What do you think?
Rate this book
183 pages, Hardcover
First published January 1, 2005
"Sometimes it seemed that time dragged, and others it seemed that it was moving quickly."
• I love the Kiesha’ra world. I always will. Even if the world-building is mostly through telling, and we see little of it, the universe and shapeshifters are all so intriguing. This universe is obviously well thought out, and intricate. Just not presented to the reader in an interesting fashion.
• This book is readable, as always. I didn’t get through it as quickly as the others, but the prose is simple and easy to follow along. Falcondance is short and fast. Unfortunately, that’s also a failing, which I'll get into later.
• Hai and Darien, I'm just...in love. I'm in love with all of these characters, actually. I love how all their stories are woven together and the connections between them. They're all so tragic, too, my poor heart.
• The Ecl is cool, if not explained as well as I would have wanted it to be. It's basically limbo from Inception.
• The weaknesses of the previous book in the series are present in this one, as well, and probably even more noticeable. Snakecharm had some weird pacing and a meandering plot, which I hoped would be a fluke. It was not. It’s a little better in Falcondance, and started off stronger with the appearance of Nicias’ magic, and it picked up near the end, but for most of the book it was incredibly slow. Surprising, since not much was gone into detail.
• I've started to realize that AAR seriously struggles with description, especially when it comes to characters. Every author has their weaknesses and that’s fine, but it’s so noticeable in this book that half the time, I didn’t even know where the characters were. The chapter where Lily and Nicias arrive to the Ahnmik, all it says is that they landed on a “marble terrace.” Where? Is it a castle? Are they high up? What does it look like? Too bad, you're gonna have to guess.
And that’s only with the scenery. For characters, we get hair color and eye color, at most. We sometimes get skin color if we’re lucky. When we do, a lot of the characters are coded as white, which is very strange when this universe, and all the shapeshifters, have their roots in Egyptian myth. Plus with the all-powerful falcons being white just...idk man, doesn't sit well with me!
• Speaking of characters, they all had the same voices. They talked in the same way, and had no real discernible personalities. I think only Darien and Hai really stood out. Darien in her desire for vengeance and Hai in her bitterness. They were interesting characters. And while Nicias was the MC...idk. I didn't dislike him, but he was so simple. His defining trait is his loyalty, and there doesn't seem to be much else to him. I didn't see him have any character development, because he always seemed the type to sacrifice himself for the greater good, and he was the same by the end.
• The telling is mainly why this book turned into a slog. Here is the plot structure of Falcondance.
Character: I'm sure you have a lot of questions.
Nicias: Asks all those questions.
Character: Answers with long, in-depth explanation.
That's it. That's most of the book. I get the necessity of it because the information has to be delivered somehow, but there are things that were only described through dialogue that would have been cool to see actually written out. Like the streets! I have a serious love for sentient cities, especially malevolent ones, so the street trickery would have been great to see more of.
• Falcondance started to pick up at the end, but it soon turned into an anticlimax, and a confusing one at that.
And after that, everything wraps up so neatly. Which leads me into...
• AAR's characters rarely run into obstacles that cannot be overcome through some plot contrivance. Everything works out well, and the only strings left loose are the sequel hooks for the series to continue.
• Remember when I mentioned that the short length was one of its weaknesses? Yeah. This would have been so much better handled if there was room to expand upon it. I feel like a part of the reason there was so much telling and not enough showing was because there wasn't enough room to show everything. And by the time interesting things rolled around, they were wrapped up so quickly there was barely enough time to take them in.
• The falcons are so cool...as ideas. We don't really get to see much of their culture, as it's only described through dialogue. And it's impossible to feel connections to any of them because they're so static. This is intentional, of course; the falcons worship the god of stillness. But that makes it difficult to care as much about them as other characters.
• There is so much more but that's the main problems I had. The magic was also vague, and as stated in one of my updates, I didn't get Nicias' reasoning for not telling Oliza the truth.