensie children of Narnia, and the wise Austen heroines, she discovered reading early on as a daily gift, a way of encountering the world in all its wonder. But what she came to realize as an adult was just how powerfully books had shaped her as a woman to live a story within that world, to be a lifelong learner, to grasp hope in struggle, and to create and act with courage.
She's convinced that books can do the same for you.
Join Sarah in exploring the reading life as a gift and an adventure, one meant to enrich, broaden, and delight you in each season of your life as a woman. In Book Girl, you'll discover:
how reading can strengthen your spiritual life and deepen your faith, why a journey through classic literature might be just what you need (and where to begin), how stories form your sense of identity, how Sarah's parents raised her to be a reader--and what you can do to cultivate a love of reading in the growing readers around you, and 20+ annotated book lists, including some old favorites and many new discoveries.
Whether you've long considered yourself a reader or have dreams of becoming one, Book Girl will draw you into the life-giving journey of becoming a woman who reads and lives well.
288 pages, Paperback
First published September 4, 2018
About the author
Sarah Clarkson
10 books1,121 followersSarah Clarkson is an author, a blogger, and a student of theology. She graduated from Wycliffe Hall, in Oxford, with a bachelor's degree in theology and is currently at work on a Master's degree in modern doctrine. She's the author of Read for the Heart (a guide to children's literature), Caught Up in a Story (on the formative power of story), and The Lifegiving Home (on the gift of creating a place of belonging), as well as the upcoming Book Girl (a woman's guide to the reading life). Through blogs, books, and her current research, she explores the theological significance of story, the intersection of theology and imagination, and the formative power of beauty. She writes regularly about her adventures at SarahClarkson.com and is at slow work on a novel. She can often be found with a cup of good coffee in one of the many quaint corners amid Oxford's "dreaming spires," where she lives in a red-doored cottage with her husband, Thomas, and daughter, Lilian.
You can also connect with Sarah on Facebook and Instagram.
You can also connect with Sarah on Facebook and Instagram.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 762 reviews
July 25, 2021
I’m not familiar with this author. So, I’m not sure if she’s always so religious in her writing or not. 🤷🏼♀️ This was just something I picked up from the library based upon the title. I liked the notes about becoming an insightful reader. 🤔 While I’d never be one to highlight or write in a book, keeping a separate notebook on hand and jotting down things I liked or want to remember is a great thing. 🤗 I also 100% agree, that the best of friends I’ve made through life is through book clubs and sharing the love of books. 🥰📚That aside, it’s definitely a religious type book- mentioning bible verses, reading and memorizing scripture, etc throughout. It’s also a bit preachy about being “well read”. I don’t feel like I’m missing out on anything by not reading or enjoying Shakespeare… but that’s just my opinion. 😉
Shelved as 'unable-to-finish'
November 13, 2019After reading a few pages I realized this is a book with a focus on Christian spirituality and deepening your faith through reading a narrow list of white European/American writers. I wish it had been more clearly labeled. Not for me - back to the library.
September 8, 2018
I immensely enjoyed certain parts of this book and didn’t love a few other parts. Overall it was an enjoyable read and will be a reference books for years to come! I added over 100 titles to a new Goodreads list I started (you can go see it as “book girl recommendations” and there are dozens of books on that list I’m really excited to read (and several that I know I should read at some point)! I would rate this book higher, but I disagree with most of her theological/Christian recommendations. We clearly hold to different theological beliefs, some of them major. And as a Christian book, this heavily affects my ability to recommend this book. But if you read it with that in mind and take all recommendations with a grain of salt, then it is an excellent reference for finding new (and old) books to read!
October 1, 2018
I don’t review a lot of non-fiction books on my blog, but when I saw there was a book about books, the reading life and bookworms, I knew I needed to read and share it! This book is not only a wonderful read, but an amazing resource, filled with book lists for different seasons of a reader’s life!
In Book Girl: A Journey Through the Treasures and Transforming Power of a Reading Life by Sarah Clarkson, Clarkson begins each section with a little essay of her own, and then proceeds to give us some book lists that correspond with the essay. I learned a lot from Ms. Clarkson’s essays and found them very relatable. Ms. Clarkson argues that reading shapes who we are and it’s the lens through which we view the world. She talks of stories helping us to understand things better in real life; they help show us what is good and give us hope to fight and cope with the evil in the world. Ultimately, she says that our lives are a story as a part of the Kingdom of God. I couldn’t agree more with her arguments for how important reading and stories are!
I personally have such a passion for Story. Ms. Clarkson talks all about the exact reason why my blog is named Faery Tales Are Real, arguing for the importance of fairy tales and how they point us to the greatest Story of Christianity. I love how she found connections between fairy tales and Biblical narrative. I just felt through reading this book that I had found a kindred spirit, as the author talks about Anne from Anne of Green Gables and how she loves the Lord of the Rings (can I get an Amen). The Lord of the Rings helped strengthen her faith when she was younger, in the same way that it did for me.
I highly recommend this book to any person who loves reading, no matter what stage of the reading journey they are in. It is an excellent resource to have on hand (the book lists are amazing)!
Content: This is a clean read. The only content is: mentions rape when describing To Kill a Mockingbird; word damn is used.
Rating: I give this book 5 stars!
Genre: Christian non-fiction
I want to thank Tyndale Momentum, Tyndale House Publishers and Sarah Clarkson for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
In Book Girl: A Journey Through the Treasures and Transforming Power of a Reading Life by Sarah Clarkson, Clarkson begins each section with a little essay of her own, and then proceeds to give us some book lists that correspond with the essay. I learned a lot from Ms. Clarkson’s essays and found them very relatable. Ms. Clarkson argues that reading shapes who we are and it’s the lens through which we view the world. She talks of stories helping us to understand things better in real life; they help show us what is good and give us hope to fight and cope with the evil in the world. Ultimately, she says that our lives are a story as a part of the Kingdom of God. I couldn’t agree more with her arguments for how important reading and stories are!
I personally have such a passion for Story. Ms. Clarkson talks all about the exact reason why my blog is named Faery Tales Are Real, arguing for the importance of fairy tales and how they point us to the greatest Story of Christianity. I love how she found connections between fairy tales and Biblical narrative. I just felt through reading this book that I had found a kindred spirit, as the author talks about Anne from Anne of Green Gables and how she loves the Lord of the Rings (can I get an Amen). The Lord of the Rings helped strengthen her faith when she was younger, in the same way that it did for me.
I highly recommend this book to any person who loves reading, no matter what stage of the reading journey they are in. It is an excellent resource to have on hand (the book lists are amazing)!
Content: This is a clean read. The only content is: mentions rape when describing To Kill a Mockingbird; word damn is used.
Rating: I give this book 5 stars!
Genre: Christian non-fiction
I want to thank Tyndale Momentum, Tyndale House Publishers and Sarah Clarkson for the complimentary copy of this book for review. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I express in this review are my own. This is in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s CFR 16, Part 255.
December 10, 2018
"To be a book girl is to take up membership in the ranks of women who read and, by their reading, live to the brave and courageous full."
I wanted to love this book. I wanted this book to be about the celebration of books and the love of books that we share. But what it felt like, for me, was mostly convincing me that I should love books. (Even though I think only a true book girl would pick up a book entitled "Book Girl.") And even more, convincing me what books I should love.
I don't know that the author intended it to feel that way, though, because many times she offered the idea that we should love what we read and read what we love. However, she then contradicted that thought by saying we should be "intelligent readers." And spent quite a few chapters explaining what "intelligent reading" is and is not.
Basically, I am a very unintelligent reader. (Or at least by her terms I am.) Even though I consider myself a very diverse reader. Once that was established (because I don't pick books to read the author believes I should), then it felt a bit condescending. No, I am not an Oxford person and she is, but I don't believe that because I pick less "difficult" or "arduous" books to read that it means that I'm an unintelligent reader. Yes, I believe in being a discerning reader, but to me that means I should read all different view points while holding strong to my values and belief system. I believe in challenging myself, but not to the point of hating what I'm reading or THAT I'm reading. And in all honesty, if I subjected myself to some of the books that she so highly recommends (I'm looking at you Dante), then I could truly come to begrudge reading.
The majority of the chapters in the book read like Pinterest pins or blog posts of book lists that fit a certain category. Nothing wrong with the books listed, but I only connected with about 10% of the books in the lists. And being that she harped on "intelligent reading" so much, it was shocking how few books were by diverse authors or about diverse characters. I mean, how do you write a chapter on the best poetry books and not include Maya Angelou? (But I do love the Anne books and the Lord of the Rings trilogy just as much as the author does!)
All that to be said, I ultimately just don't think the book was for me. (I very much preferred I'd Rather Be Reading by Anne Bogel.) Clarkson and I have very different reading tastes. I, however, do not believe that either one is right or wrong. I do think a LOT of readers will find a kindred spirit here, just not me.
I wanted to love this book. I wanted this book to be about the celebration of books and the love of books that we share. But what it felt like, for me, was mostly convincing me that I should love books. (Even though I think only a true book girl would pick up a book entitled "Book Girl.") And even more, convincing me what books I should love.
I don't know that the author intended it to feel that way, though, because many times she offered the idea that we should love what we read and read what we love. However, she then contradicted that thought by saying we should be "intelligent readers." And spent quite a few chapters explaining what "intelligent reading" is and is not.
Basically, I am a very unintelligent reader. (Or at least by her terms I am.) Even though I consider myself a very diverse reader. Once that was established (because I don't pick books to read the author believes I should), then it felt a bit condescending. No, I am not an Oxford person and she is, but I don't believe that because I pick less "difficult" or "arduous" books to read that it means that I'm an unintelligent reader. Yes, I believe in being a discerning reader, but to me that means I should read all different view points while holding strong to my values and belief system. I believe in challenging myself, but not to the point of hating what I'm reading or THAT I'm reading. And in all honesty, if I subjected myself to some of the books that she so highly recommends (I'm looking at you Dante), then I could truly come to begrudge reading.
The majority of the chapters in the book read like Pinterest pins or blog posts of book lists that fit a certain category. Nothing wrong with the books listed, but I only connected with about 10% of the books in the lists. And being that she harped on "intelligent reading" so much, it was shocking how few books were by diverse authors or about diverse characters. I mean, how do you write a chapter on the best poetry books and not include Maya Angelou? (But I do love the Anne books and the Lord of the Rings trilogy just as much as the author does!)
All that to be said, I ultimately just don't think the book was for me. (I very much preferred I'd Rather Be Reading by Anne Bogel.) Clarkson and I have very different reading tastes. I, however, do not believe that either one is right or wrong. I do think a LOT of readers will find a kindred spirit here, just not me.
November 3, 2020
Me: If I were to write a book about books, I would include all my favourite Manga, contemporaries, young adult and LGBTQ reads.
(And not include the classics or the world's greatest books. Because everyone knows that list by now.
Of course, I have read and loved a few classics and such books. And I will keep reading such recommended reads.)
I enjoyed this book. It's well written but sometimes I just couldn't help feeling why the chapters were so long. But it's still okay. It's a memoir. I liked it nevertheless.
For me, this book got a bit intimidating at times and as much as I was into the lists and favourite lists and recommended readings, I feel like the lists are just too limited. But the author seems really open-minded and I liked the fact that she talked about her reading life and reading tastes in terms of one's own preferences. I just wish there weren't a lot of chapters on religious or faith kind of reading recommendations and book summaries.
It's my own problem getting intimidated by the list of books in this one because it sounds like I have read nothing much in my life.
But it's okay. Our tastes and choices are different. And I will still choose my own kind of reads. I have accepted the fact a long time ago that reading is not a competition. And not to get intimidated by anything that is subjective when it comes to reading and books. Yes, it's subjective.
I really appreciate the parts in this particular book when the author talks about being someone who has similar struggles with the rest of the readers everywhere and how she deals with it.
At some parts, she's so similar with the reader me at how she's grateful to her reader life. I can totally get her whenever she says something about how books shaped her life and how reading changed her life.
But I just had to skip some chapters which seemed repetitive and do not see much difference between these similar chapters. But yes, I do take the recommendations seriously.
I liked this one while reading it.
But my most favourite book about books so far is "I'd Rather Be Reading" by Anne Bogel.
I would love your recommendations too.
(And not include the classics or the world's greatest books. Because everyone knows that list by now.
Of course, I have read and loved a few classics and such books. And I will keep reading such recommended reads.)
I enjoyed this book. It's well written but sometimes I just couldn't help feeling why the chapters were so long. But it's still okay. It's a memoir. I liked it nevertheless.
For me, this book got a bit intimidating at times and as much as I was into the lists and favourite lists and recommended readings, I feel like the lists are just too limited. But the author seems really open-minded and I liked the fact that she talked about her reading life and reading tastes in terms of one's own preferences. I just wish there weren't a lot of chapters on religious or faith kind of reading recommendations and book summaries.
It's my own problem getting intimidated by the list of books in this one because it sounds like I have read nothing much in my life.
But it's okay. Our tastes and choices are different. And I will still choose my own kind of reads. I have accepted the fact a long time ago that reading is not a competition. And not to get intimidated by anything that is subjective when it comes to reading and books. Yes, it's subjective.
I really appreciate the parts in this particular book when the author talks about being someone who has similar struggles with the rest of the readers everywhere and how she deals with it.
At some parts, she's so similar with the reader me at how she's grateful to her reader life. I can totally get her whenever she says something about how books shaped her life and how reading changed her life.
But I just had to skip some chapters which seemed repetitive and do not see much difference between these similar chapters. But yes, I do take the recommendations seriously.
I liked this one while reading it.
But my most favourite book about books so far is "I'd Rather Be Reading" by Anne Bogel.
I would love your recommendations too.
December 11, 2018
I LOVED this book!
Book Girl is an amazing book-on-books, probably the best I've ever read. Sarah Clarkson, as a young woman, wife,( and new mother poised to transform her own daughter into a "book girl"), and Oxford theology graduate, writes extremely well on a subject that is truly dear to her heart as well as her readers. She is perceptive, discerning and having grown up with books from birth is exceedingly well read. I had to suspend reading my library copy, return it and buy one for myself, so I may highlight and notate; in fact, digest this book slowly!
The book is broken into lovely Books Can.... chapters and subchapters, interspersed with recommended reading lists of her personal friends and family. There are the perennial favorite classic titles along with newer book mentions, that will be added to my TBR list.
Highly recommended!
Book Girl is an amazing book-on-books, probably the best I've ever read. Sarah Clarkson, as a young woman, wife,( and new mother poised to transform her own daughter into a "book girl"), and Oxford theology graduate, writes extremely well on a subject that is truly dear to her heart as well as her readers. She is perceptive, discerning and having grown up with books from birth is exceedingly well read. I had to suspend reading my library copy, return it and buy one for myself, so I may highlight and notate; in fact, digest this book slowly!
The book is broken into lovely Books Can.... chapters and subchapters, interspersed with recommended reading lists of her personal friends and family. There are the perennial favorite classic titles along with newer book mentions, that will be added to my TBR list.
Highly recommended!
October 31, 2018
Sarah Clarkson speaks to me. In both the books I’ve read from her (Caught Up in a Story and this), it’s like someone has looked into my head and described my experiences to me with a greater emotional understanding than I had heretofore had for myself. In both instances, her books have come to me at opportune moments, when my life was in flux, with me standing at a crossroads of sort. I read this one after a significant move—and, just as significantly, after several years of struggling with the motivation to read. Her ode to words and stories and her loving lists of great books—so many of which I’ve already read—has reinvigorated the reader in me. I don’t think it’s too much to say that her first book changed my life; this one did too.
March 6, 2019
Book Girl, or Christian Woman Wants You* to Read Classics** Written by White People about White People***
*only if you’re also a woman
**including those written by her and her mother
***and hobbits
*only if you’re also a woman
**including those written by her and her mother
***and hobbits
December 31, 2018
too christian and author tells you she went to Oxford approximately 1 zillion times
January 20, 2022
As I read this book I kept thinking, "I wish I could have read this in my late teens/early twenties." But books come to you when they're meant to enter your life & I'm glad this book entered my life! While I've become a reader in my 30s, I still struggle a bit with what to read. This book has so encouraged me to read the really good books from the past (although the author does have some recently published recommendations.) I know my reading life will be changed because of these lists.
I listened to this book as a re-read in 2021. The narrator did a great job. I’m glad I own this copy because I frequently wanted to pick it up to remember the books/authors mentioned. I still love the book as I did when it first came to me in 2018.
Reread 2022. I am moving my rating up to 5 stars because I know more of these books now. I feel like I had a good chat with a kindred spirit as I listened to this on walks and as I did household chores. Lovely!
I listened to this book as a re-read in 2021. The narrator did a great job. I’m glad I own this copy because I frequently wanted to pick it up to remember the books/authors mentioned. I still love the book as I did when it first came to me in 2018.
Reread 2022. I am moving my rating up to 5 stars because I know more of these books now. I feel like I had a good chat with a kindred spirit as I listened to this on walks and as I did household chores. Lovely!
January 2, 2019
I'm going with 3 stars for this one.
I received this book for review a few months ago, and to be honest, I wanted to give up on it after the first few chapters. I was a little worried when I requested this book from the publisher because of my previous experience with Sarah Clarkson's writing in my attempt at The Life-Giving Home. Her writing has come off stilted and pretentious to me in the past. I had hopes that this book (about books! one of my favorite subjects) would be one I would enjoy, but I was almost immediately bogged down in that same pretentious tone. I liked a lot of what she had to say, but her writing style is just not for me.
I snagged the audiobook because I was not getting anywhere in print, and her writing came across much more relatable and friendly with the narrator's voice. Overall, while listening, I enjoyed it. Most of the book was composed of recommended booklists, with thoughts on reading and personal stories in between. I liked hearing her book recommendations, as well as her thoughts on the reading life and the benefits that can come from reading good books.
However, I won't be adding all of these books to my to-read list (even if I did have time to read them all). I could tell from her interjections and the actual book recommendations that we are not on the same pages theologically. I wouldn't trust all her non-fiction recommendations, but I am interested to check out a few of the fiction books she referenced.
The book also lost half a star for the constant references to Oxford. I'm sure studying at Oxford was a cool experience and formative for Clarkson (if something can be "formative" at 30 years old), but it was starting to feel awkward, like name-dropping (except with a place instead of a person). The "place-dropping" just added to my problems with the writing style.
Overall, would I say this book is worth reading? Sure, go for it if you want. Not everyone will mind her style, and she did have some good recommendations (but take some of what she recommends regarding Christianity with discernment). I'll keep this one on my shelf as a reference for when I want to add a meaningful fiction book to my reading list. However, I think I can pretty confidently say this is the last book I'll be reading by Sarah Clarkson. I've read enough of her writing at this point to be able to say it's not my cup of tea.
Note: I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
I received this book for review a few months ago, and to be honest, I wanted to give up on it after the first few chapters. I was a little worried when I requested this book from the publisher because of my previous experience with Sarah Clarkson's writing in my attempt at The Life-Giving Home. Her writing has come off stilted and pretentious to me in the past. I had hopes that this book (about books! one of my favorite subjects) would be one I would enjoy, but I was almost immediately bogged down in that same pretentious tone. I liked a lot of what she had to say, but her writing style is just not for me.
I snagged the audiobook because I was not getting anywhere in print, and her writing came across much more relatable and friendly with the narrator's voice. Overall, while listening, I enjoyed it. Most of the book was composed of recommended booklists, with thoughts on reading and personal stories in between. I liked hearing her book recommendations, as well as her thoughts on the reading life and the benefits that can come from reading good books.
However, I won't be adding all of these books to my to-read list (even if I did have time to read them all). I could tell from her interjections and the actual book recommendations that we are not on the same pages theologically. I wouldn't trust all her non-fiction recommendations, but I am interested to check out a few of the fiction books she referenced.
The book also lost half a star for the constant references to Oxford. I'm sure studying at Oxford was a cool experience and formative for Clarkson (if something can be "formative" at 30 years old), but it was starting to feel awkward, like name-dropping (except with a place instead of a person). The "place-dropping" just added to my problems with the writing style.
Overall, would I say this book is worth reading? Sure, go for it if you want. Not everyone will mind her style, and she did have some good recommendations (but take some of what she recommends regarding Christianity with discernment). I'll keep this one on my shelf as a reference for when I want to add a meaningful fiction book to my reading list. However, I think I can pretty confidently say this is the last book I'll be reading by Sarah Clarkson. I've read enough of her writing at this point to be able to say it's not my cup of tea.
Note: I received a copy of this book for free from the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
March 31, 2023
I enjoyed this even more than some book recommendation type books (I honestly always enjoy them) I appreciated the unique categories and the personal essays in each section. I also appreciated that each book that was recommended was given a full, detailed description with personal antidotes often included. Although many, many of the books I’ve already read it was enjoyable to read why she choose each one and was helpful in deciding which ones I still wanted to add to my TBR.
February 5, 2022
This book has been on my radar ever since it came out. So glad I finally borrowed it from a friend (actually I gave it as a present) and then borrowed it back. lol. I need it for my own reference book though,
“A woman who reads is a woman who knows she must act: in courage, in creativity, in kindness, and often in defiance of the darkness around her. She understands that life itself is a story and that she has the power to shape her corner of the drama.”
I felt like Sarah was my personal coach/mentor- guiding me through the lense of reading and books worthy of being read. This is a book about books. And yes my TBR grew and I also noted a lot of authors she mentioned are already on my TBR list. It was in some sense a balm to my soul- I'm on the right track. Sarah, I feel like, is more philosophical (theological) than I will ever be- and because of this it was so eye opening and refreshing to see how she gets glimpses of truth and goodness in everything she reads- regardless of author or genre.
Her book is divided in sections of books that will do this you:
* Broaden your word
* Shape your story
* Still you to action
* Cultivate your imagination
* Foster community
* Open your eyes to wonder
* Deepen your soul
* Impart hope
" A book girl is one who has looked through imagined eyes vastly differences from her own so that her view of the world is broad and bright with countless varied perspectives. But a savvy book girl also knows that she who walks with the wise becomes wise, and the view points she inhabits imagination will shape the woman she becomes.”
“A woman who reads is a woman who knows she must act: in courage, in creativity, in kindness, and often in defiance of the darkness around her. She understands that life itself is a story and that she has the power to shape her corner of the drama.”
I felt like Sarah was my personal coach/mentor- guiding me through the lense of reading and books worthy of being read. This is a book about books. And yes my TBR grew and I also noted a lot of authors she mentioned are already on my TBR list. It was in some sense a balm to my soul- I'm on the right track. Sarah, I feel like, is more philosophical (theological) than I will ever be- and because of this it was so eye opening and refreshing to see how she gets glimpses of truth and goodness in everything she reads- regardless of author or genre.
Her book is divided in sections of books that will do this you:
* Broaden your word
* Shape your story
* Still you to action
* Cultivate your imagination
* Foster community
* Open your eyes to wonder
* Deepen your soul
* Impart hope
" A book girl is one who has looked through imagined eyes vastly differences from her own so that her view of the world is broad and bright with countless varied perspectives. But a savvy book girl also knows that she who walks with the wise becomes wise, and the view points she inhabits imagination will shape the woman she becomes.”
December 28, 2018
DEVOURED this book! Cheers to Sarah Clarkson who truly is a kindred spirit! I found myself resisting the urge to mark this book and then about 25 pages in, I grabbed a pencil and went back to the beginning and marked away! This is so well written and such an encouragement for those of us who love books and I hope, motivating for those who have yet to discover their inner “book girl”. So many excellent quotes, book suggestions to mention. I wish that I could sit and chat with Sarah for a bit. We have many things in common but notable differences in Faith, I disagree with her stance on HP but we share many many favorites for all the right reasons. Perfect gift for yourself or any person in pursuit of the good, the true and the beautiful (all of us!). This is just what our culture needs!
October 13, 2019
This was a sweet book. Books mean the world to me, and it’s wonderful to see that same love written out on the page for the world to see. Reading recommendations are among my favorite things, whether I’m giving or receiving them. I loved the lists provided by this book, and that fact that the author explained what each book meant to her, as well as why she had crafted these lists regarding particular topics. I believe that stories are one of the ways God speaks to us the most deeply, and that same mindset very obviously went into the crafting of this book. However, I do have to say that I enjoyed the front half of this book, heavy on fiction, more than I did the back half, which concentrated more on poetry and spiritual nonfiction. This is purely a matter of taste, as my reading life is comprised predominantly of fiction.I would recommend this book to anyone who is sentimental about the very act of reading, especially if you share the author’s Judeo-Christian worldview as it is very prevalent in her writing.
December 31, 2018
I can't finish it. I wanted to like it. The author is very impressed with herself and reminds the reader over and over that she's Oxford educated and blahhhhhh.... she's made me not even care enough to finish this review.
January 19, 2019
You were made to be a learner.
Book Girl was a joyous, head-nodding, affirming, geek-inducing read. As she wrote about the books that formed her, memories cascaded over me: where I read My Name Is Asher Lev, the grief I wore like a sweater while reading Cry, the Beloved Country, or the mountain curve that accompanied Sissy Spacek's narration of To Kill a Mockingbird.
We both have been nourished by a glorious alphabet of authors: Austen, Berry, Cather, Dickens, Eliot, Fitzgerald, Goudge, Hugo, Ishiguro, J.R.R. Tolkien, Keller, C.S. Lewis, Marilynne, Nesbit, O'Brien, Gene Stratton Porter...
If our interests were identical, comparing lists could become a listless bore. Sarah's theology recommendations reflect her Anglican faith and Oxford training, referencing many authors I don't know. My own book-about-books would suggest more gems on history, travel, music, gardening, and food.
Geek-inducing? For sheer pleasure, I counted the books and poems Sarah mentioned directly in book lists or indirectly in epigraphs and such [389]. Unscientific, I counted series, chronicles, and sagas as one. I tallied which titles I had read [207]; the number of books Sarah recommended which occupy my shelves, as yet unread [23]; and the titles that were already on my TBR (to be read) list on Goodreads or my Wish List at Paperbackswap before I read this book [21]. Kindred, much?
Whenever I read a book by a living author, I keep in the back of my mind The Dinner Question. I ask myself, "Would I want to have [author's name] to my house one evening for dinner and conversation?" This doesn't at all mean 'do we agree on most things?' Could I imagine asking her more about herself or could I envision discussing the book in greater depth? The Dinner Answer is an unqualified Yes! I'm afraid if that happened, our husbands would be reduced to silence while we interrupted each other with wild exclamations of wonder and delight.
Book Girl was a joyous, head-nodding, affirming, geek-inducing read. As she wrote about the books that formed her, memories cascaded over me: where I read My Name Is Asher Lev, the grief I wore like a sweater while reading Cry, the Beloved Country, or the mountain curve that accompanied Sissy Spacek's narration of To Kill a Mockingbird.
We both have been nourished by a glorious alphabet of authors: Austen, Berry, Cather, Dickens, Eliot, Fitzgerald, Goudge, Hugo, Ishiguro, J.R.R. Tolkien, Keller, C.S. Lewis, Marilynne, Nesbit, O'Brien, Gene Stratton Porter...
If our interests were identical, comparing lists could become a listless bore. Sarah's theology recommendations reflect her Anglican faith and Oxford training, referencing many authors I don't know. My own book-about-books would suggest more gems on history, travel, music, gardening, and food.
Geek-inducing? For sheer pleasure, I counted the books and poems Sarah mentioned directly in book lists or indirectly in epigraphs and such [389]. Unscientific, I counted series, chronicles, and sagas as one. I tallied which titles I had read [207]; the number of books Sarah recommended which occupy my shelves, as yet unread [23]; and the titles that were already on my TBR (to be read) list on Goodreads or my Wish List at Paperbackswap before I read this book [21]. Kindred, much?
Whenever I read a book by a living author, I keep in the back of my mind The Dinner Question. I ask myself, "Would I want to have [author's name] to my house one evening for dinner and conversation?" This doesn't at all mean 'do we agree on most things?' Could I imagine asking her more about herself or could I envision discussing the book in greater depth? The Dinner Answer is an unqualified Yes! I'm afraid if that happened, our husbands would be reduced to silence while we interrupted each other with wild exclamations of wonder and delight.
October 20, 2018
“Emma has been meaning to read more ever since she was twelve years old. I have seen a great many lists of her drawing up at various times of books that she meant to read regularly through–and very good lists they were–very well chosen and very neatly arranged–sometimes alphabetically and sometimes by some other rule. The list she drew up when only fourteen–I remember thinking it did her judgement so much credit that I preserved it some time; and I dare say she may have made out a very good list now. But I have done with expecting any course of steady reading from Emma. She will never submit to anything requiring industry and patience and a subjection of the fancy to the understanding.”
Mr. Knightley discussing Emma’s faults with Mrs. Weston, who will not admit them
Emma, volume 1, chapter 5
Books about books have exploded on the market recently. It seems to be an obsession among the bookish types - this is at least the 4th I've read personally, with Read-Aloud Family being the most useful. But at the end of the day, it's just a book of book lists. I feel like Book Girl is just capitalizing on the trend rather than adding something new and valuable to the collection.
Sarah Clarkson spends the first chapters waxing poetic about the reading life - "becoming a book girl" or a "bookish person" before launching into her collection of lists. And yet, I assume, anyone who would even grab this book is already convinced of the value of frequent reading. Also this is just a personal quirk but the more I read of the Clarksons (both Sally and Sarah), the more their excessively descriptive vocabulary bugs me. While there are times that torrents of explanation serve a purpose, there are other times that it comes across that the author appreciates the sound of her own voice...
Book Girl gets a few stars from me for a handful of solid book suggestions. But I can't give it many for the reasons listed above.
Mr. Knightley discussing Emma’s faults with Mrs. Weston, who will not admit them
Emma, volume 1, chapter 5
Books about books have exploded on the market recently. It seems to be an obsession among the bookish types - this is at least the 4th I've read personally, with Read-Aloud Family being the most useful. But at the end of the day, it's just a book of book lists. I feel like Book Girl is just capitalizing on the trend rather than adding something new and valuable to the collection.
Sarah Clarkson spends the first chapters waxing poetic about the reading life - "becoming a book girl" or a "bookish person" before launching into her collection of lists. And yet, I assume, anyone who would even grab this book is already convinced of the value of frequent reading. Also this is just a personal quirk but the more I read of the Clarksons (both Sally and Sarah), the more their excessively descriptive vocabulary bugs me. While there are times that torrents of explanation serve a purpose, there are other times that it comes across that the author appreciates the sound of her own voice...
Book Girl gets a few stars from me for a handful of solid book suggestions. But I can't give it many for the reasons listed above.
December 19, 2018
Non-fiction/Book love. This is the BEST book I have read about the love and importance of reading life. While I am autodidactic by nature (so I loved all the lists!), it was more than that. Mrs. Clarkson voices so many of the feelings in my heart regarding how reading has contributed to my salvation (in multiple ways). It is important people understanding she is a Christian and discusses how her reading added to how she walks her Christian life, overcomes struggles, questions the world as we know it, and celebrates the imagination. She states, "Next to Scripture and the influence of my parents, great books have formed my worldview, developed my moral imagination, and shaped my idea of virtue."
For those who have ever questioned the place fantasy and imagination have in your Christian walk, she answers this well. "A great book meets you in the narrative motion of your own life, showing you in vividly imagined ways exactly what it looks like to be evil or good, brave or cowardly, each of those choices shaping the happy (or tragic) ending of the stories in which they're made." She clearly loves classic literature and holds a special fondness for C.S. Lewis, J.R.R Tolkien, L.M. Montgomery, and Wendell Berry. The timelessness of so many of their stories speaks to their wisdom and ability to touch readers of all ages and backgrounds--so powerful! This book articulates how reading and sharing books helps us form our lives, find inspiration and faith, as well as create community (Hello, CFD!). Plus, who could resist a book that celebrates book girls?!? Absolutely loved this!
For those who have ever questioned the place fantasy and imagination have in your Christian walk, she answers this well. "A great book meets you in the narrative motion of your own life, showing you in vividly imagined ways exactly what it looks like to be evil or good, brave or cowardly, each of those choices shaping the happy (or tragic) ending of the stories in which they're made." She clearly loves classic literature and holds a special fondness for C.S. Lewis, J.R.R Tolkien, L.M. Montgomery, and Wendell Berry. The timelessness of so many of their stories speaks to their wisdom and ability to touch readers of all ages and backgrounds--so powerful! This book articulates how reading and sharing books helps us form our lives, find inspiration and faith, as well as create community (Hello, CFD!). Plus, who could resist a book that celebrates book girls?!? Absolutely loved this!
August 30, 2018
Like many book bloggers, reading is one of my biggest hobbies. Talking about my latest read or your favorite book is one of my favorite pastimes. Book Girl by Sarah Clarkson is all about her love of books and reading.
In Book Girl, Sarah Clarkson starts about by sharing how she got her love of reading and books. She then shares how books have shaped her life and how she created book lists. She then shares some of her book list categories: books that broaden your world, books can shape your story, books can stir you to action, books can cultivate imagination, books can foster community, books can open your eyes to wonder, books can deepen your soul, and books can impart hope. In each of these sections, Clarkson shares books that can affect readers in ways related to each section. She shares about the books that she has found to be helpful in each of these areas and why she recommends them. She closes Book Girl with the importance of passing books and the love of reading to those coming behind us and to those around us.
Clarkson's passion for books comes through in Book Girl. As someone who shares her love of reading and books, I enjoyed this book. It is a keeper for me and one I will refer to again. I found some new titles to add to my reading list and I appreciated the fact that some of my favorites were also some of her favorites. It was like getting together with another bookish friend and gushing over books together. I would recommend this book to all other book lover girls out there.
I received this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review.
In Book Girl, Sarah Clarkson starts about by sharing how she got her love of reading and books. She then shares how books have shaped her life and how she created book lists. She then shares some of her book list categories: books that broaden your world, books can shape your story, books can stir you to action, books can cultivate imagination, books can foster community, books can open your eyes to wonder, books can deepen your soul, and books can impart hope. In each of these sections, Clarkson shares books that can affect readers in ways related to each section. She shares about the books that she has found to be helpful in each of these areas and why she recommends them. She closes Book Girl with the importance of passing books and the love of reading to those coming behind us and to those around us.
Clarkson's passion for books comes through in Book Girl. As someone who shares her love of reading and books, I enjoyed this book. It is a keeper for me and one I will refer to again. I found some new titles to add to my reading list and I appreciated the fact that some of my favorites were also some of her favorites. It was like getting together with another bookish friend and gushing over books together. I would recommend this book to all other book lover girls out there.
I received this book from the publisher. I was not required to write a positive review.
October 1, 2020
3.25/5
This was a cool book, but I wasn't expecting it to be so focused on classics. I was hoping for some modern gems that I haven't heard of before (since this is basically a book of recommendations), but I've heard of almost all of the books mentioned (outside of the theology sections...and I just skimmed for the most part because they sounded so boring tbh). Also, I got this vibe that the author thought that her favorites are superior to any other books. Of course I understand it's pretty much a book about her favorites, but people have different opinions and are any books really objectively the best?
I wasn't a huge fan of the writing style. It sounded very formal and intellectual, if that makes sense? Well-written, but sometimes a pain to read. I had to push through to get past certain sections. While this book about books has a neat concept, I thought it lacked in a few areas. I'd probably only recommend it to Christian moms (who aren't readers) looking for books for their kids. And even then, I think it'd be smarter to just search some book lists on the internet. 🤷
I did like the sections about how reading affects your faith! I loved hearing her thoughts on escapism and the benefits of reading for your spiritual and mental health.
Honestly, I think this book would've been much better as a memoir only.
This was a cool book, but I wasn't expecting it to be so focused on classics. I was hoping for some modern gems that I haven't heard of before (since this is basically a book of recommendations), but I've heard of almost all of the books mentioned (outside of the theology sections...and I just skimmed for the most part because they sounded so boring tbh). Also, I got this vibe that the author thought that her favorites are superior to any other books. Of course I understand it's pretty much a book about her favorites, but people have different opinions and are any books really objectively the best?
I wasn't a huge fan of the writing style. It sounded very formal and intellectual, if that makes sense? Well-written, but sometimes a pain to read. I had to push through to get past certain sections. While this book about books has a neat concept, I thought it lacked in a few areas. I'd probably only recommend it to Christian moms (who aren't readers) looking for books for their kids. And even then, I think it'd be smarter to just search some book lists on the internet. 🤷
I did like the sections about how reading affects your faith! I loved hearing her thoughts on escapism and the benefits of reading for your spiritual and mental health.
Honestly, I think this book would've been much better as a memoir only.
March 24, 2019
This book is such a disappointment to me. The tag line for this book is “A journey through the treasures and transforming power of a reading life.” I expected a book about reading and how reading can enrich your life. And this book only just reaches that mark.
The author talks about reading widely and reading great books that “if you read every title in this book, you’d have a rich exposure to some of the best writers around.” The problem I have with this is that there is very little about Clarkson’s recommendations that I would consider wide. Her “if you only read these books” lists includes: Austen, Eliot, Dickens, Lewis, Tolkien, and Tolstoy. That’s six out of twelve books that were written by white European writers before 1950. There is not one book mentioned in the entire book (not just on the “must read” list) that is a primary account of a person of color, no book from an LGBTQ perspective. I mean I also love Anne of Green Gables and Jane Austen and Narnia. I do. But there are other books out there that also tell stories of character who inhabit the diverse word we really live in.
Take my advice and give this book a hard pass.
The author talks about reading widely and reading great books that “if you read every title in this book, you’d have a rich exposure to some of the best writers around.” The problem I have with this is that there is very little about Clarkson’s recommendations that I would consider wide. Her “if you only read these books” lists includes: Austen, Eliot, Dickens, Lewis, Tolkien, and Tolstoy. That’s six out of twelve books that were written by white European writers before 1950. There is not one book mentioned in the entire book (not just on the “must read” list) that is a primary account of a person of color, no book from an LGBTQ perspective. I mean I also love Anne of Green Gables and Jane Austen and Narnia. I do. But there are other books out there that also tell stories of character who inhabit the diverse word we really live in.
Take my advice and give this book a hard pass.
September 6, 2018
This book is a treasure. Not only did it stir my own creativity and desire to read, it directed me toward new troves. I experienced resonance with much of what Clarkson wrote, and feel that she is a friend in my own reading life. Book Girl is incredibly quotable and immersive, and I'll soon be making a Goodreads shelf of recommended authors and books that I want to read (first up: Hans Urs Von Balthasar).
My one quibble is that there is little attempt to include a wide swathe of global literature and non-Western writers (I haven't counted the authors she mentions, but I only remember a few writers that weren't from Europe/North America). While I understand that this was written from Clarkson's own reading life and personal experiences, it's a disappointment that her reading lists don't include a broader body of literature, given the reading life she's had. There's also no acknowledgement of why her lists are so limited. However, this inspires me to create my own lists of books that have been formative in shaping my worldview: the book girl work carries on.
My one quibble is that there is little attempt to include a wide swathe of global literature and non-Western writers (I haven't counted the authors she mentions, but I only remember a few writers that weren't from Europe/North America). While I understand that this was written from Clarkson's own reading life and personal experiences, it's a disappointment that her reading lists don't include a broader body of literature, given the reading life she's had. There's also no acknowledgement of why her lists are so limited. However, this inspires me to create my own lists of books that have been formative in shaping my worldview: the book girl work carries on.
January 28, 2021
This is such a lovely book for anyone who has ever loved a book, and anyone who has ever wondered if there were other people who loved books as much as they did. (This is not something that most of the book blogosphere wonders, methinks, but it was something I was wondering when I read it for the first time a couple of years ago).
It's composed of essays about being a "book girl", with book lists that go along with the essays. Both the lists and essays are delightfully cozy, and bring you into the author's world. The book lists are obviously highly individual to her, but it was so fun for me to have a window into her reading life, to see where our reading had overlapped, and to find new books to look forward to!
One caveat: I'm not sure why I thought it was a good idea to read a book full of book recommendations when I was already being slowly smothered by my TBR, but...there's almost twenty more books on my TBR now. (Good books, though, by all appearances. XD) So: let the reader be warned.
Four stars!
It's composed of essays about being a "book girl", with book lists that go along with the essays. Both the lists and essays are delightfully cozy, and bring you into the author's world. The book lists are obviously highly individual to her, but it was so fun for me to have a window into her reading life, to see where our reading had overlapped, and to find new books to look forward to!
One caveat: I'm not sure why I thought it was a good idea to read a book full of book recommendations when I was already being slowly smothered by my TBR, but...there's almost twenty more books on my TBR now. (Good books, though, by all appearances. XD) So: let the reader be warned.
Four stars!
January 27, 2019
This book feels as though it was for me and to me. I want to improve my reading life. I want to remember what I have read. I want to be able to tell someone my favorite books. I want to know and begin to understand better quality writing. Sarah Clarkson's focus in this book does all of these things and more. She offers book lists from people she respects as readers and friends, she makes me feel comfortable and okay with where I am in my reading and this book will gently guide me to better reading. Between this book and Anne Bogel's Book Club I look forward to this year being my year of better reading.
October 14, 2019
The title of this book and even the cover seem to hint at a very light hearted look at the reading life. It was my trust in the Clarkson family that urged me to read it.
Instead of a frivolous look at books - it is a very serious argument for the reading life with an extremely worthwhile reading list. Reading the books suggested in this book would provide a deep and well-rounded classical education.
Excellent book that I highly recommend. I had listened to this on Audible but will be purchasing a hardcopy of it for my library.
Instead of a frivolous look at books - it is a very serious argument for the reading life with an extremely worthwhile reading list. Reading the books suggested in this book would provide a deep and well-rounded classical education.
Excellent book that I highly recommend. I had listened to this on Audible but will be purchasing a hardcopy of it for my library.
August 5, 2018
I LOVED this book. Sarah Clarkson is such a treasure. My full review will be posted at Englewood Review of Books within the next few weeks.
December 5, 2018
Got about halfway through then skimmed the rest. I usually enjoy books about books, but not this one.
December 30, 2022
I am kind of surprised by how much I liked this. Sarah’s words really resonated with me though, and I LOVED all of the book suggestions that were given. I liked how the book was organized, and I found it a delight to loose myself amongst the theme based chapters and unique book lists.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 762 reviews